Custom homes discussions and local services.
Need advice on replacing an old leaky roof
- Had to deal with something similar last year - old roof, mystery wires, and a couple of surprise pipes right where I didn’t want them.
- Here’s what worked for me (and kept costs down):
- Got the roofer and a handyman to walk the attic with me before demo. We flagged anything weird - wires, ducts, random pipes.
- Only moved what was absolutely necessary. Sometimes you can just add a junction box or reroute a short section instead of redoing everything.
- For HVAC, I asked if we could just insulate better around the ducts instead of moving them. Saved a chunk of change.
- Plumbing was trickier, but a plumber buddy said as long as vent stacks are clear and not leaking, you can often work around them.
- If you’re not sure what’s what, a quick consult with an electrician or plumber can be worth it. Sometimes they’ll just charge for an hour and give you peace of mind.
- I’d say don’t let the contractors talk you into moving stuff unless it’s really in the way or unsafe. Sometimes they overcomplicate things.
- Surprises are kind of inevitable, but a little planning up front kept my budget from totally blowing up. Good luck - hope you don’t find any squirrel nests like I did...
Had a similar mess when I did my roof - felt like every time we opened up a wall, there was some new “surprise” waiting. I agree, don’t let contractors talk you into moving stuff unless it’s actually blocking the work or a safety issue. Mine wanted to reroute half the attic wiring “just in case.” Ended up just labeling everything and only moving what had to go. Saved me a headache and a chunk of cash. Never did find any critters, but I did get a face full of 30-year-old insulation dust... wouldn’t recommend.
Yeah, I hear you on the “surprises.” Every time I’ve done a roof, there’s always something lurking under the shingles. I’m with you - don’t let them upsell on moving stuff unless it’s truly necessary. Some contractors just love to pad the bill. I’d rather deal with a little dust than a blown budget.
NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF
I get where you’re coming from about the “surprises.” It’s almost like contractors have a sixth sense for finding extra work once the shingles are off. I’ve had two roofs done over the years, and both times there was some “unexpected” rot or a couple of boards that “really should be replaced.” Sometimes it’s legit, but I’ve also seen them try to swap out stuff that looked perfectly fine just to bump up the invoice.
I’m all for keeping costs in check, but I do think there’s a line. If something is genuinely rotted or unsafe, it’s probably worth fixing while everything’s open. But moving furniture or covering every square inch of the attic? That feels like overkill unless you’ve got a real dust allergy or something valuable up there. I’d rather sweep up after than pay an extra few hundred bucks for “protection.”
One thing that helped me last time was asking for photos of any damage before they did extra work. Most reputable contractors don’t mind snapping a few pics - if they push back on that, it’s a red flag in my book. Also, getting a detailed estimate upfront (with line items for possible extras) made it easier to spot when they were trying to sneak in unnecessary stuff.
I guess my main takeaway is: trust your gut, but don’t be afraid to push back if something doesn’t add up. Contractors aren’t all out to get you, but some definitely see an old roof as an opportunity to pad their bottom line. A little skepticism goes a long way... and if you end up with some dust, well, that’s what vacuums are for.
But moving furniture or covering every square inch of the attic? That feels like overkill unless you’ve got a real dust allergy or something valuable up there.
I get where you’re coming from, but I’ll push back a bit - sometimes protecting the attic is worth it. I’ve seen insulation ruined and keepsakes trashed by falling debris because someone thought a little dust was “no big deal.” It’s not just about allergies or valuables; it’s about not turning a roof job into a cleanup nightmare. Spending a bit more upfront can save you a headache later, especially if you’ve got old wiring or delicate stuff up there. Just my two cents.
Honestly, I’ve seen both sides of this. On one hand, yeah, it can feel like overkill to wrap up every box and chair in the attic. But after watching a client’s vintage comic collection get showered in shingle grit (not pretty), I’m a little paranoid about dust and debris now. Even if you’re not storing family heirlooms up there, insulation is expensive to replace if it gets trashed. A few tarps and some prep work can save a lot of regret later... just depends how much you want to gamble with cleanup duty.
- Seen way too many attics trashed by roof jobs where folks thought “it’ll be fine.”
- Dust, nails, bits of shingle - stuff gets everywhere, and insulation’s a pain to clean or replace.
- I get why some people skip it if their attic’s empty, but honestly, even a quick layer of plastic sheeting helps.
- Had a client once who ignored the prep and ended up with fiberglass bits in every holiday box. Not fun.
- It’s not about being paranoid, just realistic. Prep takes an hour, cleanup can take days... your call.
Prep takes an hour, cleanup can take days... your call.
That’s a fair point. I’ve seen people underestimate just how much mess a roof replacement can make - especially with older homes where insulation is already fragile. I’ll admit, sometimes the prep feels like overkill, but it’s always the folks who skip it that regret it later. Plastic sheeting isn’t glamorous, but neither is picking shingle grit out of your stuff for months. Worth the hassle, in my experience.
