Custom homes discussions and local services.

Digging up the backyard: found more than just dirt

750 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

DIGGING UP THE BACKYARD: FOUND MORE THAN JUST DIRT

Had a similar thing happen when I was redoing my backyard for a patio. Dug up what looked like an old septic tank lid - talk about a mood killer. Ended up being just a concrete slab, but it made me double-check the property records before going any deeper. Not as cool as finding something historic, but it did save me from making a bigger mess. Sometimes those surprises are just warnings in disguise... not treasures, but still useful in their own way.


Reply

Funny how those “discoveries” can throw a wrench in your plans. I’ve seen plenty of backyard projects where folks hit old footings or mystery slabs and it’s rarely anything exciting - usually just a reminder that previous owners had their own ideas. Double-checking property records was a smart move. Even if it’s not something historic, you don’t want to dig into an old utility line or something structural by accident. Sometimes boring is better when you’re trying to build.


Reply

Sometimes boring is better when you’re trying to build.

I get where you’re coming from, but I’ve actually found that sometimes those “wrenches” can turn into opportunities, depending on what you stumble across. Last year, I was digging out a spot for a patio and hit what I thought was just an old slab. Turned out to be the foundation for a tiny shed from the 1950s - nothing historic, but it had some cool old bricks and even a couple of intact glass bottles. Ended up cleaning them up and using them as garden edging. Not exactly a treasure trove, but it made the project feel a bit more personal.

I do agree about double-checking property records and marking out utilities - can’t stress that enough. But sometimes, if you’re willing to put in a little extra work, those unexpected finds can add character to your space. Here’s how I usually handle it:

1. If I hit something solid, I stop and poke around the edges to see how big it is.
2. I’ll dig a small test hole on one side to check if it’s just a chunk or part of something bigger.
3. If it looks like an old footing or slab, I try to figure out if it’s connected to anything structural (like a garage or porch).
4. For anything that seems weird or out of place, I’ll snap a few photos and ask neighbors - they often know the backstory.
5. Only after all that do I decide whether to remove it, work around it, or maybe even incorporate it.

Not saying everyone wants to deal with the hassle, but sometimes “boring” isn’t the only safe route. You might end up with a story or two for the next backyard BBQ.


Reply

Digging Up the Backyard: Found More Than Just Dirt

That’s honestly the best part of working on an old property - never know what’ll turn up. I once unearthed a rusted horseshoe and half a box of ancient nails under my deck. Made me wonder if there was an old stable back there or just a very unlucky horse. I get why folks like things to go smoothly, but a little chaos makes for better stories. Plus, those old bricks and bottles? Way cooler than anything you’d buy at the garden center. Sometimes the “hassle” is half the fun.


Reply

- Always wild what you’ll dig up - literally.
- I’ve found everything from old glass marbles to a chunk of what looked like a Model T fender.
- Sometimes I wonder if I’m building a patio or running an archeological dig.
- Not gonna lie, those random finds slow things down, but they make the job way more interesting.
- Anyone else ever hit a patch of bricks and start questioning if you’re about to uncover a secret tunnel?
- I’ll take weird old junk over a perfectly smooth dig any day... keeps things interesting.


Reply

Sometimes I wonder if I’m building a patio or running an archeological dig.

It’s wild how much history can be buried just a few inches down. I once unearthed what turned out to be an old cistern - thought it was a tunnel at first, nearly gave me a heart attack. Slows the project, sure, but it’s way more fun than just moving dirt.


Reply

Title: Digging Up The Backyard: Found More Than Just Dirt

- Running into unexpected stuff underground is way more common than people think.
- Old cisterns, pipes, random concrete slabs... you name it, I've seen it.
- It can really mess with your project timeline, but honestly, sometimes it's a blessing in disguise - better to find it now than after you've poured the patio.
- If you ever hit old brick or stone, check for utilities before going further. Some of those old lines aren't on any modern maps.
- I get the frustration, but hey, at least it's not just endless clay. Makes for a good story later, too.
- Once found a rusted-out Model T axle about two feet down. No idea how it got there - neighbors still talk about it.

Hang in there. These surprises are part of the fun, even if they slow things down.


Reply

Hitting unexpected stuff underground is almost a given, especially on older lots. I’ve seen everything from buried septic tanks to random chunks of rebar that nobody bothered to map out decades ago. It’s true, you really don’t want to discover an old drain line after you’ve started pouring concrete - undoing that mess is a headache. One thing I’d add: sometimes those odd finds can indicate bigger issues, like soil instability around old cisterns or slabs. Worth taking the extra time to check the surrounding area, even if it slows things down a bit. Surprises are part of the job, but I’d rather deal with them up front than risk structural problems later.


