Custom homes discussions and local services.

Keeping the critters out: weird but effective tricks?

307 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

Title: Keeping the critters out: weird but effective tricks?

Copper mesh really is the unsung hero, isn’t it? I’ve had similar luck with it in old farmhouses - seems like every time I try something “innovative,” I end up crawling back to the basics. Funny thing, though, I’ve actually had a bit of a debate with a buddy about using copper mesh versus expanding foam. He swears by the foam for sealing gaps, but I’ve seen mice chew right through it. Maybe it depends on the type of critter or just how determined they are.

Pet food’s a big one too. I used to think people were being paranoid about airtight containers, but after finding a stash of kibble under my deck (thanks to some very industrious raccoons), I’m a convert. Now everything’s in bins, and it’s made a world of difference.

One trick I picked up from an old timer was sprinkling peppermint oil around entry points. Supposedly it keeps rodents away, but honestly, results have been hit or miss for me. Maybe it masks the scent trails for a while, but if they’re hungry enough, they’ll push past anything that isn’t physically blocking them.

Has anyone tried those ultrasonic repellents? I keep seeing ads for them, but part of me thinks it’s just snake oil. Would love to hear if they actually work or if it’s just another gadget collecting dust in the garage...

Anyway, curious if there are any other “weird” solutions out there that have actually stood the test of time - or if we’re all just destined to keep patching holes and hoping for the best.


Reply

Title: Keeping the critters out: weird but effective tricks?

Copper mesh is hands-down the winner in my book too. I can’t even count how many times I’ve had to patch up old barns or crawlspaces where someone tried to do it cheap with just foam. Mice treat that stuff like a free buffet - chew right through, no problem. If you want a real seal, it’s gotta be mesh first, then maybe foam as backup for insulation, not as the main barrier.

Pet food in bins is underrated. I’ve seen rats chew through plastic storage tubs if there’s even a whiff of kibble inside. Metal cans or those heavy-duty feed bins work way better.

Peppermint oil… eh, it smells nice but I wouldn’t bet the farm on it. Same deal with those ultrasonic gadgets. Had a client swear they worked, but when we pulled apart his crawlspace, we found droppings right next to the little machine. Not exactly confidence-inspiring.

Weirdest trick I’ve seen actually work? A guy wrapped chicken wire around his deck posts and smeared Vaseline on it to keep squirrels from climbing up. Looked ridiculous but seemed to slow them down for a while... at least until they figured out a workaround. Critters are just stubborn, I guess.


Reply

Copper mesh really is a game changer - totally agree there. I’ve seen so many people try to “pretty up” a space with foam, thinking it’ll do the trick, only to end up with chewed corners and a mess. Mesh first just makes sense, even if it’s not the most glamorous material.

Pet food storage is another thing folks overlook. I once helped stage a home where the owners kept kibble in those cute plastic bins - looked great but, yeah, found a hole chewed right through. Metal might not be as stylish, but it definitely keeps things secure.

The Vaseline and chicken wire combo is hilarious but honestly kind of clever. It’s wild what people come up with when critters get persistent. Even if it’s not perfect, every little bit helps, right? Sometimes you just have to get creative and hope you’re one step ahead... at least for a while.


Reply

Keeping The Critters Out: Weird But Effective Tricks?

Funny how the “cute” solutions almost always backfire. I’ve seen folks spend a fortune on decorative storage, only to end up with a rodent buffet. Copper mesh isn’t pretty, but it’s like Fort Knox for mice. I’ll admit, I’ve tried the peppermint oil trick too - smells nice, but the mice didn’t seem to mind. Sometimes you just have to embrace the ugly fixes if you want real results.


Reply

Copper mesh is a lifesaver, I’ll give you that - looks terrible but it works. I’ve run into folks who swear by ultrasonic repellents, though I can’t say I’ve seen much difference myself. Ever tried those? Curious if anyone’s had luck with the more high-tech gadgets or if it’s just another gimmick. Sometimes the old-school fixes really do outshine the fancy stuff...


