I've actually experimented a bit with rounded-edge floats. They do glide slightly better on wetter mixes, less dragging overall. But honestly, it wasn't a huge difference—technique and concrete consistency seem to matter more than float shape, at least in my experience...
Interesting perspective, glad you shared that. I'm actually just getting into DIY concrete myself, so it's helpful to hear from someone who's tried different tools. I've been wondering if the shape of the float really made much difference—sounds like maybe not as much as I thought?
You mentioned technique and consistency being more important...which makes sense. But when you talk about consistency, do you mean wetter mixes are generally easier to handle, or is there a sweet spot that's neither too wet nor too dry? I guess what I'm asking is, how do you know when you've got the right mix? I've read a bunch of stuff online, but honestly, some of it feels contradictory or overly technical.
Also curious if you've noticed a big difference depending on weather conditions? I've heard humidity or temperature can affect how concrete behaves, even if your mix ratio stays the same. Have you experienced that yourself?
Either way, your insight makes me feel a bit less anxious about picking out tools. Seems like I shouldn't overthink it too much and just focus on getting comfortable with my mixing and floating techniques first...
"I've read a bunch of stuff online, but honestly, some of it feels contradictory or overly technical."
Yeah, I totally get that frustration—been there myself. In my experience, there's definitely a sweet spot with concrete consistency. Too wet and it weakens the mix, too dry and it's a nightmare to work with. Weather matters too; hot days can dry things out faster than you'd expect. Honestly though, you're right not to overthink tools—technique and practice make the biggest difference. You've got this.
Good points overall, though I'd add a couple things from my own projects:
- Don't underestimate prep work—making sure your forms are level and secure can save a ton of headaches later.
- Reinforcement matters more than you might think. Even basic rebar placement can significantly boost the strength of your foundation.
- And yeah, weather's sneaky... humidity can mess with curing times too, not just heat.
But honestly, trial and error is part of the DIY game. Sounds like you're on the right track.
Good reminders here, especially about humidity—I learned that the hard way refinishing a concrete countertop. Thought I had it timed perfectly, but nope... humidity threw everything off. Sounds like you're figuring things out pretty well though.
