Custom homes discussions and local services.

Dealing with itchy pink nightmare in my attic

662 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

Cellulose is decent, but honestly, I'd lean toward spray foam if budget allows. We did cellulose at our old house and yeah, it helped with drafts, but we still had some settling issues after a few years. Spray foam seals everything up tight - no gaps or settling to worry about. Plus, moisture and pests become pretty much non-issues. It's pricier upfront, but long-term comfort and peace of mind are worth it IMO. Just something else to consider before you commit...


Reply

Good points, but a couple things to keep in mind:
- Spray foam is great for sealing, but if you ever need to access wiring or plumbing later, it's a real pain.
- Also, some older homes need to breathe a bit - too tight can sometimes lead to moisture issues elsewhere.
Just something else to weigh before diving in.


Reply

You make some fair points about spray foam. I've seen firsthand how tough it can be when you need to get back in there later. A buddy of mine decided to go full spray foam in his attic - he loved it at first, raved about how cozy and quiet the house felt after. But then, a year down the line, he had a plumbing leak and... well, let's just say he wasn't raving anymore. Took forever to find the leak, and the plumber charged extra just for dealing with the foam mess.

I'm also glad you mentioned older homes needing to breathe. I know sealing everything tight sounds great on paper, but older houses weren't built with that in mind. It's like wrapping an antique piece of furniture in plastic - it might protect it, but it can also trap moisture and cause issues you didn't have before. I've seen some beautiful old homes end up with mold problems because their owners got a little too enthusiastic about sealing every nook and cranny.

That said, fiberglass insulation - the itchy pink nightmare - isn't exactly a joy to deal with either. I get why you're tempted by spray foam. Have you considered blown-in cellulose as an alternative? It's not perfect either, but it's easier to work around if you ever need to access wiring or plumbing later. Plus, it's pretty good at letting the house breathe naturally.

Curious if anyone here has tried cellulose insulation themselves and how it turned out - especially in older homes? Seems like it could be a decent compromise between sealing things up tight and still keeping future maintenance doable.


Reply

I switched to blown-in cellulose about three years ago in my 1920s bungalow. Honestly, installation was pretty straightforward - way less itchy than fiberglass, that's for sure. It's held up well so far, and I've had to get back up there twice since then for wiring updates. Definitely easier to move around and patch up afterward compared to foam. Not a miracle solution, but a decent middle ground if you're worried about future maintenance headaches.


Reply

Good to hear cellulose worked out for you - I’ve been debating between that and foam myself. Did you notice any difference in noise reduction after switching? My attic’s right above the bedroom, so quieter would definitely be a bonus...


Reply

"Did you notice any difference in noise reduction after switching?"

Honestly, I went with foam thinking it'd be a total sound barrier, but the difference wasn't huge... noticeable, yeah, but not night-and-day. If quiet's your main goal, might wanna look into adding some acoustic panels or drywall layers instead.


Reply

Good points there - foam insulation can be a bit misleading when it comes to noise. It helps, sure, but it's not magic. Acoustic panels or drywall layers are definitely solid suggestions. Another thing I've seen work pretty well is sealing up any small gaps or cracks around vents and windows. Sometimes those tiny openings let in more noise than you'd think... Anyway, sounds like you're on the right track!


Reply

"Acoustic panels or drywall layers are definitely solid suggestions."

True, acoustic panels can help, but honestly, I've found that adding mass is usually the most effective route. Had a client once who tried everything - foam, panels, sealing gaps - but the real game changer ended up being a layer of mass-loaded vinyl behind the drywall. Bit pricier upfront, sure, but it knocked down noise way better than anything else we tried. Just something to consider if you're serious about quieting things down...


Reply

I'd agree that mass-loaded vinyl can make a noticeable difference, especially if you're dealing with more stubborn sound issues. Acoustic panels are fine for echo reduction and minor noise, but they're not really built to handle serious soundproofing. Had a similar experience myself - tried panels first, but eventually had to bite the bullet and add extra drywall layers with Green Glue compound. Not cheap either, but it definitely did the trick better than just panels alone...


Reply

"Had a similar experience myself - tried panels first, but eventually had to bite the bullet and add extra drywall layers with Green Glue compound."

