Custom homes discussions and local services.

 
Discussion options
Discussion options
[#561]

How much does your house design actually help with the weather?

I moved into this older brick house last year, and honestly, I never really thought about how much the design would affect my comfort. Turns out, those thick walls keep it way cooler in the summer than my last place (which was all glass and metal, looked cool but felt like an oven). In winter, it’s not as drafty either. I guess there’s a reason people built houses like this around here?

I’m starting to think maybe modern designs don’t always fit the local climate as well as the old ones did. Anyone else notice this? Or maybe I’m just getting old and cranky about energy bills...


Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

181 replies

Title: How Much Does Your House Design Actually Help With The Weather?

You’re not imagining things - those old brick houses really do have a leg up when it comes to passive temperature control. Thick masonry acts like thermal mass, soaking up heat during the day and releasing it slowly, which keeps things more stable inside. Newer builds often skip that in favor of looks or cheaper materials, and yeah, you can feel the difference in your wallet. Not saying all modern designs are bad, but sometimes the old ways just work better for the local climate.


Reply

Not saying all modern designs are bad, but sometimes the old ways just work better for the local climate.

I get where you’re coming from - there’s something about those old brick homes that just feels solid, right? But I think modern design gets a bit of a bad rap here. There’s a lot more going on than just “cheaper materials” or chasing looks. For example, newer builds can use advanced insulation, triple-glazed windows, and even smart ventilation systems that old brick never had. I’ve seen some contemporary houses that stay super comfy year-round with barely any heating or cooling.

Honestly, it’s not always about thick walls. Sometimes it’s about orientation, shading, or even landscaping. I worked on a project where we used lightweight materials but designed deep overhangs and planted deciduous trees - kept things cool in summer and let the sun in during winter. It’s kind of like mixing old wisdom with new tech.

Don’t get me wrong, I love a good brick wall as much as anyone. But there’s more than one way to beat the weather... and sometimes the new stuff really does work if you use it right.


Reply

Definitely agree that it’s not all about thick walls or heavy materials. I built my place a few years back and went with SIP panels for the walls - honestly, the insulation is next level compared to the old farmhouse I grew up in. Doesn’t matter if it’s freezing or roasting outside, it stays pretty steady in here.

But I do think there’s something to be said for how those old homes “breathe” a bit more. My folks’ house never had mold or weird damp spots, even though it was drafty as heck. Now you gotta be careful with all the sealing and insulation - if you don’t get the ventilation right, you end up with stale air or worse.

I’m a fan of mixing things up. Use the new tech where it makes sense, but don’t ignore the stuff that’s worked for generations. Deep eaves, smart window placement, trees for shade… all that still matters, maybe even more than what your walls are made of.


Reply
bearknitter Topic starter

TITLE: HOW MUCH DOES YOUR HOUSE DESIGN ACTUALLY HELP WITH THE WEATHER?

That’s spot on about mixing old and new ideas. I’ve seen projects where just orienting the house right - like, windows facing the right direction for sun or wind - makes a bigger difference than fancy materials. Trees and overhangs are underrated, honestly.

- Old brick or stone: great thermal mass, but can be cold if not insulated right
- Modern insulation: huge energy savings, but needs proper airflow
- Shading and window placement: still makes or breaks comfort

I’ve noticed people get caught up in “modern = better,” but sometimes it’s just about using what works for your spot. My own place has deep eaves and cross-ventilation, and it’s way more comfortable than some of the newer builds I’ve worked on. Energy bills don’t lie...


Reply

“Trees and overhangs are underrated, honestly.”

Couldn’t agree more. My last place had zero shade, and even with top-notch insulation, it baked in summer. Swapped to a house with big old maples and deep eaves, and it’s night and day. Sometimes the “fancy” stuff just can’t beat smart, simple design. Funny how some new builds ignore the basics and end up with higher bills and less comfort.


Reply

Title: How Much Does Your House Design Actually Help With The Weather?

I’ve noticed the same thing. My first apartment was a top-floor unit with no trees around and barely any overhangs. Even with blackout curtains and running the AC, it felt like living in an oven half the year. I used to dread the electric bill every summer.

When I finally bought a place, I specifically looked for mature trees and a decent roof overhang. It wasn’t the fanciest house on the block, but honestly, my cooling costs dropped by about a third. The shade from just two big oaks makes a bigger difference than any “smart” thermostat or fancy window film I tried before. Plus, the house just feels more comfortable - less of that harsh glare and heat radiating off everything.

