Custom homes discussions and local services.

Digging up the backyard: found more than just dirt

750 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

Digging Up The Backyard: Found More Than Just Dirt

You nailed it with the “cheap now, pay later” thing. I once tried to save a few bucks on landscape fabric and ended up with a backyard dandelion farm. Never again. Now I swear by the heavy-duty stuff, even if the price stings at first. And about the pets - my dog decided mulch was his new snack, so I switched to river rock in the high-traffic spots. Not the look I originally wanted, but at least he’s not eating my yard anymore. Sometimes you just have to roll with it and accept a little mess.


Reply

Digging Up The Backyard: Found More Than Just Dirt

That river rock swap is a smart move. I tried to stick with mulch for years - mainly because it looked nice and was cheap - but after my third round of replacing it thanks to the neighbor’s cat (and my own dog, who thought it was a buffet), I finally caved and went with pea gravel in the worst spots. Not as cozy-looking, but way less drama.

Here’s what worked for me, in case anyone else is wrestling with the same mess: First, I dug out all the old mulch and weed fabric, which was basically shredded plastic at that point. Then I put down a double layer of the thickest landscape fabric I could find - yeah, it cost more up front, but it’s been three years and barely a weed in sight. After that, I put down a few inches of pea gravel. It doesn’t blow around like mulch, and my dog lost interest pretty quick.

One thing I learned the hard way: don’t skimp on edging. I used those cheap plastic strips at first and they just popped out after a season or two. Switched to metal edging and haven’t had to touch it since.

I get wanting everything to look perfect, but honestly, sometimes you just have to accept that pets (and wildlife) are gonna do their thing. My backyard isn’t exactly magazine-worthy, but it’s functional and a lot less work now. If you’re on the fence about spending more for better materials, my advice is just do it once and save yourself the headache later. That said, I know some folks swear by mulch and have no problems... maybe it’s just my luck with animals.

Funny how digging up your yard always turns into a bigger project than you planned. Every time I think I’m done, something else pops up - roots, rocks, or some weird old toy from decades ago. Keeps things interesting, at least.


Reply

Digging Up The Backyard: Found More Than Just Dirt

Couldn’t agree more about the edging - plastic is just asking for trouble. I’m a big fan of doing it right the first time, even if it stings a bit up front. Curious, did you run into any drainage issues with the pea gravel? I’ve had mixed results depending on the slope and soil underneath.


Reply

Curious, did you run into any drainage issues with the pea gravel? I’ve had mixed results depending on the slope and soil underneath.

That’s actually what’s holding me back from going all-in on pea gravel. I keep reading mixed reviews - some folks swear by it, others mention pooling or weird muddy patches. Did you use any kind of fabric barrier underneath? I’m trying to figure out if that’s worth the extra cost or just marketing hype. Also, does anyone have thoughts on whether compacted decomposed granite is a better bet for drainage, or is it just as finicky?


Reply

I’ve seen the same thing - pea gravel can be hit or miss depending on what’s underneath. I’ve used landscape fabric before, and honestly, it helped with weeds but didn’t do much for drainage. If the soil’s clay-heavy, water just sits there no matter what you put on top. Decomposed granite compacts pretty well, but if you overdo it, it can get almost as hard as concrete and stop draining altogether. Kind of a balancing act… I guess nothing’s totally foolproof.


Reply

If the soil’s clay-heavy, water just sits there no matter what you put on top.

That’s been my experience, too. Even with all the best prep - fabric, gravel, whatever - if you’re sitting on a slab of clay, it’s like trying to drain a bathtub with the plug in. I’ve had luck mixing in some sand and compost before laying anything down, but it’s a messy job. Sometimes I wonder if we’re just rearranging problems instead of solving them… but at least it keeps things interesting.


Reply

if you’re sitting on a slab of clay, it’s like trying to drain a bathtub with the plug in.

That’s exactly it. I’ve seen people throw thousands at fancy drainage systems, but if the subsoil’s pure clay, you’re fighting nature. Sometimes I think raised beds or even hardscaping are the only real solutions - at least you know what you’re working with. Mixing in sand helps, but it’s never perfect.


