Custom homes discussions and local services.

My Adventure With DIY Concrete Foundations

829 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

Yeah, I was thinking the same thing about testing it small-scale first. I've learned the hard way that what seems logical on paper doesn't always pan out in practice... especially with DIY projects. When I did my patio last summer, I tried to save a bit by skipping some recommended prep steps - like compacting the base properly - and ended up with uneven slabs after just one winter. Lesson learned, haha.

The woven/non-woven combo does sound promising though. From what I've read, woven fabric is great for reinforcement and stability, but drainage can be an issue if water starts pooling underneath. Non-woven fabric seems like it'd help with that, but I'm wondering if layering them might trap moisture between the two fabrics? Could that potentially cause issues down the line?

Maybe spacing them out or staggering sections could help avoid trapping water... I'm not sure. Has anyone else tried something similar? It'd be interesting to see how it holds up over time. Either way, definitely agree with starting small and seeing how it goes before committing to the whole foundation - better safe than sorry when it comes to concrete work.


Reply

I've been wondering about that trapped moisture issue too. I haven't tried layering woven and non-woven myself, but when I laid down just woven fabric under a gravel walkway, I ended up with little puddles forming after heavy rains. It wasn't terrible, but it definitely made me think twice about drainage.

Maybe instead of stacking them directly, you could overlap the edges slightly or leave narrow gaps between sections? That way water might have a place to escape. Or perhaps perforating the woven layer in strategic spots could help with drainage without sacrificing strength?

Honestly, I'm just guessing here... Has anyone actually tested variations like this and seen how they hold up long-term? Would hate to put in all that effort only to redo it next season. DIY concrete is tricky enough without dealing with moisture issues later on.


Reply

I've dealt with similar drainage headaches before. A few quick thoughts:

- Perforating woven fabric can help, but don't overdo it or you'll lose strength.
- Slight overlaps or gaps between sections definitely improve drainage - tried this myself under a patio and it worked pretty well.
- Honestly, layering woven and non-woven seems unnecessary. One good-quality non-woven geotextile usually does the trick for drainage without puddling.

Just my two cents from past projects...


Reply

Good points, though I've found layering woven and non-woven can actually help in some tricky spots - especially if your soil has a lot of clay. But yeah, definitely agree on the overlaps... learned that one the hard way myself, haha.


Reply

Interesting you mention layering woven and non-woven - I've tried that myself on a small shed foundation. My soil's mostly clay too, and the first time I skipped proper overlaps, water pooled right under the slab edges. Had to redo half the thing next spring... not fun. Now I always overlap generously and alternate layers, and it's held up pretty well since. Definitely worth the extra effort upfront to avoid headaches later.


Reply

"Had to redo half the thing next spring... not fun."

Yeah, learned that lesson myself the hard way. With clay soil, it's all about managing water flow. One thing I'd add - don't underestimate drainage around the perimeter either. I've found that even with perfect overlaps, if you don't give water somewhere else to go, it'll still find a way under your slab eventually. A simple French drain or gravel trench around the edges can save you from another "fun" weekend project down the line...


Reply

Good points on drainage, especially around clay soil. A French drain saved me headaches too - wish I'd put it in sooner.

"if you don't give water somewhere else to go, it'll still find a way under your slab eventually."

Ever tried adding landscape fabric under the gravel? Curious if others found it helpful or overkill...


Reply

Landscape fabric under gravel can be helpful, but honestly, it depends on your soil and drainage situation. I've used it a couple times - once it worked great, kept the gravel clean and prevented silt buildup. Another time, though, it seemed to clog up faster than expected and slowed drainage down. If your clay is really heavy, fabric might actually trap fine particles and cause issues later. I'd say it's not overkill exactly...just something to weigh carefully based on your specific conditions.


Reply

I totally get what you're saying about the fabric - it really can be hit or miss depending on your soil. I've had a similar experience myself. One thing that worked well for me, especially in heavier clay areas, was adding a thicker layer of larger gravel or crushed stone first before laying down the fabric. It created a bit more breathing room for water to drain through, and seemed to reduce clogging issues.