I get why builders focus on insulation and tech upgrades, but sometimes it feels like they skip the basics. Trees take time to grow, sure, but even just planning for them or adding some simple awnings can pay off. Not everything has to be high-tech or expensive to work.

Funny thing is, I used to think landscaping was just about looks. Now I see it as a legit investment in comfort and lower bills. If I ever move again, mature shade is going to be at the top of my checklist, right up there with insulation and window quality.


Reply

It’s wild how much a couple of trees or a well-placed overhang can change the whole vibe inside. I always tell folks, you can throw all the insulation and gadgets at a house, but if the sun’s beating straight in, you’re fighting an uphill battle. Ever notice how older homes almost always have those big porches or deep eaves? There’s a reason for that… sometimes the old-school tricks just work better than the latest app-controlled gizmo. Curious - did you ever try planting new trees yourself, or was it all about finding a place with mature ones already there?


Reply

Title: How much does your house design actually help with the weather?

- Gotta say, I’m all for those classic design moves - porches, deep eaves, big shade trees. They’re timeless for a reason.
- But I wouldn’t write off the “gadgets” side of things just yet. Some of the newer tech, like low-e glass or smart venting, can make a huge difference if you use them right.
- I’ve built homes where we couldn’t rely on mature trees (new developments, bare lots), so we had to get creative. Overhangs and orientation help, but pairing that with modern insulation and automated shades? That’s next-level comfort.
- Planted a few trees myself at my own place. Takes patience, but it’s worth it down the line. In the meantime, you can do a lot with pergolas or even temporary shade sails.
- Honestly, it’s not either/or. The best results usually come from mixing old-school wisdom with new-school tech. Sometimes you gotta fight the sun with every tool in the box... not just the ones that look good on a porch.


Reply

I’ll tell you, I used to think a good old-fashioned porch and some big trees were all you needed, but after sweating through a few summers in my last place, I changed my tune. Here’s what actually helped: first, deep eaves for shade (no brainer), then I added reflective film to the windows - game changer. Next step was sealing up every drafty spot I could find. Last year I tried out those motorized shades inside... didn’t expect much, but wow, the living room stayed way cooler. Honestly, it’s like building a weather fortress - layer by layer. Old tricks plus new gadgets, that’s the sweet spot.


Reply

Honestly, it’s like building a weather fortress - layer by layer. Old tricks plus new gadgets, that’s the sweet spot.

Totally get what you mean about layering solutions. I’ve always leaned on the “old tricks” side because, honestly, my budget’s pretty tight. Reflective film and sealing drafts sound doable, but those motorized shades are probably out of my price range for now. Did you notice a big difference just from the film and sealing, or was it the combo with the shades that really made it work?

I’ve been thinking about adding blackout curtains since they’re cheaper - wondering if they’d have a similar effect to the shades you mentioned. Anyone tried both and noticed a real difference? I’m all for a weather fortress, but I need to build mine on the cheap...


Reply

I’ve been thinking about adding blackout curtains since they’re cheaper - wondering if they’d have a similar effect to the shades you mentioned.

Blackout curtains do a decent job blocking light and some heat, but they can’t seal up drafts or reflect radiant heat like film does. If you’re on a budget, I’d prioritize sealing and film first. That’s where you’ll notice the biggest bang for your buck. Curtains are a good add-on, but not a substitute for stopping air leaks.


Reply

Title: How Much Does Your House Design Actually Help With The Weather?

I’ve tried blackout curtains in a couple of rooms, mainly to help with the morning sun blasting in, and they do make a noticeable difference for light and even a bit for heat. But I’ve got to agree - if you’re dealing with drafty windows or older frames, curtains alone won’t cut it. I learned that the hard way during a particularly cold winter; even with thick curtains, I could feel the cold air sneaking in around the edges. Ended up using that clear plastic window film as a stopgap, and honestly, it made a bigger difference than I expected.

One thing I’m still not sure about is how much radiant heat actually gets reflected by those films versus just being slowed down. Some brands claim wild things, but real-world results seem to depend on how well you install them. I’ve seen people use foam weatherstripping too, which is dirt cheap and surprisingly effective for sealing gaps.

If you’re in an older house like mine, the design itself can be a mixed bag. High ceilings help with summer heat but make it harder to keep warm in winter. Overhangs and shade trees are great if you have them, but not everyone does. I sometimes wonder if investing in better insulation or even storm windows would pay off more long-term than just layering up with curtains and films.

