Had a similar realization on a recent build. Initially skeptical about foam's ROI, but after seeing how much tighter the envelope was—especially around tricky rooflines—I became a convert. The comfort difference alone made it worth it, never mind the energy savings.
Went through the same thought process myself a few projects back. Always used fiberglass because, well, it's what we've always done. But once I switched to spray foam, especially around complex rooflines and dormers, it was night and day. On one build, we had a tricky cathedral ceiling section that was always drafty no matter how careful we were with fiberglass. Foam solved it instantly—no more callbacks from clients complaining about cold spots or drafts.
That said, foam isn't a magic bullet for every situation. It's pricier upfront, and if your crew isn't familiar with proper application techniques, you can end up with uneven coverage or adhesion issues. Also worth noting: make sure your HVAC contractor knows you're using foam. The tighter envelope might mean downsizing equipment or adjusting ventilation strategies.
Still, overall, the comfort and energy savings typically outweigh the initial costs, especially in complicated layouts. Glad you're seeing similar results.
"Foam solved it instantly—no more callbacks from clients complaining about cold spots or drafts."
Couldn't agree more about spray foam making a huge difference, especially in those tricky spots. Recently had a client with an older home renovation—tons of awkward angles and tight attic spaces. Fiberglass was a nightmare to install properly, and even then, we always had issues with gaps, drafts, and uneven performance. Once we switched to spray foam, the difference was immediately noticeable. The homeowners mentioned their upstairs rooms finally felt comfortable year-round.
But you're right, it's definitely not a one-size-fits-all solution. One thing I've noticed is that foam can make future wiring or plumbing modifications trickier since everything gets locked in place. We've had to carefully plan ahead for electrical runs and any potential upgrades. Also, some clients are hesitant about the environmental impact, so it helps to discuss eco-friendly foam options upfront.
Still, overall, spray foam has been a game changer for comfort and efficiency. Glad others are seeing the benefits too.
Spray foam definitely has its perks, but I've run into some headaches with it too. Had a client recently who wanted to add recessed lighting after we'd already foamed the attic... talk about a nightmare. Ended up having to carefully cut channels through hardened foam—messy and time-consuming. Fiberglass might be itchy and annoying, but at least it's easier to adjust later if plans change. Just something to keep in mind before going all-in on foam.
Yeah, spray foam can be a real double-edged sword. Had a similar issue myself when a homeowner decided they wanted skylights—after we'd already foamed the roof deck. Cutting through that stuff felt like carving through petrified marshmallow... sticky, messy, and frustrating as heck. Fiberglass might be itchy, but at least you're not locked into one layout forever. Still, I gotta admit, the energy savings and airtight seal from foam are pretty hard to beat. I usually just try to get clients to finalize their lighting and electrical plans beforehand, but we all know how often that actually happens...