Plastic sheeting isn’t glamorous, but neither is picking shingle grit out of your stuff for months.
- Totally agree on the plastic sheeting. I’ve seen dust get into closets and even drawers if you skip it.
- Curious - has anyone tried using zip walls or temporary barriers instead? Wondering if it’s worth the extra setup for bigger jobs.
Curious - has anyone tried using zip walls or temporary barriers instead? Wondering if it’s worth the extra setup for bigger jobs.
I’ve used zip walls on a couple of reno projects, and honestly, they’re a step up from just draping plastic everywhere. The zipper access is handy when you’re in and out a lot, and they seal better around the edges. For big jobs where you’re tearing off a whole roof or opening up ceilings, I’d say it’s worth the hassle - especially if you care about indoor air quality or have allergies in the house.
That said, for smaller fixes, I still just tape up plastic sheeting. It’s cheap and does the trick if you’re careful. But yeah, dust finds its way into every nook if you skip barriers... had to vacuum my sock drawer for weeks after one “quick” patch job. Not fun.
If you’re trying to keep things green, reusable zip wall panels are less wasteful than tossing plastic after every project. Just something to think about.
ZIP WALLS ARE A GAME CHANGER FOR BIG JOBS
I’m with you on the zip walls - they’re a lifesaver when you’re dealing with a full roof replacement. I’ve seen way too many “quick” plastic setups end up with dust everywhere, especially in older homes where you never know what’s lurking in the attic. The zipper access is a small thing but makes a huge difference when you’re hauling tools in and out. I will say, if you’re working solo or on a tight budget, the setup can feel like overkill, but for keeping the rest of the house livable, it’s worth it. Plus, less cleanup means more time for the fun stuff... like picking out new paint colors.
ZIP WALLS ARE A GAME CHANGER FOR BIG JOBS
Totally agree on the zip walls - worth every penny for keeping dust out of living spaces. When I did my roof, I skipped them to save a bit, but honestly, the cleanup took way longer than I expected. Did you find any tricks for sealing off HVAC vents during the work? That was my biggest headache... dust everywhere, even with plastic.
NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF
I get the appeal of zip walls, but man, those things add up fast when you’re trying to keep the budget in check. I’ve been there - staring at the price tag, thinking “Eh, plastic sheeting and painter’s tape will do the trick.” Spoiler: it sorta does, but you pay for it in time and dust bunnies later.
For the HVAC vents, here’s my step-by-step (learned the hard way after a kitchen reno went sideways):
1. Turn off your HVAC system if you can. Otherwise, you’re just blowing dust through the whole house no matter what you cover.
2. Get some heavy-duty contractor bags (the thick black ones). Cut them open so you have big sheets, then tape them over every vent opening with painter’s tape. Duct tape is tempting but can leave residue.
3. If you’re extra paranoid (which I am), stuff a towel or old t-shirt loosely inside the vent before taping over it. Just remember to pull it out when you’re done - ask me how I know...
4. For returns, do the same thing. Those seem to suck up every speck of dust in the county.
5. After the work, vacuum out the vents before turning the system back on. I skipped this once and ended up with dust blowing out for days.
Honestly, nothing’s perfect. Zip walls are slick but if you’re pinching pennies, doubling up on plastic and being a little obsessive with sealing edges goes a long way. Just budget extra time for cleanup - sometimes I think that’s the real cost nobody talks about.
And yeah, I’ve tried those magnetic vent covers too. They work okay for floor vents but not so much for ceiling ones. If anyone’s got a magic bullet for keeping dust out of light fixtures, I’m all ears...
NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF
Plastic sheeting and painter’s tape - been there, done that, and yeah, you’re right: it works, but it’s a pain. I’ve seen folks try to save a few bucks on dust control, only to spend way more time cleaning up later. Sometimes it’s just not worth the hassle.
On the roof replacement side, here’s how I usually tackle the mess and keep the chaos contained:
- Before demo, I’ll lay down drop cloths or even old tarps in the attic (if you have access). It catches a surprising amount of debris.
- For light fixtures, I’ll unscrew the covers and wrap them in plastic grocery bags or painter’s plastic. Not perfect, but it keeps the bulk of the grit out. Just don’t forget to take them off before flipping the lights back on - melted plastic smells awful.
- If you’re dealing with blown-in insulation up top, expect a mess no matter what. I’ve seen people try to vacuum as they go, but honestly, it just gets everywhere. Best bet is to do a deep clean after the roofers are done.
- On the HVAC stuff, your list is spot-on. Only thing I’d add: if you’ve got a filter at your return, swap it out after everything’s finished. Those things clog up fast with all the dust floating around.
One thing I’ll mildly disagree with - sometimes spending a little extra on containment (zip walls or even reusable dust barriers) pays off if you value your sanity. Especially if you’ve got pets or kids running around while the work’s happening.
Last tip: if you’re hiring out, ask the crew how they plan to protect your interiors. Some are great about it, others... not so much. Learned that one the hard way after finding shingle grit in my coffee maker.
