Custom homes discussions and local services.

Building base structures - what if you had to start over?

1,320 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

Couldn’t agree more about the hallway thing - 32” is just asking for bruised elbows and daily frustration. People get starry-eyed over fancy finishes, but you can’t retrofit good flow into a house. I’ve had clients beg to “just move that wall a little” after the fact, and it’s never as simple (or cheap) as they hope. Honestly, I’d take wider halls and decent closet clearances over the latest HVAC gadget any day. The basics matter way more than most folks realize when they're in the planning phase.


Reply

Honestly, I’d take wider halls and decent closet clearances over the latest HVAC gadget any day.

Funny how the basics get overlooked. I’ve seen folks obsess over quartz counters but then end up with a laundry room you can barely turn around in. If you were starting from scratch, would you prioritize wider halls or bigger bedrooms? I always wonder where people draw the line between flow and square footage for “living” spaces.


Reply

Title: Building Base Structures - What If You Had to Start Over?

I hear you on the basics getting lost in the shuffle. It’s wild how many new builds I’ve walked through where the hallways feel like afterthoughts - barely wide enough for two people to pass, let alone move a piece of furniture without scraping up the walls. Meanwhile, there’s a showpiece kitchen island that could double as a runway. Priorities, right?

If I had to start from scratch, I’d lean toward wider halls and doorways over bigger bedrooms, hands down. Years ago, my partner and I lived in this older ranch with these generous hallways - nothing fancy, just enough space that you never felt boxed in. It made a difference every single day, especially when we had kids running around or were carrying laundry baskets (or, let’s be honest, when we were both grumpy and needed to pass each other without bumping elbows). Bedrooms are important, but unless you’re spending all day in there, I’d rather have a house that feels open and easy to navigate.

I get the appeal of large bedrooms, but I think people forget how much “living” happens in the spaces between rooms. Flow matters more than square footage sometimes. You can always make a bedroom feel cozy with good lighting and storage tricks, but you can’t fake a cramped hallway or a closet you can’t open all the way.

Funny story - my aunt built her dream house and insisted on walk-in closets for every bedroom. Gorgeous, but she skimped on hallway width to make it work. Now every time we visit for family gatherings, there’s this awkward bottleneck outside the guest rooms where everyone’s trying to get by at once. She jokes about it now, but it drives her nuts.

Anyway, I’d say give me functional flow over extra square footage any day. The little things - clearances, door swings, turning radius - those are what make a house livable long-term. And honestly? You don’t miss the extra bedroom space as much as you think once you’ve lived with better circulation.


Reply

I get where you’re coming from about wanting more generous hallways - there’s nothing worse than trying to move a couch and realizing you have to wedge it through a passage that feels like it was designed for stick figures. That said, I’ve seen the pendulum swing too far in the other direction, where folks focus so much on “flow” and open space that the private parts of the home end up feeling like an afterthought.

You mentioned,

“You can always make a bedroom feel cozy with good lighting and storage tricks, but you can’t fake a cramped hallway or a closet you can’t open all the way.”
and I mostly agree, but I think there’s a limit to how much coziness you can squeeze out of a small bedroom - especially if you’re sharing it, or if you need space for a desk, or you just want a spot to breathe away from the main living areas. I once worked on a remodel for a family who’d gone all-in on wide corridors and open sightlines, but their teenage kids ended up basically living in the living room because their bedrooms felt more like oversized closets than actual retreats. Privacy matters, especially when you’ve got a full house.

One thing I always try to do is find that sweet spot - enough width in the halls so you’re not bumping elbows, but not at the expense of making bedrooms feel like afterthoughts. There’s a reason old farmhouses had those big, square rooms with doors that actually closed; people needed space to themselves, too. I think sometimes we get caught up in the idea of “open concept” and forget that a home needs places to tuck away, not just pass through.

Funny how every family seems to have a different rhythm, though. Some folks barely use their bedrooms except to sleep, others treat them like personal sanctuaries. I guess if I had to start over, I’d want a layout that lets both the shared spaces and the private ones breathe a little. Flow matters, sure, but so does having a door you can close and a room that feels like yours, not just another stop on the hallway.


Reply

BUILDING BASE STRUCTURES - WHAT IF YOU HAD TO START OVER?

- Totally get the struggle with “flow” vs. privacy. I’ve seen too many houses where you could land a plane in the hallway but you can barely fit a twin bed in the bedroom.
-

“Flow matters, sure, but so does having a door you can close and a room that feels like yours, not just another stop on the hallway.”
Couldn’t agree more. If your bedroom feels like a bus stop, something’s off.
- Honestly, I’d rather have a slightly tight hallway than a bedroom that doubles as a closet. You can always sidestep down the hall, but you can’t magic up square footage for actual living.
- Open concept is great until you realize there’s nowhere to hide from your own family... or your own mess.
- If I had to start over? Give me rooms with doors and enough space to actually live in them. Hallways are for moving through, not living in.


