Custom homes discussions and local services.
My Adventure With DIY Concrete Foundations
Raised beds were my lifesaver too - felt like a total gardening hack at first, but hey, whatever works, right? Haven't tried cover crops yet either, though I've heard good things about clover...might give it a shot next year and see what happens.
Have you thought about using buckwheat as a cover crop instead of clover? Clover's great, but I've found buckwheat grows super fast and is fantastic at suppressing weeds. Plus, it breaks down quickly when you turn it under, so it's pretty convenient if you're short on time. I tried it last year between my raised beds, and it really helped keep things tidy without much fuss. Might be worth considering if you're experimenting next season...
Interesting idea about buckwheat - I hadn't really considered it before. I've mostly stuck with clover because it's familiar and seems reliable, but your point about buckwheat being quick-growing caught my attention.
"Plus, it breaks down quickly when you turn it under, so it's pretty convenient if you're short on time."
That's definitely appealing since I'm usually juggling multiple projects at once. Did you notice any issues with pests or wildlife being attracted to it? Might give it a shot next season just to see how it compares...
Buckwheat's been pretty hassle-free for me pest-wise. I did notice a few more bees buzzing around, but honestly, that's a plus in my book since it helps pollinate the garden. Deer didn't seem overly interested either - at least not compared to when I tried planting peas (total buffet disaster, lol). I'd say give it a go; it's low-risk enough that even if wildlife does nibble a bit, you're not losing much.
"Deer didn't seem overly interested either - at least not compared to when I tried planting peas (total buffet disaster, lol)."
Interesting, I've had deer issues with almost everything green so far. Did you use any specific fencing or repellents around the buckwheat, or was it just naturally unappealing to them?
Buckwheat seems naturally less appealing to deer, at least in my experience. I didn't use fencing or repellents around mine, and they mostly ignored it. Maybe the texture or taste isn't their favorite...either way, it worked out better than peas did!
I've noticed the same thing about buckwheat. Deer around here usually go nuts for anything green, but they barely touched mine last summer. Funny enough, they demolished my neighbor's beans just a few yards away...go figure. Maybe it's the bitterness or something? Either way, I'm sticking with buckwheat again this year - less hassle and it actually improved my soil quite a bit. Peas were tasty but definitely more trouble than they're worth with deer around.
"Either way, I'm sticking with buckwheat again this year - less hassle and it actually improved my soil quite a bit."
Totally agree with you on buckwheat being a solid choice. I've had similar experiences - deer seem to steer clear of mine too, but they'll happily munch on everything else nearby. Honestly, the soil improvement alone makes it worth planting again. Plus, it's pretty low-maintenance compared to peas or beans. If you're looking for another deer-resistant cover crop, maybe try hairy vetch? Worked wonders for me last season...
Buckwheat is great, no doubt, but I wouldn't completely write off peas or beans just yet. Last year, I experimented with field peas as a cover crop, and honestly, it turned out better than expected. Sure, they're a bit fussier at first, but once established, they really took off and added a ton of nitrogen back into the soil. My tomatoes this season are thriving like never before, and I'm pretty sure that's why.
Funny you mention deer resistance though - I must have some weird deer around here because they didn't seem interested in my peas at all. Maybe they had tastier options nearby? Who knows. But I did notice the rabbits were a different story... had to put up some temporary fencing to keep them from feasting.
Hairy vetch sounds intriguing, but I've heard mixed things about it being a bit invasive if you're not careful. Did you have any trouble managing it? I love the idea of trying new cover crops, but after my experience with mint (still pulling that stuff out years later...), I'm a little cautious about anything that might spread aggressively.
Anyway, buckwheat's definitely a solid choice - especially if you're looking for something quick and easy - but don't discount legumes entirely. They might surprise you.
Interesting points about legumes, but honestly, my experience with peas was a bit different. I tried them two seasons ago, and while they did add nitrogen, the hassle factor was pretty high for me. Between rabbits treating my garden like an all-you-can-eat buffet and the plants themselves struggling to get established in our clay-heavy soil, it felt like more trouble than it was worth.
Funny you mention hairy vetch - I gave that a shot last year too. It wasn't exactly invasive in my case, but it definitely had ambitions of world domination if left unchecked. Had to spend way more time than I'd planned keeping it from climbing over everything nearby. Still, I have to admit it did wonders for soil structure.
Buckwheat's been my go-to mostly because it's so low-maintenance and predictable. Maybe I'm just lazy or skeptical after past experiences (mint trauma is real!), but I'm hesitant to jump back into legumes anytime soon...
Interesting experiences with legumes, but I'm curious - have you tried crimson clover yet? I was skeptical too after peas turned into rabbit snacks and vetch went rogue on me, but crimson clover surprised me. It handled my clay soil pretty well, didn't attract as many critters, and wasn't nearly as aggressive as hairy vetch. Might be worth a shot if you're ever feeling brave enough to dip back into legumes...
