Custom homes discussions and local services.
Need advice on replacing an old leaky roof
NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF
Flashing issues are sneaky - seen more leaks from bad flashing than anything else. People always blame the shingles, but it’s usually the details that get missed. Skylights... yeah, they look great in magazines, but unless you want to be up there with a caulk gun every spring, I’d skip them. I’ve had clients swear they’ll keep up with maintenance, then call me two years later with water stains on the ceiling.
Drip edge is one of those things folks try to save a few bucks on and regret it fast. Water finds its way into everything if you let it. Ridge vents are solid - just make sure your soffits are clear or you’re not getting much airflow. And underlayment? The upgraded stuff is worth it, especially if you’re in an area that gets wild weather swings. Cheap felt just doesn’t cut it anymore.
If you’re already tearing off the old roof, might as well do it right the first time. Fixing shortcuts later costs way more than doing it right up front.
Drip edge is one of those things folks try to save a few bucks on and regret it fast.
Had a client who skipped the drip edge - said the overhang was “enough.” Two years later, fascia board was rotted out. It’s always the little details that cost you big down the line.
It’s always the little details that cost you big down the line.
I get what you’re saying, but is it always so black and white? I’ve seen a few jobs where the overhang actually did fine - maybe just lucky weather? Still, as someone who’s seen water stains creep inside from bad flashing, I’d rather not risk it. Is drip edge really that pricey to add, though? Sometimes contractors make it sound like a huge upcharge.
Is drip edge really that pricey to add, though? Sometimes contractors make it sound like a huge upcharge.
I’ve wondered the same thing. When I replaced my garage roof, the contractor made drip edge sound like some luxury add-on, but the actual material cost was pretty minimal. Labor might bump it up a bit, but honestly, peace of mind is worth a little extra. I get wanting to save where you can, but those “little details” really do pay off in the long run - especially if you’re on a tight budget and can’t afford surprise repairs later. Sometimes it’s about investing smart, not just spending less.
Totally agree - those little details like drip edge can seem minor until you’re chasing water stains a year later. I’ve seen clients skip it to save a few bucks, only to regret it when fascia boards rot out. Sometimes the “boring” stuff is what keeps everything else looking good.
NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF
I get where you’re coming from about drip edge, but I’ll be honest - I’ve done two roofs now (my own and my brother’s) and skipped the drip edge both times. We used architectural shingles with a good overhang and made sure the underlayment wrapped right over the edge. Five years later, no water stains, no rot, nothing weird on the fascia. Maybe we just got lucky with our climate? We’re in a pretty dry area most of the year.
That said, I wouldn’t recommend skipping it for everyone. If you’re somewhere with heavy rain or snow melt, yeah, probably not worth taking that risk. But sometimes these “must-have” details get pushed hard by contractors because it’s easier to do everything by the book than to assess what actually matters for each house. Not saying drip edge is useless - it’s just not always as critical as people make it out to be.
If you do decide to skip it (not saying you should!), at least make sure your shingles hang over enough and your underlayment is solidly installed. And check your gutters - if they’re clogged or pulling away from the fascia, water will find a way in no matter what you do up top.
Anyway, just wanted to throw in a different perspective. Sometimes following every single step isn’t necessary if you know your local conditions and keep an eye on things after the fact.
NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF
sometimes these “must-have” details get pushed hard by contractors because it’s easier to do everything by the book than to assess what actually matters for each house
- Totally get this. Sometimes, “by the book” just means “covering all bases,” but not every base is in play, you know?
- I’ve skipped drip edge on a shed before - dry climate, barely any rain - no problems after 8 years. But on my main house? Wouldn’t risk it. Murphy’s Law loves a roof.
- If you’re rolling the dice, at least double-check your shingle overhang and keep those gutters in check. Water’s sneaky.
- Honestly, half the battle is just keeping an eye out for weird spots or leaks after storms... roofs are like toddlers: turn your back and they’ll find trouble.
NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF
I get the urge to skip some “extras,” but honestly, cutting corners on a roof can come back to haunt you - especially if you ever plan to sell. Inspectors love to flag missing drip edges or improper flashing, even if you’ve never had a leak. I’ve seen folks lose serious resale value over stuff that seemed minor at install time. If you’re already investing in a new roof, might as well do it right and not have to think about it again for decades. Peace of mind’s worth a lot, at least for me.
NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF
- You’re spot on about not skipping the “little” stuff. Drip edge, ice & water shield, proper flashing - those aren’t just upsells, they’re what keep you from dealing with headaches later.
- I’ve tried to save a few bucks in the past by skipping underlayment on a shed roof. Regretted it after the first big rain.
- If you’re already tearing off the old roof, it’s worth doing it right. You’ll sleep better knowing you won’t have to mess with it again for ages.
- Even if you don’t plan to sell soon, a solid roof just makes life easier. No one likes surprise leaks in the middle of winter...
NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF
- I get wanting to do every single upgrade, but sometimes budgets just don’t stretch that far. If you have to pick, focus on what actually protects the interior - ice & water shield near eaves and valleys is non-negotiable, but I’ve seen people go overboard with extras that don’t add much.
- Not every home absolutely needs the most expensive underlayment or all the bells and whistles. Depends on your climate and how your attic’s vented.
- If you’re planning any ceiling or lighting updates inside, coordinate now - last thing you want is to patch up drywall after a new roof install. Learned that one the hard way...
NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF
- I hear you on not needing every fancy upgrade. Last time I did a roof, I got talked into some “premium” underlayment that cost a fortune and honestly, didn’t notice a difference. Ice & water shield at the eaves is legit, though - don’t skip it, especially if you get snow. If you’re redoing anything inside, schedule it together or you’ll end up chasing your own tail with patching. Learned that juggling act the messy way...