Reply

BUILDING BASE STRUCTURES - WHAT IF YOU HAD TO START OVER?

Totally with you on the need for real, usable rooms. I get why open concept is trendy, but honestly, it’s not always practical - especially if you care about energy efficiency or sound control. Smaller, well-insulated rooms are easier to heat and cool, and you actually get some peace and quiet. I’d take a cozy, functional bedroom over a giant hallway any day. Plus, doors are underrated... sometimes you just need to shut out the world (or your kids).


Reply

BUILDING BASE STRUCTURES - WHAT IF YOU HAD TO START OVER?

You nailed it about doors being underrated. I’ve seen so many new builds go all-in on open concept, and then the owners end up scrambling for ways to add privacy later. There’s something to be said for a house that actually lets you close off a space and just... breathe. Sure, open layouts look great in magazines, but real life is messy and loud. Give me a solid wall and a door any day - especially if I’m trying to get work done or just escape the chaos for a bit.


Reply

BUILDING BASE STRUCTURES - WHAT IF YOU HAD TO START OVER?

I get where you’re coming from. Open concept looks sleek, but after living in a house with barely any doors, I started missing the option to just shut out the noise. That said, I do like how open layouts can make a small space feel bigger. Maybe there’s a middle ground - like sliding doors or pocket doors? Curious if anyone’s tried those and actually found them useful long-term, or if they end up being more hassle than they’re worth.


Reply

SLIDING DOORS VS. OPEN CONCEPT - ANYONE REGRET IT?

Pocket doors are a bit of a mixed bag in my experience. They’re great for saving space and giving you that option to close things off, but the hardware can be finicky over time, especially if you go cheap on installation. I’ve seen them stick or come off track after a few years. Sliding barn doors look cool but don’t block sound much. If I had to start over, I’d probably do a combo - some open areas, but with solid doors where privacy actually matters, like bedrooms or offices. Open concept is nice until you’re trying to take a call and someone’s blending a smoothie...


Reply

SLIDING DOORS VS. OPEN CONCEPT - ANYONE REGRET IT?

I get the hesitation with pocket doors, but honestly, if you invest in high-end hardware and a good installer, they can be pretty seamless - literally and figuratively. I did a reno a few years back and splurged on soft-close pocket doors for my study and primary bath. Zero issues so far. The trick is making sure the wall cavity is deep enough and not cutting corners on the frame. I will say, though, I hear you on the open concept noise:

Open concept is nice until you’re trying to take a call and someone’s blending a smoothie...
That’s painfully real. Sometimes I wish I’d gone for more glass partitions - keeps things airy but you can still shut out the chaos when you need to.


Reply

The trick is making sure the wall cavity is deep enough and not cutting corners on the frame. I will say, though, I hear you on the open concept noise: That’s painfully real.

BUILDING BASE STRUCTURES - WHAT IF YOU HAD TO START OVER?

- Totally get the open concept struggle. That “someone’s blending a smoothie...” moment? Been there, regretted that.
- We did sliding doors for a couple spaces and honestly, no regrets. They’re not perfect, but they’re way better than the constant noise bleed.
- If I had to do it again, I’d probably add more solid walls or glass dividers. Open is nice till you need privacy or quiet.
- Agree on the hardware - don’t cheap out. Ours glide like butter, but a friend’s stick all the time and it drives him nuts.
- Bottom line: a little separation goes a long way if you actually live in your space, not just look at it.


Reply

STARTING OVER: WALLS, DOORS, AND NOISE - WHAT I’D DO DIFFERENTLY

You nailed it with the wall cavity depth. I see a lot of folks try to squeeze sliding doors into 2x4 walls and then wonder why they rattle or don’t block sound. If I had to start from scratch, I’d go 2x6 for any pocket or sliding door - gives you more room for solid hardware and insulation.

On the open concept thing...I get the appeal, but after living in a few, I’m convinced some separation is just practical. Doesn’t have to be full-on closed rooms everywhere, but even partial walls or those glass dividers you mentioned make a huge difference. I once did a build where we used floor-to-ceiling bookshelves as dividers - looked cool and actually helped with noise.

And yeah, hardware matters way more than people think. Cheap tracks are a nightmare. Spend the extra for soft-close and sturdy rollers. It’s one of those things you only notice when it’s bad.

If I could go back, I’d plan for more flexible spaces - pocket doors, movable walls, stuff like that. Open when you want it, closed when you need it. Live and learn, right?


Reply

BUILDING BASE STRUCTURES - WHAT IF YOU HAD TO START OVER?

- Couldn’t agree more on the 2x6 for pocket doors. Tried to retrofit a 2x4 wall once - never again. The noise and flimsy feel just aren’t worth it.
- Open concept is nice in theory, but after a few years, I miss having spots to escape the chaos. Partial walls or even sliding panels make a world of difference.
- Hardware’s one of those things you don’t notice until it’s driving you nuts. Cheap tracks = regret.
- If I had to do it over, I’d think harder about outlets and switches too. Always seem to end up with one in the worst spot.