Reply

I get where you’re coming from, but I’ve actually had some luck with amending clay - though it’s definitely not a quick fix. Years ago, I inherited a backyard that was basically a brick pit after rain. Instead of going straight to raised beds, I spent a couple seasons working in compost, gypsum, and even some coarse bark chips. It took patience, but drainage improved enough for turf and some shrubs. Not perfect, but sometimes worth a shot before giving up on the ground entirely.


Reply

Honestly, I really admire your patience with that clay. It’s easy to get discouraged and just throw in the towel (or throw down a bunch of expensive raised beds). I’m with you - sometimes it’s worth giving the ground a fighting chance. I’ve found that even just layering cardboard and mulch over winter helps break things up a bit. It’s not magic, but it’s budget-friendly and kind of satisfying to see slow progress. Hang in there - sometimes the stubborn soil surprises you.


Reply

I’ve found that even just layering cardboard and mulch over winter helps break things up a bit. It’s not magic, but it’s budget-friendly and kind of satisfying to see slow progress.

Tried the cardboard trick myself a few years back - honestly, didn’t expect much, but it actually made a difference. Still had to put in some elbow grease come spring, but the soil wasn’t nearly as stubborn. Raised beds are tempting, but I’d rather fight with the ground I’ve got before shelling out for lumber and soil. Sometimes the old ways just work, even if they’re slow.


Reply

I get the appeal of raised beds, but I’m with you - there’s something satisfying about working with what’s already there, even if it’s a pain. I tried the cardboard and mulch method last fall, and honestly, I was skeptical. The soil did loosen up a bit, but I still hit a ton of rocks and old roots. Did anyone else run into weird stuff buried in their yard? I found what looked like an old horseshoe... made me wonder what else is down there.


Reply

Never fails - dig a hole and you’re bound to hit something weird. In my last place, I kept running into chunks of old brick and a rusty pipe that went nowhere. The horseshoe’s kind of cool though, probably better than the random glass shards I’ve found. As for rocks and roots, that’s pretty much par for the course unless you’re dealing with new construction. I’ve had decent luck loosening things up with a digging fork, but honestly, sometimes it’s just easier to work around the big stuff rather than try to clear it all out.


Reply

Title: Digging Up The Backyard: Found More Than Just Dirt

Yeah, it’s wild what you’ll find underground. I once pulled up a chunk of concrete with a metal rod sticking out - no clue what it was for. Old bricks are pretty common, especially in neighborhoods that have been around a while. I hear you on the digging fork, though. Sometimes I just end up hacking away with a mattock and calling it good enough. Roots are the worst, honestly. I’ve tried to dig them out, but half the time I just end up rerouting whatever I’m working on. That horseshoe’s a nice score, though... beats the time I found a buried plastic Santa head.


Reply

Honestly, I gotta disagree about hacking away with a mattock being “good enough.” I used to do the same, but it just wore me out and made a mess. Here’s what’s worked for me: first, soak the area with water the night before - softens things up big time. Next, use a cheap pruning saw for roots instead of trying to muscle them out. For concrete chunks or bricks, I pry them loose with an old crowbar (found at a yard sale). It’s slower, but saves your back and tools. Plus, you never know what you’ll find if you’re careful... sometimes even old coins or weird bottles.


Reply

- That’s actually a smart move, soaking the ground first - makes sense if you’re not in a rush.
- I’ve found that using a root slayer shovel can sometimes cut through roots faster than a saw, but it really depends on the soil and what’s buried down there.
-

“sometimes even old coins or weird bottles.”

Love this part. I once dug up some old porcelain shards - nothing valuable, but still kind of cool.
- Curious - when you find bricks or concrete, do you try to reuse them for landscaping? Or just haul them out? Sometimes the “junk” ends up being perfect for edging or little garden paths...


Reply

Sometimes the “junk” ends up being perfect for edging or little garden paths...