I've got to admit, crimson clover surprised me too. After my fiasco with hairy vetch - honestly, that stuff took over faster than I could blink - I was pretty skeptical about legumes in general. But crimson clover was different. It didn't go wild and invade every corner of the yard, and it actually improved my heavy clay soil noticeably after just one season. Still, I wouldn't say it's totally critter-proof; rabbits mostly left it alone, but deer seemed intrigued enough to nibble occasionally.
One thing I'd suggest is planting it a bit thicker than recommended if you're aiming for weed suppression or erosion control. I found that sparse patches let weeds sneak through pretty easily. Overall though, it's been one of the few cover crops that's genuinely lived up to the hype for me...and trust me, I've tried plenty that haven't.
Funny you mention crimson clover - I had a similar experience with buckwheat. Thought it'd be a quick fix for erosion control around my DIY concrete foundation project, but it ended up patchy and weeds crept right back in. Your tip about planting thicker makes sense; wish I'd thought of that earlier. Might give crimson clover a shot next season, especially if it helps with clay soil...mine's practically concrete itself, haha. Did you prep your soil much beforehand, or just toss the seeds and hope for the best?
"Did you prep your soil much beforehand, or just toss the seeds and hope for the best?"
Honestly, I went with the "toss and pray" method at first - figured nature would sort itself out. Big mistake. After a season of patchy disappointment, I bit the bullet and lightly raked in some compost before reseeding thicker. Made a huge difference. Crimson clover's been solid for me on clay-heavy ground, but yeah, buckwheat was a bust here too... weeds loved it though, haha.
Interesting you mention crimson clover doing well on clay-heavy soil - I’ve been struggling with that myself. Did you find compost alone was enough to loosen things up, or did you also have to do some deeper tilling? I've heard mixed opinions about tilling clay soils, with some folks saying it helps drainage and others claiming it just compacts things even more in the long run. Curious if you've noticed any difference either way.
Also, speaking of buckwheat - did you try planting it at a specific time of year? I had a neighbor swear by planting it late summer as a quick cover crop, but when I tried it earlier in spring, weeds completely took over. Maybe timing matters more than I realized...
I've had mixed luck with tilling myself - did it once pretty deep, thinking it'd help loosen things up, but after a heavy rain it just turned into a brick-like mess. Compost and mulch layering seemed to work better, at least in my yard. As for buckwheat, your neighbor's onto something; late summer worked way better for me too. Tried spring planting once and weeds laughed me outta the garden... timing really matters.
"after a heavy rain it just turned into a brick-like mess."
Haha, sounds like my first attempt at prepping soil for a rain garden - ended up with something closer to pottery clay than planting medium. Curious though, have you tried mixing in sand or gravel to improve drainage? I've found layering compost and mulch helps, but adding some coarse material can really keep things from compacting again. Timing definitely matters, but sometimes tweaking the soil composition makes all the difference...
Been there myself - my first DIY concrete pad turned into a crumbly disaster after a storm. Agree on the sand suggestion, but I'd lean more toward crushed stone or gravel for foundations...sand can sometimes shift unpredictably under load. Keep at it though, you'll get the hang of it.
Definitely agree on the crushed stone or gravel recommendation - sand can indeed be tricky, especially if moisture levels aren't consistent. I've seen sand-based foundations shift dramatically after heavy rains, causing cracks and uneven settling that can be a nightmare to correct later.
One factor that hasn't come up yet is drainage. Did you consider incorporating any drainage solutions into your foundation design? In my experience, even a well-compacted gravel base can run into issues if water isn't directed away properly. A simple French drain or even just ensuring the ground slopes away from your pad can make a significant difference in longevity.
Also, curious about the concrete mix you used. Did you go with a standard pre-mixed bag or did you mix your own proportions? Sometimes, DIYers underestimate the importance of getting the water-to-cement ratio right. Too much water weakens the concrete significantly, causing it to crumble or flake over time. On my first project, I made the mistake of adding extra water to make the concrete easier to work with... seemed fine at first, but after a few months, surface flaking and cracking started showing up everywhere.
Another small detail worth mentioning - did you reinforce your pad with rebar or wire mesh? Even smaller pads benefit greatly from some form of reinforcement. It helps distribute weight evenly and reduces cracking from temperature fluctuations or minor ground shifts.
Either way, don't be discouraged by the setbacks. Concrete work has a definite learning curve, but each project gets easier and more intuitive.
Totally feel you on the drainage point. When I did my first DIY pad, I thought I'd covered everything - gravel base, rebar, careful mixing - but completely overlooked drainage. It wasn't even a huge slope or anything, just a slight dip nearby that I didn't think twice about. Sure enough, after the first big storm, water pooled around one side, and within a year I had noticeable cracking and settling. Learned the hard way that even a subtle slope matters.
Also, your comment about the water-to-cement ratio hits home. I remember thinking "just a little extra water won't hurt," because it made the concrete easier to spread. Big mistake... ended up with surface flaking and weak spots. Next project, I stuck strictly to the recommended ratio, even though it was tougher to work with at first. The difference was night and day - no cracks, no flaking, and still solid years later.
Definitely a learning curve, but each project gets smoother. Sounds like you're already picking up some valuable lessons, so hang in there.