Also, if you're worried about fine particles clogging things up, you might consider skipping the fabric altogether and just going with a deeper gravel base. I've seen that approach work surprisingly well in some tricky drainage spots. Just make sure to compact each layer as you go - makes a huge difference in stability later on.

Either way, sounds like you're already thinking things through carefully...which is half the battle with DIY projects like this. Good luck!


Reply

"Also, if you're worried about fine particles clogging things up, you might consider skipping the fabric altogether and just going with a deeper gravel base."

Interesting point about skipping the fabric - I’ve seen that work well too, especially in areas prone to heavy rainfall. Personally, I lean towards using permeable materials whenever possible to keep things eco-friendly and sustainable. Have you ever experimented with recycled concrete or other reclaimed materials for your gravel base? Curious how that might affect drainage and stability...


Reply

I've actually tried recycled concrete on a couple of projects. Drainage-wise, it worked surprisingly well - maybe even better than standard gravel. Stability was solid too, but sorting out the larger chunks was a bit of a hassle...worth it though for the sustainability factor.


Reply

Totally agree on the drainage part - recycled concrete really surprised me too. Sorting chunks can be annoying, but honestly, once you get a system down, it's not so bad. Plus, knowing you're cutting waste feels pretty great...worth the extra effort for sure.


Reply

Yeah, recycled concrete's underrated. I remember a project where we reused chunks from an old driveway - initially thought it'd be a headache, but drainage improved noticeably. Bit of extra sweat, sure, but the results spoke for themselves.


Reply

"initially thought it'd be a headache, but drainage improved noticeably."

Interesting point about drainage - did you notice if the recycled concrete settled differently over time compared to fresh pours? I've been considering reusing some old patio slabs for a small shed foundation, mostly to save cash (because let's face it, concrete prices lately are no joke...). My main worry is uneven settling or cracking down the line. I've done DIY foundations before, but always with new mixes. Curious if anyone else has had long-term experience with recycled chunks holding up under weight. Would hate to save a few bucks now only to spend double later fixing it...


Reply

I reused some old concrete slabs from a driveway demo for my garden shed foundation about four years ago. Like you, I was worried about uneven settling or cracking, especially since I'd only worked with fresh pours before. Honestly, it turned out better than expected. I did notice a bit of initial settling in the first few months - nothing major, just slight adjustments - but after that, it's been rock solid. No noticeable cracks or shifting since then.

"initially thought it'd be a headache, but drainage improved noticeably."

This was my experience too. The gaps between recycled chunks actually seemed to help drainage quite a bit compared to my previous solid slab foundations. Just make sure you compact and level your base really well beforehand; that's probably what saved me from bigger issues down the line. Overall, I'd say go for it if you're comfortable with prep work and don't mind a little extra effort upfront.


Reply

Interesting perspective, but I'd be a bit cautious about relying too heavily on recycled slabs for drainage. I tried something similar a few years back, and while it initially seemed to help drainage, over time dirt and debris filled in the gaps. Eventually, those spaces that improved drainage ended up causing pooling issues after heavy rains. Maybe it depends on your local soil type or climate - I have pretty clay-heavy soil here, so that might've made things worse.

If you're considering this route, I'd suggest adding a layer of gravel or crushed stone beneath the slabs to maintain proper drainage long-term. It adds a little extra work upfront, but it saved me from having to redo the whole thing later on. Just something to keep in mind based on my own experience...


Reply

Good call on the gravel underneath - I learned that lesson the hard way too. Also, if your soil's clay-heavy, consider mixing in some coarse sand or organic matter...helps keep things draining smoothly and saves headaches later.


Reply

Yeah, clay soil can be a real pain...I had a similar issue when I built my shed. Wish I'd known about mixing in organic matter then - would've saved me from some swampy surprises down the road. Good tips!


Reply

Totally agree, clay can be tricky... Did you consider adding a gravel layer beneath the foundation for drainage? I've found it helps a ton with moisture issues, especially in areas prone to heavy rain. Saved me some headaches on past projects.


Reply

Yeah, gravel underneath definitely helps. I skipped it once thinking I'd save time... big mistake. Ended up dealing with moisture seeping in after heavy storms. Lesson learned the hard way, haha.


Reply
Scroll to Top