Reply

Surprises are part of the job, but I’d rather deal with them up front than risk structural problems later.

That’s the truth. When I dug out for my workshop slab, I hit what looked like an old foundation wall about two feet down. At first I thought it was just a chunk of concrete, but it turned out to be the remains of a root cellar from who-knows-when. Took me a whole weekend to clear it out, but I’m glad I did - there was a big pocket of loose soil underneath. Would’ve been a nightmare if I’d just poured over it. Sometimes those “extra” hours save you weeks down the line.


Reply

Funny how these things always seem to pop up right when you think you’re making progress. When I was putting in a patio, I ran into a bunch of old bricks and broken glass about a foot down - looked like someone just buried their trash there decades ago. I debated just working around it to save some cash, but ended up hauling it all out. Did you have to bring in extra fill after clearing out that root cellar? I always wonder if it’s worth paying for more gravel or just compacting what’s there...


Reply

I’ve run into the same dilemma - sometimes it feels like you’re just shuffling dirt and debris from one spot to another. I usually lean toward bringing in clean fill, especially if I’m worried about drainage or stability, but it does add up. Did you notice any settling after you finished, or did compacting do the trick? I’ve heard mixed things about just tamping down what’s already there, especially if it’s old fill.


Reply

DIGGING UP THE BACKYARD: FOUND MORE THAN JUST DIRT

- I’ve definitely seen settling when I’ve just tamped down old fill, especially if it’s got a lot of organic material or random junk mixed in. Even with a plate compactor, it’s tough to get it really solid unless you’re layering and wetting as you go.
- Clean fill is pricey, but in my experience, it’s the only way to be sure you’re not going to have weird dips or soft spots a year later. I had a spot behind my garage where I tried to reuse what was there, tamped it like crazy, and still ended up with a mini sinkhole after the first big rain.
- If you’re worried about drainage, I’d check what kind of fill you’re using. Some of the stuff they call “clean” is basically just sandy loam, which drains fast but doesn’t hold shape well. I’ve had better luck with a mix that’s got some clay content, but not too much or you’ll get pooling.
- For stability, layering is key. I usually go 4-6 inches at a time, wet it down, compact, then repeat. It’s tedious, but I haven’t had settling issues since I started doing it that way.
- Curious - did you run into any weird debris or trash while digging? I pulled out a half-buried tire and a bunch of broken bricks last time, which made me wonder what else is lurking down there. Sometimes I feel like I’m just moving the problem around, not actually fixing it.

Have you tried using geotextile fabric under your fill? I’ve heard mixed reviews, but supposedly it helps with stability and keeps things from mixing over time.


Reply

DIGGING UP THE BACKYARD: FOUND MORE THAN JUST DIRT

- I’ve definitely seen settling when I’ve just tamped down old fill, especially if it’s got a lot of organic material or random junk mixed ...

DIGGING UP THE BACKYARD: FOUND MORE THAN JUST DIRT

- That’s wild about the tire and bricks - makes me wonder what’s under my own yard. I totally get the feeling of “just moving the problem around.”
- I’ve been debating geotextile fabric too. Some folks swear by it, but I’ve heard it can make drainage weird if you’re not careful.
- Layering and wetting sounds tedious, but your results speak for themselves. I’m tempted to try it, even if it takes forever.
- Clean fill is expensive, but after reading about your mini sinkhole, I’m thinking it’s worth it.
- Thanks for sharing your experience - it’s reassuring to know I’m not the only one running into random junk and weird settling.


Reply

DIGGING UP THE BACKYARD: FOUND MORE THAN JUST DIRT

-

makes me wonder what’s under my own yard

- When we broke ground for our veggie beds, I found a random chunk of asphalt and a half-buried garden gnome. Still not sure how either got there.
- I tried skipping the layering step once - regretted it after everything sank weirdly. Now I’m a convert, even if it’s a pain.
- Geotextile fabric is tempting, but I’ve heard mixed things too. My neighbor swears it kept her yard from turning into a swamp, but I’m on the fence.
- Clean fill is pricey, but honestly, dealing with mystery debris later costs more - in time and sanity.


Reply

I totally get the hesitation with geotextile fabric - I've read mixed reviews too. When I did my raised beds, I went with cardboard and a thick mulch layer instead, just to save a bit. It worked okay, but I did have some weeds sneak through. Has anyone tried using old sheets or something similar as a budget-friendly barrier? Curious if that holds up or just turns into a mess over time...


