Custom homes discussions and local services.
Need advice on replacing an old leaky roof
NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF
Extra taping is one of those things that feels like overkill until you see what happens without it - frost, mold, the whole mess. I get the urge to over-seal, but there’s a fine line before you start trapping moisture where you really don’t want it. As for rigid board in old homes, I’ve wrestled with it in some pretty funky eaves and honestly, it’s not always worth the headache. Sometimes a good dense-pack cellulose or even mineral wool fits those odd angles better, and you don’t end up cursing at 2am trying to cut foam to fit a 120-year-old roofline. Just my two cents...
Sometimes a good dense-pack cellulose or even mineral wool fits those odd angles better, and you don’t end up cursing at 2am trying to cut foam to fit a 120-year-old roofline.
That’s the truth - old houses never have a straight line where you want one. I’ve found mineral wool especially forgiving in those weird nooks, plus it doesn’t mind a bit of moisture if you miss a spot with the vapor barrier. One thing I’d add: don’t skimp on air sealing around penetrations (chimneys, vent pipes, etc). Even if you’re not going crazy with tape everywhere, a little attention there pays off.
On over-sealing, I do think there’s such a thing as too much. Once, I went heavy-handed with poly and tape in an attic, and ended up with condensation issues - had to pull it all back and redo with a smart membrane. Now I always double-check that the assembly can dry in at least one direction.
If you’re replacing the whole roof, it’s tempting to modernize everything, but sometimes matching the old materials (like using skip sheathing with wood shingles) actually keeps things drier long-term. Just depends on what you’re working with...
Now I always double-check that the assembly can dry in at least one direction.
That’s key. I once worked on a Queen Anne with a complicated roofline - mineral wool was a lifesaver for those impossible angles, but the real headache was sealing around all the oddball vent stacks. Skipped the poly that time and used a vapor-smart membrane, which kept things from getting soggy. Matching old skip sheathing is smart, but sometimes you just have to pick your battles depending on how much rot you’re dealing with under there...
Matching old skip sheathing is smart, but sometimes you just have to pick your battles depending on how much rot you’re dealing with under there...
Yeah, that’s the truth. I’ve seen folks get hung up on making everything look original, but if half the rafters are mush, you’re just asking for trouble down the line. Vapor-smart membranes are a solid call - poly always makes me nervous, especially in these older places where nothing’s square and air leaks are everywhere. I’ve had mixed luck with mineral wool myself, but it’s definitely easier to work into weird corners than rigid foam.
Sealing around vent stacks is always a pain. I swear, whoever designed some of these old roofs must’ve hated future roofers. Sometimes you just have to accept a little compromise for the sake of actually getting it watertight and not spending weeks chasing every last detail. Sounds like you made the right calls given what you were up against.
Vapor-smart membranes are a solid call - poly always makes me nervous, especially in these older places where nothing’s square and air leaks are everywhere.
That’s exactly what I’m worried about with our place. Every time I pull up a board, I find another spot that looks like it was patched by someone’s granddad in the '60s. Did you insulate right up to the sheathing, or leave an air gap? I keep reading conflicting advice and don’t want to trap moisture by accident...
I know the feeling - old houses are full of surprises, sometimes the fun kind, sometimes not so much. I went with a small air gap between the insulation and sheathing, just to be safe. It’s a bit of a balancing act, but I’d rather have a little airflow than risk trapping moisture. Vapor-smart membranes definitely help, but nothing’s perfect in these quirky old places. You’re not alone… every board I pull up tells a new story too.
I went with a small air gap between the insulation and sheathing, just to be safe. It’s a bit of a balancing act, but I’d rather have a little airflow than risk trapping moisture.
I get the logic behind leaving an air gap, but honestly, in most old houses, that can sometimes do more harm than good. If the airflow isn’t controlled, you might just be inviting condensation issues - especially if you’re in a climate with big temp swings. I’ve had better luck going with a fully adhered vapor-smart membrane right against the sheathing. It’s not perfect, but it’s more predictable than hoping for passive airflow to behave. Every house is its own puzzle, though...
