Custom homes discussions and local services.
Keeping the critters out: weird but effective tricks?
I’ve had similar experiences - exclusion is king, but I do like the cedar idea for trim. Have you ever tried using hardware cloth instead of steel wool for sealing gaps? I’ve found it holds up better over time, especially in damp spots. Curious if anyone’s noticed a difference.
Title: Keeping the critters out: weird but effective tricks?
I’ve actually gone back and forth between hardware cloth and steel wool, depending on the spot. Hardware cloth is my go-to for anything that’s got a bit of space to it - like under the deck or around vents. It’s just tougher, and I don’t have to worry about it rusting away or getting chewed through by the more determined rodents. Steel wool, on the other hand, I’ll use for those tiny, awkward gaps where it’s hard to get anything else to fit. But yeah, in damp areas, steel wool turns into a rusty mess pretty quick.
Funny story - last winter I thought I’d sealed up everything with steel wool behind my shed. Come spring, found a mouse had basically built itself a cozy little nest right in the rusty clump. Switched to hardware cloth after that and haven’t had any squatters since. Cedar trim is a nice touch too, though I mostly use it for looks rather than function. Anyone else ever try stuffing copper mesh in gaps? Heard mixed things about that...
Copper mesh is something I've looked into, mostly because it doesn't rust out like steel wool. From what I've seen, it's a bit pricier, but folks say rodents don’t like chewing through it. That said, I’ve heard stories about mice just pushing it aside if it’s not packed in tight enough. I guess the real trick is making sure whatever material you use actually stays put and doesn’t create a new hiding spot.
I’ve also wondered about using expanding foam in combination with mesh - like, does that really hold up over time? Some people swear by it for sealing weirdly shaped gaps, but I’m skeptical about how durable it is, especially if there’s any moisture involved. Anyone ever notice foam breaking down or critters just gnawing right through it?
I’ve also wondered about using expanding foam in combination with mesh - like, does that really hold up over time?
You’re right to be skeptical about foam as a long-term solution, especially if moisture is an issue. In my experience, the foam alone isn’t much of a deterrent - rodents can chew through it pretty easily. But pairing it with copper mesh can work well if you really pack the mesh in so it can't be pushed aside. The foam just fills the gaps and holds the mesh in place, but it’s definitely not a substitute for a physical barrier. For odd-shaped gaps, that combo is probably your best bet, but I’d avoid relying on foam by itself.
I’ve actually seen that combo - foam and mesh - hold up pretty well in older homes, especially where you’re dealing with weird gaps around pipes and such. The key really is making sure the mesh is packed tight, like you mentioned. Foam’s not perfect, but it does make things look neater and helps keep drafts out. I wouldn’t call it a permanent fix, but for tricky spots where you can’t fit hardware cloth or metal flashing, it’s a solid workaround. Sometimes you just have to get creative with these old houses...
Yeah, I’ve done the foam and mesh thing too, and honestly, it’s worked better than I expected. I get what you’re saying about it not being a forever fix, but sometimes you just need something that’ll keep the mice out until you can do a bigger repair. One thing I learned the hard way - don’t skimp on the mesh quality. Cheap stuff just gets chewed through. If you can find stainless steel, it’s worth it. Those little gaps behind cabinets are the worst...
Title: Keeping The Critters Out: Weird But Effective Tricks?
I get the whole foam and mesh combo, but I’ve always wondered if it just gives a false sense of security. Like, I tried it under my sink last fall and thought I was good... until I found mouse droppings again a few weeks later. Maybe I messed up the install, or maybe those little guys are just too determined? Stainless steel mesh sounds solid, but is it really that much better than the galvanized stuff? I keep seeing both at the hardware store and the price difference is kinda wild.
Also, has anyone tried using peppermint oil or those ultrasonic plug-ins? My neighbor swears by them, but I’m skeptical. Part of me thinks the mice just get used to whatever you throw at them unless you seal every single gap. Those tiny spaces behind appliances are a nightmare - how do you even reach back there without tearing your kitchen apart?
Title: Keeping The Critters Out: Weird But Effective Tricks?
Totally get where you’re coming from with the foam and mesh. I’ve seen folks rely on that combo and still end up with a mouse problem - those little guys can squeeze through gaps you’d swear were sealed. Stainless steel mesh is pricier, but in my experience it’s worth it if you want something they really can’t chew through. Galvanized works for a while, but I’ve seen mice gnaw at it or just find a weak spot.
Peppermint oil is one of those things people love to recommend, but honestly, I haven’t noticed much difference. Maybe it makes your kitchen smell nice for a bit, but determined critters don’t seem to care. Ultrasonic plug-ins are hit or miss too - some people swear by them, but I’ve never seen solid proof they work long-term.
Getting behind appliances is the real pain. Sometimes I use a long stick with a rag taped to the end to push mesh or steel wool into tight spots - definitely not elegant, but it beats pulling out the stove every time. At the end of the day, sealing every gap is key, even if it feels like playing whack-a-mole.
Title: Keeping The Critters Out: Weird But Effective Tricks?
You nailed it with the “whack-a-mole” analogy - sometimes it really does feel endless. I’ve had similar luck with peppermint oil; maybe it works for some, but I think mice just get used to it. Stainless steel mesh is definitely a solid investment, even if it stings the wallet a bit. That trick with the stick and rag is clever, by the way. It’s not glamorous, but whatever gets the job done, right? Sealing every gap is tedious, but you’re on the right track. Hang in there - it’s worth it in the long run.
Title: Keeping The Critters Out: Weird But Effective Tricks?
