Custom homes discussions and local services.
Discussion options
Should a proposed WOTUS change affect wetland due diligence?
EPA and the Army have proposed supplemental changes to the Clean Water Act’s “waters of the United States” definition. If finalized, the changes could reduce the wetlands and other waters covered by federal permitting, with comments reportedly due October 9, 2026.
For someone evaluating a future homesite with seasonal ponding, a swale, or other wet-looking areas, would this change how you approach the purchase? I’m wondering whether buyers should still obtain a site-specific wetland delineation and environmental review before relying on any possible reduction in federal coverage.
The proposal isn’t final, and I assume state or local wetland protections could remain broader than federal rules. I’d also be cautious about treating seasonal water or a drainage feature as exempt without a professional determination. How are builders, designers, or buyers factoring this uncertainty into contracts, contingencies, and permitting timelines?
Sources for the current development:
Updated Definition of “Waters of the United States” | 91 FR 57284 | LexFed
New WOTUS Proposal Could Ease CWA Permitting for Development Projects: Comments Due Oct. 9 | Phelps
5 replies
The contract should treat wetland feasibility as independent of the proposed federal change. I’d want the contingency to cover:
1. A site-specific delineation and any needed environmental review.
2. Confirmation of federal, state, and local jurisdiction and approval requirements.
3. Enough time to obtain permits or written agency determinations.
4. The right to cancel and recover the deposit if the site can’t support the intended plans, before the deposit becomes nonrefundable.
That protection matters even if federal coverage is reduced. A state or local program may still regulate the seasonal ponding or swale, and the project could remain constrained by grading, stormwater, access, or other site conditions. The contract should also say that a later rule change doesn’t eliminate the buyer’s feasibility exit or shorten the review period.
I’d tighten the fourth contingency. “Can’t support the intended plans” sounds practical, but it can become a dispute over whether a more expensive redesign technically remains possible.
The exit should identify objective triggers, such as an agency denial, mitigation or off-site credit costs exceeding a stated limit, or failure to obtain the required permits or written determinations by a defined deadline. That also keeps the federal rule change from quietly shifting the feasibility standard after the contract is signed. A site might fall outside federal jurisdiction yet still require state or local approvals, or become uneconomic because of grading, stormwater, or access requirements.
The contingency should also assign responsibility for the delineation itself. I’d spell out:
1. Who selects the qualified consultant, and whether the other party gets a reasonable chance to review that choice.
2. Who pays for the delineation, any follow-up agency review, and needed revisions.
3. Whether the buyer may rely on the consultant’s written report, including its stated limitations, when deciding to exercise the exit right.
4. The deadline for delivering that report before the deposit becomes nonrefundable.
That avoids a later argument that the buyer’s consultant was unacceptable or that the report was only informational and could not support the contractual exit. The agreement should still distinguish the consultant’s site findings from an agency’s formal jurisdictional or permitting decision.
The expected permit-application date matters too. A federal jurisdictional determination made before a final rule may not settle coverage for a later application; its stated validity and the agency’s transition rules could affect whether a fresh review is needed. If federal coverage is critical to the schedule, build in time to confirm that before relying on the determination.
The concern about a swale or seasonal ponding isn’t limited to whether it falls within a wetland boundary. A delineation can help establish jurisdiction, but it doesn’t tell you whether the remaining land can accommodate the house, driveway, grading, and stormwater plan. I’d want the site review to assess those constraints too: a feature outside wetland jurisdiction can still make the intended layout impractical.