Custom homes discussions and local services.

Need advice on replacing an old leaky roof

1,744 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF

I totally get caring about the style - my partner and I went back and forth on colors for weeks. Ended up with architectural shingles too, mostly because they looked decent and didn’t blow our budget. We almost skipped the “approved” underlayment to save a bit, but our neighbor did that and had a nightmare with their warranty later. Sometimes it’s worth following the rules, even if it feels like overkill at the time. The impact-rated shingles are tempting, but we gambled on regular ones since hail’s not a huge thing here... fingers crossed that doesn’t come back to bite us.


Reply

NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF

The underlayment issue is interesting - I’ve been reading up on that, and it seems like one of those things people don’t notice until there’s a problem. I’m in the middle of planning our first roof replacement, and honestly, the “approved” materials lists feel a bit overbearing at first glance, but I get why they exist. My builder warned me that skipping something as basic as the right underlayment could void the warranty or even cause insurance headaches if there’s water damage down the line. It’s frustrating to pay for things you can’t even see, but I guess it’s like insulation or wiring - better to do it right once.

On the shingle choice, I went back and forth on impact-rated versus standard too. We’re not in a hail-prone area either, but I started wondering about resale value and if buyers would care about that kind of upgrade. In the end, I’m leaning toward regular architectural shingles since they look better than 3-tab and seem to last longer. The color debate is real though - my partner wants something bold and I’m more into neutrals, so we’re probably going to end up somewhere in between.

One thing my neighbor mentioned was making sure you get photos of each stage of installation. He had trouble getting his warranty honored because he didn’t have proof that the contractor actually used all the specified materials. Seems paranoid, but after hearing his story, I’ll probably ask for a few progress pics just in case.

It’s weird how much goes into something as basic as a new roof...and how many small choices can come back to haunt you if you cut corners. At least with architectural shingles you get some style without totally blowing your budget - that was my main concern too.


Reply

It’s frustrating to pay for things you can’t even see, but I guess it’s like insulation or wiring - better to do it right once.

Totally relate to this. We just did our roof last year and the underlayment cost made me wince, but our neighbor skipped it and now has leaks again. Did you get quotes on synthetic vs. felt underlayment? I was surprised how much the price jumped, but everyone swore by synthetic. Still not sure if it was worth the extra, honestly.

On colors - my partner picked a “charcoal blend” and I was worried it’d look too dark, but now I barely notice. Does anyone actually care about shingle color after a month or two?


Reply

- Underlayment is one of those “invisible” upgrades that always feels like a splurge, but when it’s storming out, you’re glad it’s there.
- I’ve seen synthetic hold up way better in humid climates - less curling and weird smells over time. The upfront cost stings, but you probably won’t have to think about it again for decades.
- Shingle color...honestly, most people forget what they picked after a few weeks. Unless it’s neon green or something wild, it just blends into the background. That said, lighter shades can make a house look bigger from the street - just a little trick I’ve noticed.


Reply

NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF

That’s a good point about underlayment - when you’re on a tight budget, it’s tempting to skip the “invisible” stuff, but I’ve regretted cutting corners there before. The peace of mind during a storm is worth it. I used synthetic last time and yeah, the upfront cost hurt, but I haven’t had to mess with it since. As for shingle color, I stressed over it way too much...now I barely notice. Go with what feels right and don’t overthink it. You’re making smart choices here.


Reply

NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF

You’re spot on about underlayment - skipping it’s just asking for trouble down the line. Here’s how I usually approach it: 1) Strip everything down to the decking, check for rot, and replace any bad wood. 2) Go with a high-quality synthetic underlayment; it’s pricier but you won’t be patching leaks every season. 3) For shingles, lighter colors actually help with heat if you’re in a sunny area, but honestly, after a month you’ll forget what you picked. Don’t sweat the color too much...focus on the build quality and details like flashing. That’s where the real headaches come from if you cut corners.


Reply

NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF

Don’t sweat the color too much...focus on the build quality and details like flashing. That’s where the real headaches come from if you cut corners.

Couldn’t agree more about the flashing - seen way too many “new” roofs start leaking just because someone got lazy with the details around chimneys or valleys. I’d even say, if you’re hiring it out, ask them specifically how they handle those tricky spots. Some crews just slap on a bit of caulk and call it a day, which is a recipe for callbacks.

One thing I’d add: ventilation. Folks get so focused on shingles and underlayment that they forget about airflow in the attic. If your old roof was leaking, there’s a chance moisture’s been building up inside too. I’ve had clients who replaced their whole roof but still ended up with moldy rafters because the vents were clogged or undersized. Not fun.

Curious - what kind of decking do you have under there? Plywood holds up better than old plank boards, but sometimes you don’t know until you tear into it. If you find a lot of rot, it might be worth upgrading while you’re at it. Costs a bit more upfront but saves headaches later.

