Totally get where you're coming from on the fiberglass vs. spray foam thing. I went fiberglass too, and honestly, once you gear up with long sleeves, gloves, and a decent mask, it's not that terrible. Sure, it's itchy as heck for a couple days if you're not careful, but I'd rather deal with that than gamble on spray foam installation issues. Had a buddy who went spray foam and ended up with moisture trapped behind it—total nightmare. Fiberglass might be annoying, but at least it's predictable...
I hear ya on fiberglass being predictable, but honestly, spray foam isn't always the gamble people make it out to be. Had mine done professionally last year and haven't had a single moisture issue yet (knock on wood...). The attic's noticeably cooler in summer too, which is a huge plus. I get the hesitation though—guess it really boils down to finding an installer who knows their stuff.
Good points about spray foam—I've seen it work wonders in some homes, but I've also come across a few horror stories when it's not done right. Curious, did your installer recommend open-cell or closed-cell foam for your attic?
When we had ours done, the installer actually leaned toward open-cell foam for budget reasons—closed-cell was pricier and seemed a bit overkill for our needs. Honestly, I was just thrilled to say goodbye to that itchy nightmare, haha. It's held up pretty well so far, no complaints yet...but yeah, I've heard those horror stories too. Definitely worth double-checking your installer's experience before diving in.
"Honestly, I was just thrilled to say goodbye to that itchy nightmare, haha."
Haha, totally get that relief—fiberglass insulation is the worst. Open-cell foam can definitely be a solid choice, especially if budget's a factor. But I'd also suggest considering your local climate and humidity levels before fully committing. I've seen open-cell foam work wonders in drier climates, but in areas with higher humidity or moisture issues, closed-cell can sometimes be worth the extra cost. It provides a stronger moisture barrier and can help prevent mold or mildew down the line.
Also, you're spot-on about installer experience. I've had clients who went with cheaper installers and ended up with uneven coverage or missed spots—definitely not something you want to deal with later. A good installer makes all the difference, regardless of the foam type you choose. Curious, did your installer mention anything about vapor barriers or ventilation adjustments when switching to foam? Sometimes those details get overlooked...