Reply

Title: Digging Up the Backyard: Found More Than Just Dirt

I’ve actually tried using old cotton sheets as a weed barrier under a gravel path in my last place. I figured, why not repurpose what I had on hand? At first, it seemed like a clever workaround - easy to lay down, and it covered a decent area without much fuss. But after one season, I noticed the sheets started breaking down pretty fast, especially where water pooled or the soil stayed damp. By the next spring, I was basically pulling up shreds mixed with roots and mud. Not exactly the low-maintenance solution I’d hoped for.

From a materials standpoint, most household fabrics just aren’t designed to withstand constant moisture and pressure from soil and mulch. They tend to decompose or get moldy way quicker than geotextile fabric does. Plus, once they start breaking apart, you end up with more mess to clean up later - little bits of fabric tangled up with plant roots is not fun.

I get the appeal of using what’s on hand (and saving money), but if you’re looking for something that’ll last more than a season or two, I’d lean toward cardboard or even layers of newspaper over old sheets. At least those break down cleanly and add some organic matter back into the soil. If you do go with fabric, maybe try something synthetic like an old polyester curtain liner - it won’t decompose as quickly, though it’s not exactly eco-friendly.

One thing that helped me cut down on weeds was doubling up on mulch - like a thick wood chip layer over whatever barrier I used. It’s not foolproof, but it definitely slowed things down. Weeds are persistent little things... seems like no matter what you use, some always find their way through.


Reply

- Totally get the urge to use what’s lying around - cotton sheets seem like a smart hack at first.
- I’ve been there with “budget” weed barriers and yeah, they just don’t hold up. That mess of roots and fabric shreds is the worst.

-

“At least those break down cleanly and add some organic matter back into the soil.”

Cardboard’s been my go-to for a while now. It’s free (hello, Amazon boxes), and it actually helps the soil instead of making more work later.

- The double mulch trick is solid advice. I’ve noticed even with cardboard, if I skimp on mulch, weeds just laugh at me.

- Polyester or synthetic stuff does last longer, but I always wonder about microplastics or weird chemicals leaching in over time? Not sure if that’s a real issue or just internet paranoia...

- Anyway, props for trying to make do with what you had. Sometimes you gotta experiment to find out what works (and what definitely doesn’t).


Reply

“Polyester or synthetic stuff does last longer, but I always wonder about microplastics or weird chemicals leaching in over time? Not sure if that’s a real issue or just internet paranoia...”

I’ve wondered the same. Honestly, I’d rather deal with a few weeds than risk adding mystery chemicals to the soil. Cardboard + thick mulch seems like the least-bad compromise. If you want a step up, I’ve had some luck layering newspaper under the cardboard - sounds redundant, but it really slows down the aggressive weeds. Not perfect, but better than digging out polyester shreds years later...


Reply

Digging Up The Backyard: Found More Than Just Dirt

That’s pretty much my take, too. I’ve worked on a few properties where folks used that black landscape fabric - sometimes the woven stuff, sometimes the plastic-y kind - and years later it’s just a mess. You end up with these little plastic threads tangled in the roots, and it never really goes away. Not great for resale, either. I get why people want the low-maintenance route, but long-term, it’s just more trouble than it’s worth.

Cardboard and mulch is what I recommend most of the time. It breaks down slow enough to smother weeds for a season or two, but you’re not left with junk in the soil. If you’re worried about stubborn weeds (bindweed, I’m looking at you), newspaper under the cardboard does help. I’ve even seen folks use old cotton sheets - nothing with elastic or synthetic blends, just plain cotton - and that works if you’ve got some lying around. Not as common, but it does the trick.

One thing to watch out for: make sure your cardboard doesn’t have glossy coatings or colored inks. Some of those can have weird chemicals, too. Stick to plain brown stuff, tear off any tape, and you’re good.

I get the appeal of “permanent” solutions, but honestly, nothing’s really permanent in a backyard. Roots find a way, and you’ll be out there pulling something eventually. At least with cardboard and mulch, you’re not digging up mystery plastics years later. Plus, it’s easier to replant or change things up down the road.

If you do go this route, water the layers down as you build them. Helps them settle and stick together, and makes it harder for weeds to sneak through gaps. Learned that one the hard way after a windy day scattered my carefully placed cardboard all over the yard...


Reply

I’ve run into the same landscape fabric mess more times than I can count. It’s a pain when you’re trying to dig in new beds or even just plant a tree - those plastic threads get everywhere. Cardboard and mulch definitely make things easier down the line, especially if you ever want to change up your layout. One tip I’d add: if you’re working near the house, keep the mulch layer a few inches away from the foundation to avoid moisture issues. Learned that one after a client had ants move in... Not fun.


Reply
Scroll to Top