Also, are you in an area that gets ice dams? If so, ice & water shield along the eaves is a must. I’ve seen folks try to save money by skipping it, and every spring they’re back up there with buckets.

What’s your timeline looking like? Sometimes waiting for a dry spell makes all the difference, especially if you’re doing any of it yourself.


Reply

Totally agree about the ventilation - when we moved in, I didn’t even realize how much that mattered until we found some mildew in the attic.

“If your old roof was leaking, there’s a chance moisture’s been building up inside too.”
Ended up adding a ridge vent and it made a huge difference. Also, I’d say don’t stress if you find some decking that needs replacing. We had to swap out a few sheets of plywood and it wasn’t as big a deal as I thought. Worth it for peace of mind.


Reply

Title: Need advice on replacing an old leaky roof

Yeah, ventilation’s one of those things that doesn’t get enough attention until you’re dealing with the aftermath. I’ve seen a lot of folks focus on shingles or flashing, but skip over airflow and end up with moldy insulation or warped decking. Had a job last year where the homeowner was convinced all he needed was new shingles - turns out, half his attic was sweating because the vents were basically useless. Ridge vent fixed it, but not before we had to rip out a bunch of soggy OSB.

Swapping out decking isn’t the end of the world, like you said. It’s messy and adds a bit to the bill, but honestly, it’s way better than letting soft spots go and ending up with a trampoline for a roof. I’d rather see someone just bite the bullet and do it right than patch over rot and hope for the best.

One thing I’d add - sometimes people get talked into “upgrading” with fancy underlayments or ice shields everywhere. Not saying they’re bad, but if your roof’s got proper slope and ventilation, you don’t always need to go overboard. I’ve seen more than a few projects where folks spent big on bells and whistles but ignored basic airflow...and still ended up with problems.

Anyway, yeah, don’t freak out about some bad decking. Just make sure whoever’s doing the work actually checks for hidden damage instead of just slapping new shingles on top. That’s where corners get cut and headaches start later.


Reply

I get where you’re coming from, but I’d actually push back a bit on the “don’t always need to go overboard” part. Sometimes those “bells and whistles” like premium underlayment or full ice shield coverage are what set a luxury roof apart - especially if you’re in an area with wild weather swings or want that peace of mind for decades.

-

“if your roof’s got proper slope and ventilation, you don’t always need to go overboard.”

- True, but high-end homes often call for that extra layer of protection. It’s not just about function, it’s about future-proofing and resale value.
- I’ve seen folks regret skipping the upgrades when a freak storm hits or they try to sell and buyers expect top-tier everything.
- Sometimes investing in the “extras” is less about necessity and more about elevating the whole experience. Just my two cents.


Reply

“I’ve seen folks regret skipping the upgrades when a freak storm hits or they try to sell and buyers expect top-tier everything.”

That hits home. When we built last year, I thought the fancy ice shield was overkill, but after that insane hailstorm in March, I was glad we went for it. It’s not just about resale - sometimes it’s just about not stressing every time the weather app pings.


Reply

- Upgrades can feel like overkill until you’re staring at water stains on your ceiling.
- Ice/water shield is one of those things you only appreciate after the first big storm - totally worth it in my book.
- If you’re replacing an old leaky roof, I’d look at synthetic underlayment and proper ventilation too. Those details make a huge difference long-term.
- Not everyone needs the “top-tier everything,” but cutting corners on weatherproofing is where folks usually regret it... seen it too many times.
- Peace of mind during storm season? That’s hard to put a price on.


Reply

TOPIC: Need advice on replacing an old leaky roof

Upgrades can feel like overkill until you’re staring at water stains on your ceiling.

Ain’t that the truth. I used to roll my eyes at all the “premium” options when we did our first roof, figured the basic stuff would be fine. Fast forward a few years and I’m dragging buckets out every time it rains. Ended up costing more in repairs than if I’d just gone with better underlayment and flashing from the start.

I get being skeptical about all the upsells - roofers love to pad the bill. But honestly, things like ice/water shield and synthetic underlayment aren’t just marketing fluff. After we finally bit the bullet and redid ours with those, it’s been solid through some nasty storms. No more surprise leaks or weird drafts.

One thing I’d add: ventilation is easy to overlook but makes a huge difference. Our attic used to get swampy in summer, which just made everything worse. Once we got proper vents in, not only did it help with moisture, but our AC didn’t have to work as hard either.

I wouldn’t say you need to go for every single upgrade they offer - some of it really is overkill depending on your climate and house. But skimping on weatherproofing is where most folks end up regretting it, like you said. Peace of mind during storm season is worth a lot, especially if you’ve ever had to mop up after a midnight downpour.