Yeah, Green Glue and drywall can definitely help, especially if you're dealing with stubborn noise. But honestly, before going all-in on heavy-duty solutions, I'd suggest checking your attic insulation first. Sometimes just sealing gaps and upgrading to eco-friendly insulation (like cellulose or recycled denim) can make a surprising difference. Plus, it's healthier and less itchy than that pink fiberglass nightmare you've got up there...


Reply

"Sometimes just sealing gaps and upgrading to eco-friendly insulation (like cellulose or recycled denim) can make a surprising difference."

Good point on sealing gaps - it's easy to overlook how much air leakage contributes to noise and temperature issues. I swapped out fiberglass for blown-in cellulose a few years ago, and it was night and day. No more itchy arms, and the house just feels quieter overall. Definitely worth considering before going full drywall-and-glue mode...


Reply

Did you notice any difference in heating or cooling bills after switching to cellulose? I've been considering it for a while, but I'm skeptical if the savings actually justify the upfront cost. Also, curious if anyone's tried recycled denim insulation - does it really perform as well as cellulose, or is it mostly hype? Seems like a trendy option, but I haven't seen much real-world feedback yet...


Reply

Switched a couple clients over to cellulose last year, and their bills did drop noticeably - around 15-20% on average. Denim insulation sounds cool but haven't personally tested its long-term performance. Curious if anyone's done a side-by-side comparison of denim vs. cellulose insulation yet?


Reply

I've heard good things about denim insulation too, but honestly, I'm a bit skeptical about its long-term settling issues. Cellulose has been around forever and we know it holds up pretty well over time. Denim sounds eco-friendly and all, but does it really maintain its R-value after a few years of attic heat and humidity cycles? I'd be interested to see if anyone's tracked performance beyond just the first year or two...


Reply

"Denim sounds eco-friendly and all, but does it really maintain its R-value after a few years of attic heat and humidity cycles?"

Fair point - I haven't seen extensive long-term data either. But from the few projects I've specified denim insulation for, homeowners seem satisfied even after several years. Granted, that's anecdotal and not hard science, but no major settling complaints yet. Still, your skepticism is justified - cellulose has decades of proven track record behind it, so it's definitely the safer bet if longevity is your top priority.


Reply

I put denim insulation in my attic about 5 years ago - mostly to avoid that itchy pink stuff you're talking about. Haven't noticed any major drop-off in comfort or insulation yet, but honestly, who climbs up there regularly to measure R-values...?


Reply

Denim insulation's a good call - had a buddy who did that maybe 7 or 8 years back, and he's still happy. Couple things he mentioned to me though:

- Denim tends to settle a bit more than fiberglass over time, so you might lose some thickness eventually - but probably not enough to notice indoors.
- He also said rodents seemed less interested in nesting in denim compared to fiberglass (no idea why, but that's a plus).
- If you're ever curious about your insulation performance without climbing up there, you could try one of those cheap infrared thermometers on cold nights. Just point it at the ceiling and see if there's any major temp difference from room to room.

Honestly though, if you're comfortable inside and your energy bills aren't creeping up noticeably, I wouldn't worry much about exact R-values either. Sounds like you're doing just fine...


Reply

Denim insulation sounds like a solid choice - definitely better than dealing with that itchy pink stuff. I worked on a project a few years back where we swapped fiberglass for denim, and the homeowners were thrilled. They said it made the attic feel less "industrial" and more comfortable overall.

One thing I noticed was how much quieter their house felt afterward. Denim seems to dampen sound better than fiberglass, which is a nice bonus if you're sensitive to noise. And yeah, rodents didn't seem interested at all - maybe it's the lack of scratchy fibers?

Honestly, don't stress too much about minor settling or exact R-values. Comfort is key, and if your home's cozy and your bills aren't skyrocketing, you're already winning. Plus, there's something oddly satisfying about knowing your old jeans are keeping you warm at night...


Reply

Denim's great stuff - just make sure you cut it with a sharp blade, or you'll feel like you're wrestling with a stubborn pair of jeans all day. Learned that the hard way... But yeah, way better than fiberglass itch!


Reply

Denim insulation definitely has its merits, especially in avoiding the dreaded fiberglass itch, but it's not without drawbacks. From my experience, it can absorb moisture more readily than traditional options, potentially leading to mold issues down the line if your attic isn't properly ventilated. I'd suggest considering rock wool as an alternative - less itchy than fiberglass and handles moisture better than denim. Just something to think about before you commit fully...


Reply
Scroll to Top