Hope some of this helps. Roof projects are never fun, but keeping the mess under control makes a big difference.
NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF
You nailed it with the drop cloths and tarps - those things have saved me from hours of vacuuming attic insulation out of weird places. One thing I’d add: if you’ve got a lot of stuff stored up there, try to move it or at least cover it with old sheets. I once thought “eh, it’ll be fine,” and ended up picking shingle crumbs out of my camping gear for months. Also, if you’re around during demo, keep an eye on the crew’s path in and out - they can track a surprising amount of grit through the house. Not fun to find roof bits in your socks later...
Also, if you’re around during demo, keep an eye on the crew’s path in and out - they can track a surprising amount of grit through the house. Not fun to find roof bits in your socks later...
That’s a detail I hadn’t even considered - thanks for pointing it out. I’ve noticed contractors sometimes underestimate how much debris gets tracked around, especially if the weather’s bad and things get muddy. Did you find any way to minimize that, like temporary runners or shoe covers? I’m debating whether it’s worth investing in those sticky mats for entryways or if that’s overkill.
Did you find any way to minimize that, like temporary runners or shoe covers? I’m debating whether it’s worth investing in those sticky mats for entryways or if that’s overkill.
Honestly, I’ve tried a few things and it’s kind of a mixed bag. The sticky mats are great in theory, but unless you’re super strict about everyone using them (and changing them out often), they get gross fast and stop working. Plus, roof grit is heavier than regular dust, so it doesn’t always stick. I’d say they’re more useful for fine dust than chunks of shingle or nails.
What worked best for me was a combo of those cheap plastic runners from the hardware store and just being a bit of a nag about shoes. I laid runners down in the main traffic areas and taped the edges so they didn’t bunch up. Not pretty, but it saved my floors. Shoe covers are hit or miss - some crews will use them, others just ignore them or rip through them in an hour. If you’re around, you can ask them to use a specific door and keep the rest blocked off, which helps a lot.
One thing I learned the hard way: even with all that, you’ll still find random bits weeks later. I found a roofing nail in my laundry room sock drawer, no clue how it got there. Just part of the fun, I guess.
If you’re worried about mud, especially if it’s wet out, maybe throw down some old towels at the entry points too. They’re easy to swap out and toss in the wash. I wouldn’t go overboard with fancy stuff unless you’ve got really nice floors you’re trying to protect. Most of it is just about damage control and lowering your expectations a bit during demo. It’s messy work, no way around it.
REPLACING AN OLD ROOF IS MESSIER THAN I EXPECTED
This is so relatable. We just went through our first big reno and I was shocked by how much stuff ended up everywhere, even with all my “preparation.” I totally get the urge to try every trick in the book to keep things clean, but it’s like you said - some of it just comes down to accepting a bit of chaos for a while.
I tried sticky mats too, thinking they’d be a game changer, but honestly, they didn’t do much for the bigger debris. I was also surprised how quickly they looked gross, and then I felt like I was just tracking the mess around anyway. I ended up using those plastic runners and some old towels, and it helped a lot more than I expected. I’m not sure I’d bother with the fancy stuff unless you’ve got really delicate flooring or something you’re super attached to.
It’s funny you mention finding nails in weird places. I found a shingle granule in my coffee mug weeks after the roofers left. No clue how it got there. I guess it’s just part of the experience? At least now I know to expect it.
I think you’re on the right track with focusing on the main traffic areas and just being realistic about what you can control. It’s easy to get caught up in wanting everything perfect, but sometimes you just have to let go a little. The important thing is you’re getting the leak fixed, and that’s huge. The mess is temporary, but a dry house is forever (or at least for a good long while).
Hang in there - it’ll be worth it when you’re not worrying about buckets under the ceiling every time it rains.
It’s funny you mention finding nails in weird places. I found a shingle granule in my coffee mug weeks after the roofers left.
This made me laugh - last year, I kept finding those little roofing nails in my flowerbeds for months. Even after I thought I’d done a thorough sweep, I’d step on one barefoot and remember, “oh right, the roof.” I tried tarps and runners too, but honestly, there’s only so much you can do. I agree, the mess is temporary. Once that first heavy rain hits and you realize you’re not running for buckets, it feels totally worth it.
I swear, those nails are like glitter - once they’re in your yard, you’ll be finding them for ages. I had a similar experience after a cedar shake replacement. Even with the crew’s magnetic sweep, I still found a few strays in the grass months later. It’s almost like a rite of passage for homeowners.
I do think the payoff outweighs the hassle, though. There’s something oddly satisfying about hearing rain on a new roof and knowing you don’t have to worry about leaks. Out of curiosity, did anyone here opt for any kind of underlayment upgrade or specialty shingles? I debated going with a synthetic underlayment instead of felt, but wasn’t sure if it was worth the extra cost. Curious if anyone noticed a difference in noise or insulation after their roof was done.