Anyway, if you’re on a budget, maybe try combining a few methods - seal up the obvious leaks first, add film if you can stand the look of it (some people hate it), then layer on curtains for extra comfort and aesthetics. It’s rarely one thing that solves everything... more like chipping away at the problem from different angles.


Reply

You’re spot on about layering solutions - no single fix really does it all, especially in older homes. I’ve found that window films can help with radiant heat, but their effectiveness really depends on the type (low-e vs. basic plastic) and how airtight you get the seal. Sometimes the claims on the box are a bit optimistic. Have you looked into adding rigid foam board insulation to attic hatches or crawlspace doors? That made a bigger difference for me than I expected, especially in winter. Curious if anyone’s tried interior storm windows - are they worth the hassle?


Reply

Tried the interior storm windows last winter - honestly, they’re a bit of a pain to install, but I did notice less draft around my old sashes. Not magic, but better than nothing. Rigid foam on the attic hatch made a bigger difference for me too. Window film’s hit or miss... some peeled off by spring.


Reply

Honestly, I’ve seen a lot of folks get frustrated with window film - if it’s not prepped just right, it never seems to last the whole season. The attic hatch is a sneaky culprit for heat loss, so good call beefing that up. Curious, have you looked at your wall insulation or air sealing around outlets? Sometimes those little gaps add up more than people expect.


Reply

Curious, have you looked at your wall insulation or air sealing around outlets? Sometimes those little gaps add up more than people expect.

That’s spot on - those “little gaps” are like the secret agents of heat loss. I’ve torn into plenty of walls thinking, “how bad could it be?” and then found air just whistling through around outlets and light switches. People underestimate how much that stuff adds up over a whole house.

Honestly, window film is kind of a band-aid if the bones of the house aren’t right. If you’re dealing with drafty walls or an attic hatch that’s basically a sieve, no amount of plastic on the windows is gonna save you from high bills. I’m always pushing folks to focus on proper insulation and air sealing first. It’s not as flashy as new windows, but it pays off every winter.

Funny thing - one client insisted on triple-glazed windows but skipped air sealing. Guess what? Still cold by the outlets. Sometimes it’s not about spending more, just spending smarter.


Reply

TITLE: House Design vs. Weather – It’s All in the Details

I’ve lost count of how many times I’ve walked into a “high-efficiency” house and found cold air pouring in behind baseboards or outlets. People love to talk about fancy windows or high-tech thermostats, but honestly, if the basic shell isn’t tight, you’re just throwing money at the symptoms.

One time, I had a client who insisted on radiant floor heat - looked great on paper. But the crawlspace underneath was basically open to the outside. Didn’t matter how much heat you pumped in, it just vanished. We ended up spending more time (and less money) sealing up rim joists and insulating the crawl than anything else. After that, their bills dropped and the place actually felt comfortable for once.

I get why folks want to focus on the big-ticket stuff - it’s more exciting. But it’s usually the boring details like caulk, foam gaskets, and proper attic insulation that make all the difference. It’s not glamorous work, but it’s what keeps your toes warm in January.


Reply

TITLE: HOW MUCH DOES YOUR HOUSE DESIGN ACTUALLY HELP WITH THE WEATHER?

Totally agree about the “boring” details making the biggest difference. I’ve seen people spend a fortune on triple-pane windows, but then skip air sealing around them - kind of defeats the purpose, right? Curious if you’ve found any particular materials or methods that work best for sealing up those tricky spots, like behind outlets or along rim joists? I’m always torn between spray foam and those little pre-cut gaskets...


Reply

- I’ve definitely gone back and forth on this. Here’s what I’ve found after a few budget-friendly renos:

- For outlets, those foam gaskets are cheap and easy - like, you can do a whole house for under $20. They’re not perfect, but honestly, unless you’re in an extreme climate or super picky, they make a noticeable difference for the price.

- Rim joists are trickier. I tried the little batt insulation “stuff and seal” method first (fiberglass + caulk), but it was a pain and didn’t seal as well as I hoped. Ended up using spray foam in a can - messy, but it really does the job if you don’t mind looking like you lost a fight with shaving cream.

- One thing I learned: don’t overthink every single gap. Focus on the big leaks first (attic hatches, basement rim joists, around windows/doors). The tiny stuff adds up, but not as much as you’d think.

- If you’re on a budget like me, prioritize where you’ll get the most bang for your buck... and maybe save the triple-pane windows for your next house.


Reply
Scroll to Top