Custom homes discussions and local services.

Need advice on replacing an old leaky roof

1,744 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

You're spot-on about debris buildup - no roof material completely solves that issue. A leaf blower is definitely handy, but if you want to cut down ladder time, maybe consider gutter guards? I've seen them help clients quite a bit, though they're not 100% maintenance-free either. Still, they can save you from climbing up there every weekend in fall. Whatever you decide, just remember every home has its quirks...you're doing great thinking this through carefully.


Reply

Great points - gutter guards are definitely helpful, but yeah, they're not a magic bullet. I've seen some homes where debris still sneaks in, especially those tiny pine needles...they can be a real pain.

A few things to mull over might be:
- Have you thought about tweaking your landscape a bit? Sometimes trimming back or even swapping out certain trees can make a big difference.
- Also, roof slope matters - steeper roofs naturally shed debris better. Not always practical to change slope, but if you're already replacing the roof anyway, could be worth considering.
- Lastly, material color can impact how visible debris buildup is. Darker shingles might hide stains but show leaves more clearly; lighter colors do the opposite. Any preference there?

Every decision's got trade-offs, but it sounds like you're on the right track. Curious if you've looked into any of these angles yet?


Reply

"Sometimes trimming back or even swapping out certain trees can make a big difference."

That's spot-on advice. We had a similar issue at our last place - beautiful old oak trees, but man, the leaves and acorns were relentless. Eventually, we trimmed back some branches closest to the roofline, and it helped a ton. Still, I kinda miss the shade they provided... Have you thought about balancing tree coverage with sunlight exposure for energy efficiency? Might be another angle worth considering.


Reply

Trimming back branches definitely helps, but it's also worth thinking about the type of trees you have around the house. At our previous home, we had these gorgeous maples - beautiful colors in fall, but they dropped leaves like crazy. After replacing our roof (which was a nightmare with all those leaves clogging gutters), we decided to swap out one of the maples for something smaller and less messy. Ended up going with a dogwood - it still gave us some shade and looked great, but way fewer leaves to deal with.

Also, good point about energy efficiency. Have you considered how your roofing material choice might factor into that? We went with lighter-colored shingles last time around, and it made a noticeable difference in keeping the attic cooler during summer months. Not sure if you're leaning toward shingles or maybe metal roofing - but metal roofs can reflect heat pretty well too, depending on the color and finish.

Another thing to think about is gutter guards. I know they're not exactly glamorous (trust me, no one's ever said "wow, nice gutter guards!" 😂), but they really cut down maintenance if you're dealing with lots of tree debris. Just something practical to toss into the mix while you're planning out the roof replacement.

Anyway, sounds like you've got some good ideas already - hope it all goes smoothly!


Reply

"Ended up going with a dogwood - it still gave us some shade and looked great, but way fewer leaves to deal with."

Dogwoods are a solid choice - nice balance between aesthetics and practicality. Good call on the gutter guards too; they're underrated for sure. One thing I'd add is ventilation. Proper attic ventilation can really extend your roof's lifespan and boost energy efficiency. Sounds like you're already thinking things through pretty thoroughly, though... good luck with the project!


Reply

Dogwoods do look great, but honestly, I've had mixed experiences with them near roofs. Had one at my old place - branches were surprisingly brittle and snapped easily during storms. Maybe keep an eye on trimming regularly to avoid roof damage down the line?


Reply

Dogwoods can definitely be tricky near roofs - I've noticed the same brittleness with some maples around my house. Do you think it's more about species choice or just consistent pruning? I've been debating swapping out a couple trees myself, but it's hard giving up that shade in the summer... Have you had better luck with other types of trees near your roofline?


Reply

I've noticed similar issues with maples myself. In my experience, consistent pruning helps, but species choice probably matters more long-term. Oaks seem sturdier near rooflines, though they grow slower... definitely a trade-off when you're thinking about shade and budget.


Reply

"Oaks seem sturdier near rooflines, though they grow slower... definitely a trade-off when you're thinking about shade and budget."

Good point about oaks - I've found them reliable over the years, especially when planning developments near residential structures. While their slow growth can be frustrating initially, the long-term benefits in terms of reduced maintenance and fewer roofing issues often outweigh the upfront patience required. Another thing to consider is root systems; maples can sometimes cause foundation issues down the line, whereas oaks typically have deeper roots. Just something else to factor into your decision-making process.