I’m kinda torn on this too. I keep reading about air gaps vs. vapor barriers and my head spins every time. My house is old (like, “washtub in the kitchen” old) and I’m on a tight budget, so I’m worried about doing something that’ll just create new problems down the road. Is the vapor-smart membrane stuff expensive? And does it actually help with those weird cold spots you get in winter? I’d love to avoid another surprise mold patch behind the drywall...
Vapor-smart membranes can get pricey, especially if you’re covering a big area, but they do let moisture escape when needed - which helps with mold. I’m curious, though: have you checked what’s actually causing those cold spots? Sometimes it’s less about vapor and more about insulation gaps or weird airflow patterns in old houses. Ever tried using an IR camera or just feeling around on a cold day to see where it’s worst?
Funny you mention the IR camera - I borrowed one from a buddy last winter and was honestly surprised by what I found. The worst cold spots in my attic weren’t where I expected at all. Turned out, there were a couple spots where the insulation had slumped down behind some old wiring, and one spot near a vent that was just...bare. I’d been blaming moisture issues, but it was mostly just air sneaking in. Ever notice how sometimes it’s the weirdest little gaps that cause the biggest headaches? I still think vapor-smart membranes are useful, but patching those insulation gaps made a bigger difference for me than anything else.
Funny thing is, I’ve seen vapor-smart membranes make a huge difference in some older homes, especially where moisture’s been a recurring headache. Patching insulation gaps is crucial, no doubt, but do you think it’s enough if the roof deck itself isn’t air-sealed? Sometimes those little fixes just mask bigger issues lurking up there…
NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF
Totally hear you on the vapor-smart membranes - those things can be a game changer, especially in old houses with mystery moisture issues. Had a similar situation with my own place: patched up insulation gaps thinking that’d do the trick, but it didn’t really solve anything until I went after the air leaks in the roof deck itself. It’s wild how much difference a proper air seal makes. Sometimes those “quick fixes” just end up being bandaids when the real problem’s hiding in plain sight...
NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF
- Been there - my old roof was a patchwork of “fixes” that never lasted.
- Ended up using peel-and-stick membrane under new shingles. Not the cheapest, but saved me from future headaches.
- Skipped the fancy insulation upgrades for now, just focused on stopping leaks and drafts first.
- Sometimes you gotta pick your battles... one step at a time, right?
- Curious - did you look into metal or composite shingles at all, or just stick with asphalt?
- Peel-and-stick membranes are solid, but I’ve seen some folks skip them to cut costs and regret it later.
- I get holding off on insulation upgrades, but sometimes if you’re already tearing things up, it’s less hassle to address it all at once.
- Any issues with ventilation after the new roof went on? Sometimes stopping leaks can trap more moisture inside...
NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF
I have to push back a bit on the idea that it’s always best to upgrade insulation while you’re already doing roof work. In theory, it sounds efficient, but in practice, I’ve seen plenty of projects where that “while we’re at it” mentality just snowballs the budget and timeline. Sometimes, especially with older homes, you open up a can of worms - suddenly you’re dealing with unexpected framing repairs or code issues you didn’t budget for. Unless there’s a clear insulation problem (like visible gaps or major drafts), I’d be cautious about tacking on more work than necessary.
On the ventilation point, I’m actually surprised how often people overlook it after a new roof goes on. It’s not just about stopping leaks; if you tighten everything up without considering airflow, you can end up with condensation issues - especially in attics. I’ve seen clients spend good money on beautiful new ceilings only to have them stained by trapped moisture a year later. Sometimes the solution is as simple as adding ridge vents or checking soffit vents for blockages, but it’s amazing how often that step gets skipped.
As for peel-and-stick membranes, I get the appeal - they’re great insurance against leaks - but I’m not convinced they’re always necessary in every climate or roof style. In some cases, especially with good overhangs and proper flashing, traditional underlayment does the job just fine. It really depends on your risk tolerance and local weather.
Metal and composite shingles are interesting options too, but honestly, they don’t always play nicely with certain architectural styles. I’ve seen metal roofs look out of place on some older homes unless you’re really leaning into that look. Composite can be a good middle ground if you want durability without going full industrial.
Just my two cents - sometimes less is more when it comes to renovations. It’s easy to get caught up in upgrades, but sometimes sticking to the essentials saves a lot of headaches down the road...
NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF
You nailed it about the “while we’re at it” trap. I’ve watched more than one project spiral from a simple roof replacement into a full-blown attic renovation, just because someone thought, “Hey, let’s add insulation since we’re up there.” Next thing you know, you’re chasing down ancient knob-and-tube wiring or realizing the rafters are spaced like someone was guessing. It’s like opening a wall in an old house - sometimes you find treasure, sometimes you find a squirrel’s nest and a plumbing leak.
Ventilation is the one thing I always harp on, though. Years ago, I worked on a 1920s bungalow where the owner had just put on a gorgeous new roof - cedar shakes, the whole nine yards. Six months later, he called me in a panic because his attic looked like a rainforest. Turns out, the contractor had sealed everything up tight but didn’t bother with ridge or soffit vents. We ended up having to retrofit the whole thing, which was way more expensive than just doing it right the first time. It’s not glamorous, but airflow saves a lot of headaches (and mold).
Peel-and-stick membranes are kind of like that extra insurance policy you hope you never need. Around here, with our freeze-thaw cycles, I do recommend them at least along the eaves and valleys. But yeah, if you’re in a milder climate and your roof isn’t a complicated mess of dormers and valleys, traditional felt can be totally fine. Sometimes people get sold on all the bells and whistles when the basics would do.
Metal roofs... I have a soft spot for them, but I agree they can look out of place on certain homes. I once saw a Victorian with standing seam metal and it just looked confused, like it couldn’t decide if it wanted to be a farmhouse or a city hall. Composite shingles are a safer bet if you want something low-maintenance that doesn’t scream “modern.”
At the end of the day, I’m with you - don’t let the project snowball unless there’s a real reason. Sometimes the best renovation is the one that doesn’t try to fix what isn’t broken.
NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF
I get what you’re saying about not letting things spiral, but I’ll push back a bit on skipping upgrades like insulation if you’re already tearing into the roof. Sometimes that’s the only realistic shot at getting it done right, especially with old houses where access is a nightmare. Yeah, it can open a can of worms, but ignoring obvious energy leaks just to keep things simple can cost more in the long run - both in bills and comfort. I’m all for not overcomplicating, but sometimes “while we’re at it” is actually the smart move. Just gotta know where to draw the line.
NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF
That’s a solid point about insulation - if you’re already opening up the roof, it’s probably the best (and sometimes only) chance to address those issues. I’ve run into that with older homes where attic access is basically nonexistent unless you’re pulling off the roof deck anyway. Skipping it just to keep things simple can end up being a false economy, especially if you’re dealing with ice dams or wild temperature swings.
One thing I’d add: if you’re going to upgrade insulation, make sure you’re also looking at ventilation. It’s easy to focus on R-value and forget that without proper airflow, you can actually create more problems - trapped moisture, mold, even premature shingle failure. I’ve seen folks go all-in on insulation and then have to rip things out later because they missed that step.
It’s always a balancing act between scope creep and doing it right. Sometimes “while we’re at it” is just common sense, but yeah, knowing when to stop is half the battle...
NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF
I learned that the hard way on my last reno - added insulation but didn’t pay enough attention to soffit vents. Ended up with condensation issues that cost more to fix than if I’d just done it right from the start. If you’re already tearing things up, might as well double-check all the airflow paths... trust me, it’s worth the hassle.
If you’re already tearing things up, might as well double-check all the airflow paths... trust me, it’s worth the hassle.
Totally get where you’re coming from. I once thought I was being clever by cramming extra insulation up into the rafters - figured more was better, right? Ended up with a weird musty smell in the attic that just wouldn’t quit. Turns out, blocking those soffit vents basically trapped all the moisture up there. Had to pull everything out and start over, which was a real pain (and not cheap).
One thing I’d add: if you’re going for a new roof anyway, it’s a good time to look at the type of insulation and ventilation together. Sometimes people focus on R-value but forget about vapor barriers or baffles to keep airflow moving. Even the color of your shingles can make a difference in heat buildup, which affects moisture too. Little details, but they add up.
Funny how the stuff you can’t see - like air movement - ends up being the most important.