Ice & water shield at the eaves is legit, though - don’t skip it, especially if you get snow.
That’s spot on. I’ve seen too many folks try to save a few bucks by skipping the ice & water shield, only to end up with leaks right where the roof meets the gutters. It’s not worth the headache, especially in colder climates.
I do have to push back a bit on the underlayment, though. I’ve worked on a few projects where the “premium” stuff actually made a difference - mainly on low-slope roofs or spots that see a lot of wind-driven rain. But for a typical pitched roof? Standard synthetic usually does the job just fine.
One thing I always ask: are you planning to change out any skylights or vents while you’re at it? I’ve had clients regret not doing those at the same time, since cutting into a brand new roof later is just...painful. And yeah, if you’re touching ceilings or insulation inside, try to coordinate. Nothing worse than patching drywall twice because of poor timing.
Curious - what kind of roof are you replacing? Shingles, metal, something else? Sometimes the material choice changes what’s worth upgrading.
Had a project last winter where skipping the ice & water shield turned into a nightmare - ice dams everywhere, and water found every weak spot. I’d echo the skylight/vent advice too. Had a client who didn’t swap an old vent, and sure enough, it leaked the next season. If you’re already tearing things up, might as well do it right the first time. Material-wise, I’ve seen metal roofs handle snow better, but they’re not for everyone. Shingles are fine if you get the details right.
If you’re already tearing things up, might as well do it right the first time.
Couldn’t agree more. Cutting corners on roof work just isn’t worth it. I’ve seen too many “quick fixes” turn into expensive headaches. Metal roofs are great for snow, but yeah, they’re not everyone’s cup of tea. If you stick with shingles, just make sure the underlayment and flashing are solid - those details make all the difference.
Couldn’t agree more about not cutting corners - seen too many “band-aid” jobs end up being way pricier down the road. If you’re tackling a full roof replacement, it’s honestly the perfect chance to get every detail right and maybe even add a bit of luxury. Here’s how I’d approach it:
First, pick materials that’ll last and look good - sometimes architectural shingles are worth the upgrade for both curb appeal and durability. Next, don’t skimp on underlayment; synthetic options can be a game-changer for moisture protection. Flashing is one of those things people overlook but it’s the difference between “dry and cozy” or “calling the roofer back next spring.”
I know metal roofs are polarizing - I’m personally a fan for modern homes, but they’re not always the vibe for everyone or every neighborhood. If you go with shingles, maybe think about adding some accent copper flashing or even a skylight if you’re feeling bold. It’s your home, after all... might as well make it something you love.
It’s a lot of work now, but trust me, when you hear rain pounding and don’t have to worry about leaks, it’ll all feel worth it.
Title: Need advice on replacing an old leaky roof
Totally agree about not skimping on underlayment - I've seen too many expensive homes with gorgeous shingles but terrible moisture issues underneath. One thing I'd add: pay attention to attic ventilation while you're at it. It’s not glamorous, but good airflow can make a huge difference in longevity and comfort. I went with standing seam metal on my last project, and while it was pricey, the energy savings and low maintenance have been worth every penny. Not for everyone, but if you’re staying long-term, it’s worth considering.
I went with standing seam metal on my last project, and while it was pricey, the energy savings and low maintenance have been worth every penny. Not for everyone, but if you’re staying long-term, it’s worth considering.
I get the appeal of metal roofs, but honestly, I couldn’t justify the upfront cost when we built last year. We went with architectural shingles and invested more in ice/water shield and ridge vents. No regrets so far - plus, repairs are way easier if a branch comes down.
NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF
Interesting to see both sides here. I’ve been weighing the same options for our place, and honestly, the up-front cost of metal is a tough pill to swallow. But then again, I keep hearing about the long-term savings and how you basically never have to think about it again. I’m curious - has anyone actually tracked their energy bills before and after switching to metal? I’ve seen claims about better insulation and reflectivity, but I wonder how much of that is marketing versus real-world numbers.
On the other hand, architectural shingles seem like a solid middle ground. They look good, aren’t as basic as the old 3-tabs, and like you said, repairs are way less intimidating. I had a friend with a metal roof who had to call in a specialist just to fix a small dent from hail. That’s not something I’d want to deal with every time a storm rolls through.
I guess my question is: for those who went with shingles but invested in higher-end underlayment or ventilation - have you noticed any downsides over time? Any regrets about not going metal? And for the folks who did go metal, did you notice any noise issues during heavy rain or hail? My partner’s convinced it’ll sound like living inside a drum set...
It feels like there’s no perfect answer here, just trade-offs depending on what matters most - cost, aesthetics, hassle factor. Anyone ever try one of those composite or synthetic options? Are they just marketing hype or actually worth considering?
NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF
I get the hesitation on metal, but honestly, I think the noise thing is overblown - modern installs usually have solid sheathing and insulation that cut way down on the drum effect. What bugs me more about shingles is how fast they can look tired, especially in harsh sun or after a couple storms. Composite options are interesting, though... I’ve seen some that mimic slate or shake and hold up surprisingly well, but yeah, the price tag can be wild. Still, if you’re planning to stay put for decades, it might be worth stretching the budget.
NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF
I totally get the concern about shingles looking worn out fast - had a client who went with architectural shingles, and within five years, they looked way older than they should’ve. We ended up doing a composite shake on my own place last year. Pricey, yeah, but honestly, it’s holding up beautifully and the curb appeal is next level. If you’re planning to stay long-term, I’d lean toward something that’ll still look good in 15-20 years. The upfront cost stings, but you don’t have to think about it again for ages.