Did you end up getting multiple quotes before deciding on shingles? I’m trying to figure out if it’s worth paying extra for a “name brand” installer or just going with a smaller local crew that seems to do solid work. Also, did you notice much of a difference in price between felt and synthetic underlayment? Every roofer I talk to has a different opinion, and I’m not sure what’s actually worth the money.
I’m trying to figure out if it’s worth paying extra for a “name brand” installer or just going with a smaller local crew that seems to do solid work.
- I got three quotes before picking my shingles. The price difference was bigger than I expected, honestly.
- Ended up going with a local crew. They weren’t the cheapest, but they had great reviews and actually took time to answer my (many) questions. The “name brand” company felt a bit pushy and their quote was almost $4k higher for basically the same materials.
- For underlayment, I noticed synthetic was about 2x the cost of felt, but every roofer swore by their own preference. One guy said felt is fine unless you’re in a super wet climate, another said synthetic is a must for longevity.
- I went with synthetic because our weather’s unpredictable and I figured it’s not something I want to cheap out on. But honestly, if you’re not in a crazy climate, felt might be just fine.
If you trust the local crew and they’ve got good references, I’d say don’t stress about the big name. Just make sure they’re insured and you’re comfortable with their communication style. That made all the difference for me.
If you trust the local crew and they’ve got good references, I’d say don’t stress about the big name.
I tend to agree, but I’d add—don’t underestimate the value of a detailed contract and warranty, regardless of who you pick. Local crews can be fantastic, but I’ve seen jobs where a handshake agreement led to headaches later. On underlayment, synthetic is almost always worth it for unpredictable weather. It’s not just about moisture—it resists tearing during install, which matters more than people think.
On underlayment, synthetic is almost always worth it for unpredictable weather.
I’m with you there—synthetic’s just tougher all around. That said, did anyone here actually have a warranty claim honored? I’ve heard stories where the fine print made it nearly impossible. Curious if that’s just bad luck or more common than folks think.
I’ve heard stories where the fine print made it nearly impossible.
That’s my worry too. Synthetic’s great, but I’ve seen warranties get voided over things like “improper ventilation” or using the wrong nails. Sometimes it feels like the warranty is more of a marketing tool than real protection. Anyone else try self-adhered underlayment? It’s pricier, but I’ve found it holds up better in weird weather swings and doesn’t rely as much on the paperwork.