That’s the best part - turning random finds into something beautiful or useful. I’ve actually used old bricks I dug up as a border for a flower bed, and it gave the space a bit of character you just can’t buy new. Even concrete chunks can look surprisingly chic if you arrange them right. It’s like the yard’s got its own hidden history, and you get to showcase it.


Reply

Digging Up the Backyard: Found More Than Just Dirt

I totally get what you mean about the “junk” adding character. When we started working on our backyard, I was honestly kind of annoyed at first by all the random stuff buried back there - chunks of broken tile, some weird old pavers, even a rusty horseshoe (no idea how that got there). But after a while, I started seeing it differently. Instead of hauling it all to the dump, I tried using some of it to line the path to our shed. It’s not perfectly uniform, but that’s kind of the charm, right? There’s something satisfying about making use of what’s already there, even if it’s not what you’d pick out at the store.

I will say, though, sometimes I wonder if I’m just being cheap or if it actually looks good. My partner was skeptical at first - she thought the mismatched bricks would make the yard look messy. But now that the plants have started to fill in, it all sort of blends together and feels intentional. I guess it’s one of those things where you have to trust the process a bit.

One thing I didn’t expect was how much these little “finds” would spark conversations with neighbors. Turns out, a couple of them recognized the bricks from an old local factory that got torn down decades ago. Now it feels like our yard has a story, not just a bunch of random stuff stuck in the ground.

I know some folks prefer everything new and matching, but honestly, I think there’s something special about letting the history of the place show through. It’s not always the easiest route, but it’s definitely more interesting.


Reply

Digging Up the Backyard: Found More Than Just Dirt

I totally get where you’re coming from about the “junk” adding character. There’s something kind of cool about using what you find on your own property, even if it’s not all shiny and new. I know the trend in a lot of high-end homes is to have everything super coordinated and pristine, but honestly, sometimes that can feel a little sterile. The mismatched look has its own vibe, especially when there’s a story behind it.

I’ve seen some pretty fancy gardens that try to fake that “collected over time” look with expensive reclaimed materials, but it never feels quite as authentic as actually using what’s already there. Plus, the fact that your neighbors recognized those bricks? That’s gold. It’s like your yard is part of the neighborhood’s history now, not just another cookie-cutter space.

I get the hesitation about whether it looks good or just cheap. I’ve had that same debate with my partner over some old stone we found buried in our yard - she wanted to toss it, but I convinced her to let me try working it into a little seating area. It took a while to grow on her, but now she loves it, especially since the plants have started to soften the edges. Sometimes you just have to give things a chance to settle in.

Honestly, I think there’s a lot to be said for letting a space evolve naturally instead of forcing it to look like a catalog. It’s way more interesting when there’s a bit of history and personality mixed in. And hey, if you ever decide you want to swap something out later, you can always do that. For now, I’d say embrace the quirks - sounds like you’re onto something pretty unique.


Reply

I get the appeal of “letting a space evolve naturally,” but I’ll admit, I’m still on the fence about how far to take that. I’ve seen a few yards where the “quirks” just end up looking like someone forgot to finish the job. That said, I do appreciate when there’s a real story behind the materials - like you said,

“the fact that your neighbors recognized those bricks? That’s gold.”
I once found some old wrought iron fencing buried behind my place. Cleaned it up, worked it into the garden, and now it’s a conversation starter. But I still think there’s a fine line between character and clutter... sometimes it’s hard to know which side you’re on until you live with it for a while.


Reply

Totally get what you mean about that fine line. I’ve had a few “projects” where I thought I was adding character, but after a month or two, it just looked like a pile of leftovers. There’s something about old materials, though - if they’ve got a story or some history, it feels different. Like your wrought iron fence, that’s cool. I once dug up a bunch of mismatched pavers and tried to make a path. At first it looked kind of random, but after the plants grew in and the dirt settled, it actually worked.

I guess sometimes you have to live with the weirdness for a bit before you know if it’s “quirky charm” or just...messy. Maybe the trick is being willing to change things up if it doesn’t feel right after a while. Or maybe I’m just indecisive - hard to say.


Reply
Scroll to Top