Reply

Tried those ultrasonic things a couple years back - honestly, didn’t notice much of a change. Maybe the mice just didn’t care? What’s worked best for me is a combo: copper mesh stuffed in every gap, then a dab of expanding foam to seal it up. Not pretty, but it keeps ‘em out. I do check every few months for new holes, just in case. Sometimes the low-tech route really is the way to go...


Reply

Sometimes the low-tech route really is the way to go...

Totally agree - sometimes all the gadgets in the world can’t beat a little elbow grease and some copper mesh. I tried those ultrasonic things too, and I swear the mice just used them as background music. The only thing that’s really worked for me is blocking every tiny gap I can find, even if it means crawling around with a flashlight at 2am. Not glamorous, but hey, it beats finding mouse droppings in the pantry.


Reply

Title: Keeping the critters out: weird but effective tricks?

- Copper mesh is my go-to too - nothing chews through it, not even the most determined little rodent.
- I know folks swear by steel wool, but I’ve seen mice actually pull that stuff out like they’re redecorating. Copper holds up better in my experience.
- For door gaps, those rubber sweeps do more than folks think. Not fancy, but they close off the “mouse highway” at ground level.
- Peppermint oil? Smells nice, but I’ve watched mice walk right past it like it’s not even there. Maybe it works for some, but I’d never rely on it.
- Found a nest once behind a dishwasher - never underestimate where they’ll squeeze in. Pulled out the whole appliance, sealed up the gap with leftover tile grout and mesh. No more problems since.
- If you’re patching holes in older homes, I always tell people to check attic corners and under sinks too. Sometimes you gotta think like a mouse... and admit defeat when they outsmart you.

Honestly, it’s a battle of patience more than anything. A little creativity (and a lot of crawling around) goes a long way.


Reply

I’m curious - has anyone tried those decorative door sweeps or threshold plates that blend in with the flooring? I’ve seen some that look pretty sleek, but I wonder if they’re as effective as the plain rubber ones. Sometimes I worry about sacrificing function for aesthetics, especially in older homes where gaps aren’t always even. Also, has anyone found a way to seal up radiator pipe holes without making it look like a DIY patch job? That’s always been a tricky spot for me...


Reply

I hear you on the door sweeps - those fancy ones look great, but honestly, I’ve found the plain rubber types seal better, especially with uneven old floors. The decorative ones are nice for a quick fix, but I always end up going back to function over form. For radiator pipe holes, I’ve used escutcheon plates with a dab of caulk behind them. Looks intentional, not like you slapped some putty on and called it a day.


Reply

For radiator pipe holes, I’ve used escutcheon plates with a dab of caulk behind them. Looks intentional, not like you slapped some putty on and called it a day.

That’s a smart move. I tried the “stuff some steel wool in and hope for the best” method under my kitchen sink last winter. It worked for a while, but then I found little bits of it pushed out onto the floor... so, yeah, not my proudest fix. Escutcheon plates with caulk sound way more legit.

On the door sweeps - totally agree about the rubber ones. Our place has these old, uneven floors and the fancier sweeps just leave gaps. The plain rubber strip is ugly but it actually keeps out the drafts (and whatever else might be trying to sneak in).

One weird trick I picked up from my neighbor: sprinkle a line of cinnamon near any tiny gaps you can’t seal right away. Supposedly ants and mice hate it? Not sure if it’s science or just old-school wisdom, but it smells better than mothballs at least.


Reply

Cinnamon’s a new one for me - I’ve always heard peppermint oil does the trick for ants and mice, but I haven’t noticed much of a difference when I’ve tried it. With the steel wool, I had the same issue as you, until I started packing it in with a bit of expanding foam. Mice won’t chew through both, apparently. As for door sweeps, I’m with you - ugly rubber beats a cold draft any day, especially with these old floors that never seem to sit level. Sometimes practical just wins out over pretty.