Reply

"Another thing to consider is root systems; maples can sometimes cause foundation issues down the line, whereas oaks typically have deeper roots."

Good call about the roots. When we built our place, we went with maples for quicker shade (rookie move, I know...), and now we're dealing with roots pushing up the driveway. Oaks might've saved us some headaches, even if it meant waiting a bit longer for shade. Lesson learned the hard way - patience pays off in home ownership!


Reply

We had a similar issue with maples at our old place - roots cracked the walkway pretty badly. Ended up swapping them out for smaller ornamentals like dogwoods and redbuds. Less shade, sure, but way less hassle down the road...


Reply

"Less shade, sure, but way less hassle down the road..."

Ha, sounds like trees and roofs have something in common - sometimes less is more. When we redid our roof a few years back, we debated metal vs asphalt shingles. Ended up going with metal; pricier upfront, yeah, but honestly worth every penny. No leaks, minimal maintenance, and the sound of rain is kinda soothing... unless it's hail. Then it's like living inside a popcorn machine. Still beats buckets on the floor though.


Reply

Metal roofs are solid, no doubt, but they're not always the best fit. Had one on a rental property - tenants complained about noise constantly. Good asphalt shingles installed right can last decades without hassle and keep things quieter inside... something to consider.


Reply

"Had one on a rental property - tenants complained about noise constantly."

Interesting point about the noise factor, hadn't thought much about that before. Makes sense though... rain and hail probably sound pretty intense on metal. Has anyone here tried adding extra insulation or soundproofing under a metal roof to help with that? Wonder if that could make enough difference or if it'd just end up being more hassle than it's worth.

I've had asphalt shingles myself for years, and they've held up pretty well with minimal fuss, but I'm curious if anyone's found other roofing materials that strike a good balance between durability and noise control. Maybe something like composite or even rubber roofing tiles? Would be great to hear some experiences from folks who've gone down that road.


Reply

"Wonder if that could make enough difference or if it'd just end up being more hassle than it's worth."

Yeah, that's a good question about insulation under metal roofs. My brother-in-law did exactly that - added some extra foam insulation panels when he installed his metal roof. It definitely helped tone down the noise from rain, but honestly, hail still sounded pretty loud. Not unbearable, but noticeable enough that you'd probably still hear complaints from tenants who are sensitive to noise.

I've personally had composite shingles for about five years now, and they've been surprisingly solid. They're quieter than metal for sure, and seem to hold up better than standard asphalt in heavy storms. Rubber tiles sound intriguing too... haven't seen them much around here though. Might be worth checking out if you're looking for something durable but quieter than metal.


Reply

We put metal roofing on our porch extension and added thin insulation underneath... helped a bit with rain noise, but honestly it's still pretty loud during storms. Not sure I'd do that again - probably composite shingles next time, quieter and less hassle overall.


Reply

Yeah, metal roofing can definitely be noisy - learned that the hard way myself. We did a guesthouse with metal a few years back, thinking it'd be durable and stylish (which it was), but every heavy rainstorm felt like we were inside a drum. Eventually, we ended up retrofitting extra soundproof insulation, which helped some, but honestly still louder than I'd prefer. Composite shingles have been my go-to since then - less hassle overall and way quieter.


Reply

Glad I'm not the only one who found metal roofs a bit overrated. Did a farmhouse project last year, client insisted on metal for the "rustic charm." It looked amazing, but yeah... every storm turned into a percussion concert. Composite shingles are definitely underrated in comparison.


Reply

Couldn't agree more about the noise factor with metal roofs. I recently toured a luxury home with a stunning copper roof - visually impressive, no doubt - but the owner quietly admitted he regretted the choice. Apparently, even with extra insulation, rainstorms became a constant distraction. Composite shingles certainly don't get enough credit; they're versatile, quieter, and can mimic premium materials surprisingly well. I've seen some high-end homes using architectural shingles that genuinely rival slate or cedar shakes in appearance, minus the maintenance headaches. That said, metal does have its place if durability and longevity are your main priorities - but for most residential applications, especially if comfort and quiet matter, composites might be the smarter choice.


Reply

Fair points about the noise, but honestly, I've lived under a metal roof for years and barely notice it anymore. Plus, from a sustainability angle, metal roofs are unbeatable - fully recyclable and great for rainwater harvesting. Maybe it's just about getting used to the sound...?


Reply
Scroll to Top