I’ll take a heavy, solid brass faucet with a reliable ceramic disc any day. Chrome might not win any style awards, but it’s so much easier to keep looking decent, and it just lasts.
Couldn’t agree more about the longevity of chrome and solid brass. I’ve specified a few “statement” fixtures for clients—matte black, brushed gold, you name it—and almost every time, maintenance becomes an issue within a year or two. The finishes scratch or spot, and the internal parts just aren’t built for the long haul. Out of curiosity, has anyone found a finish that actually holds up as well as chrome in a real-world setting? I keep hoping there’s something out there that balances durability and aesthetics, but I haven’t seen it yet...
Honestly, you’re not alone—chrome just seems to take the daily abuse so much better. I’ve tried oil-rubbed bronze and even that “PVD” coating everyone raves about, but after a few years of tenants or families using them, it’s always the same story. I get the appeal of those trendy finishes, but in the real world? Chrome and solid brass are still king. Maybe someday someone will crack the code...
I get the appeal of those trendy finishes, but in the real world? Chrome and solid brass are still king.
Yeah, I hear you. I’ve swapped out more “designer” faucets than I care to admit. Tenants just don’t baby these things, and honestly, neither do most homeowners. Chrome’s boring but it holds up. Brass is solid but gets pricey fast. I keep hoping someone will invent a finish that actually survives rental turnover, but until then, it’s chrome for me too.
I keep hoping someone will invent a finish that actually survives rental turnover, but until then, it’s chrome for me too.
Honestly, same here. I tried matte black once—looked sharp for about six months, then started chipping and showing water spots everywhere. Chrome’s not exciting, but at least it doesn’t make me regret my choices every turnover.
Chrome’s not exciting, but at least it doesn’t make me regret my choices every turnover.
I get where you’re coming from—chrome is the safe bet, especially for rentals. But have you looked into PVD finishes at all? They’re supposed to be a lot more durable than standard powder coat or paint, and some manufacturers are offering them in black, brass, even brushed nickel. I’ve specified a few for higher-traffic spaces and so far, they seem to hold up better against scratches and water spots. Not perfect, but definitely less maintenance than the matte black stuff.
That said, I do wonder if the extra cost is justified for most rentals. Sometimes it feels like no finish can really survive tenants who treat fixtures like gym equipment... Anyone had luck with stainless steel? It’s not as flashy as black, but I’ve seen it outlast chrome in some commercial installs.