If you’re on the fence about spending a bit more now, just remember how much hassle and money it can save you down the line. Learned that one the hard way...


Reply

TOPIC: Need advice on replacing an old leaky roof

I hear you on the peace of mind, but I’ve seen plenty of folks go all-in on upgrades that didn’t really fit their situation. Sometimes it’s less about the fanciest materials and more about who’s swinging the hammer. Had a project last year - basic shingles, nothing fancy, but the crew was top-notch and paid attention to every detail. That roof’s holding up better than some “premium” ones I’ve seen slapped together in a rush.

Not saying skip weatherproofing, but sometimes the basics done right are just as good as the bells and whistles. Just my two cents from watching a lot of roofs go up (and come down) over the years...


Reply

TOPIC: Need advice on replacing an old leaky roof

I’m with you on not getting dazzled by the “latest and greatest” roofing trends. I’ve seen people pick fancy tiles that look great in catalogs but clash with the rest of their house - or worse, don’t actually solve the leak. My step-by-step: 1) Figure out what’s actually causing the leak (sometimes it’s flashing, not the shingles). 2) Pick a material that fits your home’s style and climate - no point in metal if you’re in a hail-prone area. 3) Vet your crew like you’d vet a babysitter. I’d rather have basic shingles installed by someone who cares than a “designer” roof done by folks who rush. Sometimes boring is beautiful... and dry.


Reply

TOPIC: Need advice on replacing an old leaky roof

Totally agree about not chasing trends just for the sake of it - seen way too many mismatched roofs that just look off. Curious though, has anyone here tried going a bit greener, like cool roofs or even solar tiles? Wondering if those actually hold up or if it’s more hassle than it’s worth.


Reply

TOPIC: Need advice on replacing an old leaky roof

Going greener with your roof is actually a solid move, not just a trend. Here’s what I’ve seen:

- Cool roofs (white or reflective coatings) really do help with summer temps - my AC bills dropped noticeably after switching.
- Solar tiles are pricier upfront and can be trickier to install, but if you’re planning to stay put for a while, the payoff’s real. Maintenance isn’t much more than regular panels.
- Both options hold up well if you pick reputable brands and installers. Just don’t cheap out on labor.

Honestly, it’s less hassle than people think, and you’ll feel good about it every time the sun’s beating down.


Reply

Cool roofs (white or reflective coatings) really do help with summer temps - my AC bills dropped noticeably after switching.

That lines up with what I've read, though I’ve always wondered how much difference it actually makes in practice. Did you notice any downsides with the cool roof - like more frequent cleaning or issues with algae? I’ve heard some folks complain about dirt buildup making them less effective over time, especially in areas with a lot of trees.

On the solar tile front, I’m curious if you had to upgrade any electrical systems to handle the new setup. I know some older homes need panel upgrades before adding solar, which can add to the cost. For anyone else who’s gone this route, did you run into any surprises during install? Just weighing if it’s worth the hassle compared to sticking with a standard shingle and maybe adding panels later.


Reply

COOL ROOFS VS. STANDARD SHINGLES - IS IT REALLY WORTH IT?

I’ve installed a fair number of cool roofs, and while they do help with summer cooling, the benefits can be a bit overstated depending on your climate and how much direct sun your roof gets. In shaded areas or spots with heavy tree cover, you’re right - dirt and algae can build up faster, which cuts down on reflectivity unless you’re willing to clean it regularly. Some clients end up frustrated by the maintenance.

On the solar tile side, electrical upgrades are almost always needed for older homes - sometimes it’s just a panel swap, but I’ve seen full rewires needed if the existing system is really outdated. That can add a few thousand to the project, which surprises folks who budgeted just for the roof itself. Honestly, unless you’re set on an integrated look, standard shingles plus traditional panels are usually less hassle and easier to maintain long-term.


Reply

“unless you’re set on an integrated look, standard shingles plus traditional panels are usually less hassle and easier to maintain long-term.”

- Visually, cool roofs can look a bit stark - especially if your home’s style leans warm or classic. I’ve seen clients go for them and then wish they’d picked something that blended better with their exterior palette.
- Maintenance is definitely a thing. If you’re not into climbing up there to scrub off algae, the “cool” factor fades pretty quick (literally and figuratively).
- On the other hand, standard shingles give you more color options and textures. You can coordinate with trim or even play up contrast for curb appeal.
- Solar tiles are sleek, but I’ve watched projects balloon in cost because of electrical surprises. Not fun when you’re already stressed about leaks.
- If you’re thinking resale value, sometimes buyers care more about the look than the energy savings - depends on your neighborhood vibe.

Curious - are you planning to change your home’s exterior color scheme or keep things as they are? That might tip the scale one way or another.


Reply
Scroll to Top