Reply

Steel wool plus foam is a solid combo - been my go-to for years on job sites. Mice are persistent, but they really hate chewing through that mess. On peppermint oil, I’ve seen mixed results too. Some swear by it, but I think it’s more of a deterrent than a solution. Door sweeps are ugly as sin, but honestly, after seeing the energy bills on some older properties, I’ll take ugly over cold any day. Sometimes you just gotta embrace function over form, especially with these old houses that have seen better days.


Reply

- Steel wool + foam is a classic, but I’ve had issues with rust stains over time, especially in damp basements.
- Peppermint oil... yeah, it smells nice, but I’ve never seen it actually stop anything determined.
- Door sweeps can look rough, but there are some low-profile magnetic ones now that blend in better - worth checking out if aesthetics matter.
- Has anyone tried ultrasonic repellents? I’m skeptical, but a neighbor swears they work for her 1920s Tudor. Wondering if it’s just a placebo effect or legit science.


Reply

- Steel wool’s a go-to, but yeah, rust is a pain - especially in older basements with moisture issues. I’ve switched to copper mesh for that reason.
- Peppermint oil never did much for me either. Smells good for a day, then the critters are back.
- Magnetic door sweeps are solid. Used them on a recent rehab and they’re way less noticeable than the old rubber ones.
- Tried ultrasonic repellents in a rental property once. Didn’t see any measurable difference - might work for some, but I wouldn’t count on it as a standalone fix.


Reply

I hear you on the peppermint oil - never worked for me either, just made my basement smell like a candy shop for a bit. I actually tried stuffing dryer sheets in some gaps after reading about it online. Didn’t notice fewer mice, but my crawlspace smelled like fresh laundry for weeks. Has anyone had luck with expanding foam for sealing up odd-shaped holes, or do critters just chew right through that stuff?


Reply

Expanding foam seemed like a good idea at first - I used it around some pipes and odd corners in my garage. It definitely filled the gaps, but after a few months, I noticed little chew marks and eventually found bits of foam scattered around. Turns out, mice can get through it if they're determined enough. What worked better for me was stuffing steel wool into the holes before sealing with foam. Not the prettiest fix, but it’s cheap and actually kept them out. Sometimes the low-tech solutions are the most effective...


Reply

Title: Keeping the critters out: weird but effective tricks?

Steel wool does seem to be the go-to for a lot of folks, even if it’s not exactly pretty. I’ve tried the foam too and had the same issue - mice just chew right through it like it’s nothing. Ever tried copper mesh? I’ve heard it doesn’t rust like steel wool, but I’m not sure if it’s any better at stopping determined rodents. Still, can’t argue with what works, even if it’s not fancy. Sometimes I wonder if all these “miracle” products are just marketing...


Reply

“Ever tried copper mesh? I’ve heard it doesn’t rust like steel wool, but I’m not sure if it’s any better at stopping determined rodents.”

Copper mesh actually holds up a bit better in damp areas, but in my experience, mice will still give it a shot if they’re motivated enough. I get wanting something less ugly than steel wool, though - sometimes you just have to pick your battles between aesthetics and function. At the end of the day, nothing beats a good old-fashioned patch job with actual hardware cloth if you want to keep things looking tidy and critter-proof. The “miracle” stuff always feels a bit gimmicky to me too...


Reply

Honestly, hardware cloth is my go-to too. It’s not the prettiest but it actually works and you don’t have to keep redoing it every few months. Copper mesh is a bit pricey for what it is, and I’ve seen mice just chew right through if they’re desperate. I tried stuffing steel wool in some gaps under the sink once, but all it did was rust and make a mess - plus I still heard the little feet at night, so that was a bust.

If you’re on a budget, a combo of caulk and hardware cloth does the trick most times. Might not win any design awards, but at least you’re not shelling out for “miracle” sprays or whatever’s trending on TikTok this week. I’d rather have an ugly patch than another mouse in my cereal...


Reply
Scroll to Top