Struggling to understand window insulation ratings and it's driving me nuts

business_diesel · 2025-04-11T12:21:44Z

So I'm in the middle of trying to pick out new windows for my place, and honestly, the whole insulation rating thing is kinda making my head spin. Like, I get that lower numbers are supposed to be better, but then there's all these different numbers and terms thrown around... it's like they purposely make it confusing just to mess with people, haha. I spent half of yesterday reading articles and watching videos, but somehow I still feel lost. And every time I think I've got it figured out, I stumble across another site or forum post that contradicts everything I just learned. Ugh. It doesn't help that some companies seem to use slightly different terms or measurements either. Like come on, can't we just have one simple rating system everyone agrees on? Or am I just being dense here? Anyway, I'm curious if other folks have had this same annoying experience when shopping for windows. Is it always this complicated or am I just unlucky?

Page 13 / 44 Prev Next

Passive Solar Design Principles

Last Post by design_kenneth

219 Posts

207 Users

0 Reactions

702 Views

RSS

Posts: 2

juliea18

(@juliea18)

New Member

Joined:

Totally agree on the triple pane thing being mostly hype, but gotta gently push back on the SHGC point. Lower ratings definitely help keep heat out, true...but if you're somewhere chilly (like I am), higher SHGC windows can actually be a sneaky bonus in winter. Free solar heat—can't beat that. I went mid-range windows myself, and honestly they've been great without wrecking the wallet. Just my two cents from the cold side of the fence, haha.

Posts: 6

magician485648

(@magician485648)

Active Member

Joined:

"higher SHGC windows can actually be a sneaky bonus in winter. Free solar heat—can't beat that."

Fair point there, but I'm curious about how much solar gain you're really getting during cloudy stretches or shorter winter days. When I built mine, I went lower SHGC to keep things consistent year-round. Might've missed out on some free warmth, but my heating bills haven't been terrible either... Wondering if anyone's actually measured the difference in real-world conditions? Could be interesting to test out.

Posts: 3

animation726

(@animation726)

New Member

Joined:

When I built mine, I went lower SHGC to keep things consistent year-round.

I've wondered about this too. I went lower SHGC to save upfront, but now I'm second-guessing myself. Has anyone tracked indoor temps with higher SHGC windows during cloudy winter weeks? Curious if the difference is noticeable or just theoretical...

Posts: 7

pets_adam

(@pets_adam)

Active Member

Joined:

I get the logic behind lower SHGC, but honestly, I've visited homes with higher SHGC windows during cloudy winters and didn't feel much difference. Maybe it's more noticeable on paper than in real life...? Would love to see actual temp logs though.

Posts: 7

scott_campbell

(@scott_campbell)

Active Member

Joined:

I've wondered about this too, actually. On cloudy winter days, the solar gain difference between high and low SHGC windows might be minimal enough that you wouldn't really feel it directly. But maybe the cumulative effect over a whole heating season is more noticeable? I'd be curious if anyone has compared monthly heating bills or indoor temp logs between similar houses with different window ratings. Anecdotally, my friend's place has higher SHGC windows and swears by them, but honestly... I couldn't tell much difference when I visited.