Curious - has anyone tried those accordion-style glass walls? Wondering if they’re actually practical for daily use or just look cool in photos.


Reply

BUILDING BASE STRUCTURES - WHAT IF YOU HAD TO START OVER?

Yeah, the 2x4 pocket door regret is real. I did that in my old place and every time someone closed it, the whole wall rattled. Never again - 2x6 or nothing. On the open concept thing, totally get it. It looked great at first, but now I wish I had a spot to hide from the kids’ Nerf battles. As for those accordion glass walls, a friend put one in his kitchen. Looks amazing, but he says cleaning all those panes is a pain and the track gets gunky if you’re not on top of it. Cool factor’s high, but I’d want to see how it holds up after a year or two of daily use...


Reply

BUILDING BASE STRUCTURES - WHAT IF YOU HAD TO START OVER?

I hear you on the pocket doors. I did a 2x4 one in my last house because I thought it’d be a slick way to save space and cash. Regretted it pretty quick - felt like I was living inside a drum set every time someone used it. If I could go back, I’d honestly just do a regular swinging door or pony up for a proper 2x6 wall. Sometimes “budget-friendly” just means fixing it later.

The open concept thing is funny too. Everyone’s obsessed with it on those home shows, but after living in one, I’d trade some of that “airy” vibe for a little peace and somewhere to stash the laundry baskets. Not everything needs to be visible all the time.

As for those glass accordion walls... sure, they look incredible, but have you ever tried to keep fingerprints off them? Or dealt with crumbs in the tracks? If you’re not into cleaning, it’s just another chore waiting to happen. Cool factor isn’t everything - sometimes simple wins out in the long run.


Reply

Sometimes “budget-friendly” just means fixing it later.

That’s the truth. I see so many people cut corners on framing or insulation, thinking they’re saving a buck, but it always comes back around - either in comfort or resale value. Open concept is another one. It looks great on paper, but acoustics and storage are a nightmare. Curious if anyone’s actually found a good balance between open flow and practical separation? I’ve yet to see a layout that nails both without some compromise.


Reply

Open concept is another one. It looks great on paper, but acoustics and storage are a nightmare.

Totally agree - open layouts look slick in renderings, but once you’re living in it, the echo and clutter can drive you nuts. I once did a partial wall with built-ins that helped, but it’s always a trade-off.


Reply

- Can’t argue with the acoustics issue - open concepts can be a headache there.
- Storage always gets underestimated. People love the clean look, but where does all the stuff go?
- Partial walls or built-ins are a smart compromise. I’ve seen folks use double-sided shelving or even sliding panels to break up space without closing it off entirely, which helps a bit.
- There’s no perfect answer, but it’s good you’re thinking about trade-offs early. Every layout comes with its own set of headaches... just gotta pick which ones you’re willing to live with.


Reply

Title: Building Base Structures - What If You Had to Start Over?

You nailed it with the storage dilemma. Every time I walk through a new build with clients, they’re drawn to those wide-open spaces and minimal lines, but then we hit the “where does the vacuum live?” moment. It’s always a bit of a reality check. I’ve seen some creative solutions - hidden cabinetry, under-stair drawers, even benches that double as storage - but there’s only so much you can tuck away before it starts to feel forced.

Acoustics are another beast entirely. Open concepts look fantastic in renderings, but once you get a couple of kids running around or someone working from home, it’s a different story. I’ve had folks ask about soundproofing after the fact, which is never as effective (or cheap) as planning for it upfront. Sometimes I wonder if we’re all just chasing that magazine spread look without thinking about how we actually live day-to-day.

Partial walls and built-ins are definitely underrated. There’s something to be said for a little separation - just enough to define spaces without boxing everything in. I’ve seen some projects use glass partitions or even plant walls, which add character and help with noise a bit. Not perfect, but better than nothing.

At the end of the day, every layout is a compromise. There’s no magic formula that fits everyone. Personally, I’d rather have a slightly less “open” space if it means I’m not tripping over shoes or hearing every phone call from the kitchen. But maybe that’s just me getting old... or practical? Hard to say.

It’s always interesting to see how people prioritize these things when starting from scratch. Some folks really do want that ultra-minimalist vibe and don’t mind making sacrifices for it, while others would trade aesthetics for function any day. Guess it comes down to knowing what headaches you’re willing to put up with long-term.


Reply

BUILDING BASE STRUCTURES - WHAT IF YOU HAD TO START OVER?

You’re not wrong about the open concept headaches. I’ve seen too many folks get caught up in the “airy” look, only to realize later they’ve got nowhere to stash the mop or buffer out the noise. It’s easy to get swept up by those glossy renderings, but real life is messier. Partial walls and built-ins might not be flashy, but they’re practical - sometimes boring wins out over trendy. At the end of the day, you’re spot on: it’s all about what you’re willing to live with long-term. No shame in picking function over form.


Reply
Scroll to Top