Peppermint oil never did much for me either - smelled nice, but the mice didn’t seem to care. Stainless mesh is pricey, but honestly, it’s the only thing that’s actually worked long-term at my place. I’ve heard some folks swear by ultrasonic repellents, but I’m skeptical. Has anyone actually seen those work, or is it just marketing hype?
Ultrasonic repellents are mostly snake oil, in my experience. Tried them in a few properties - mice just ignored the noise and kept coming back. Stainless mesh is expensive, yeah, but it’s a one-and-done fix. Anything else is just a band-aid.
Stainless mesh is definitely solid, but yeah, the price tag stings if you’ve got a lot of ground to cover. I’ve tried to balance cost and effectiveness by doing a bit of a hybrid approach at my place. Here’s what worked for me (and didn’t break the bank):
1. First, I walked the perimeter and stuffed steel wool into every little gap I could find - cheaper than mesh, and mice hate chewing through it.
2. For bigger holes, I used hardware cloth (it’s like mesh but cheaper and comes in rolls). Secured it with construction adhesive and screws where possible.
3. Caulked up any cracks that looked suspicious, especially around pipes and vents.
4. As a last step, I put out snap traps in spots where I’d seen droppings before - just as a backup.
I agree ultrasonic gadgets are mostly hype... mine just collected dust after a month. If you’re handy and don’t mind some DIY, piecing together these fixes can save cash over full stainless mesh everywhere. Not perfect, but my mouse problem dropped off fast after this routine.
Title: Keeping the critters out: weird but effective tricks?
That’s pretty much my playbook too, though I’ll admit I splurged on stainless mesh for a few “problem” corners just for peace of mind. One thing I’d add - if you’ve got a crawl space or basement, check for gaps around utility lines. I once found a mouse highway behind my water heater… used expanding foam plus steel wool and haven’t seen any signs since. I’m with you on the ultrasonic gadgets - mine just made an annoying noise and did nothing. If you’re picky about aesthetics, painting over hardware cloth blends it in better than I expected.
Funny you mention painting hardware cloth - I did that on a porch vent and it really does disappear unless you’re looking for it. One trick I picked up: copper mesh instead of steel wool for stuffing gaps. It doesn’t rust, so you don’t get those weird stains later. I’m still not convinced about expanding foam alone, though... mice seem to chew right through unless there’s something sharp in the mix.
I’m still not convinced about expanding foam alone, though... mice seem to chew right through unless there’s something sharp in the mix.
I get what you mean about foam - mice are relentless. But honestly, copper mesh can get pricey if you’ve got a lot of gaps. I’ve had decent luck layering cheaper steel wool with a dab of foam to hold it in place. Sure, steel wool rusts, but if it’s tucked away and you’re on a tight budget, it does the trick for a few years. Not perfect, but sometimes you’ve got to weigh cost vs. longevity.
“Sure, steel wool rusts, but if it’s tucked away and you’re on a tight budget, it does the trick for a few years.”
- Steel wool + foam is decent for a quick fix, but I’ve seen mice chew through rusted steel after a season or two.
- If you want something longer-term and still affordable, try stainless steel scrub pads from the dollar store - way less rust, still tough for rodents.
- For bigger gaps, I’ve also used hardware cloth (1/4" mesh) cut to size, then foamed around the edges. Not as cheap as steel wool, but lasts way longer.
- Just make sure whatever you use is packed in tight. Mice are little Houdinis...
That’s a solid list of tricks. I’ve run into the same thing with steel wool - works for a bit, but once it rusts out, mice can get bold. The stainless scrub pads are a great hack, especially if you’re trying to keep costs down. I’ve even seen folks double them up for bigger holes, and it seems to hold up.
Hardware cloth is probably my favorite for long-term fixes, even if it’s a bit more work up front. If you’ve got old houses or barns, you know those critters will find any gap you missed. I’ve noticed if you don’t pack stuff in tight, they’ll just push at the edges until they wiggle through. Sometimes I’ll dab a little caulk around the hardware cloth, just to make it less tempting.
Anyway, you’re not alone fighting the Houdini mice. It’s always a bit of trial and error, but you’re on the right track with these ideas.
Title: Keeping the critters out: weird but effective tricks?
- Hardware cloth’s my go-to too - takes a bit more elbow grease, but it holds up way longer than steel wool.
- I’ve tried spray foam with mixed results. Mice just chew right through unless you back it with something tougher.
- Stainless pads are handy, but I’ve had them rust eventually if there’s any moisture. Maybe I’m in a damper spot?
- Ever mess with copper mesh? Heard it’s pricey, but supposedly mice hate it and it doesn’t rust out.
Curious if anyone’s had luck with ultrasonic repellents or if that’s just snake oil...
Copper mesh is solid - pricey, yeah, but it doesn’t corrode and mice seem to avoid it. I’ve layered it behind hardware cloth in a few spots and haven’t seen any chew-through yet. About ultrasonic repellents...I’ve tried two brands and honestly didn’t notice a difference. Maybe they work for some pests, but rodents just ignored them here. Has anyone tried sealing with eco-friendly caulks or tapes? Wondering if there’s a green option that actually holds up.
I’ve been down the eco-friendly caulk rabbit hole a bit - tried a soy-based sealant last fall around a couple of basement vents. It was easy to work with and didn’t stink up the place, but after one winter, I’m seeing some cracking where the foundation flexes. Not sure I’d trust it for spots that get a lot of temperature swings or moisture. Anyone had better luck with those “green” tapes? I keep seeing them in the hardware store but can’t tell if they’re just marketing or actually tough enough for critters.
Also, I’m with you on ultrasonic repellents. Total dud for me. The mice just walked right by the thing like it wasn’t even there. Wonder if those peppermint sprays are any better, or just another gimmick...