Custom homes discussions and local services.

Need advice on replacing an old leaky roof

1,744 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

It’s wild how those “invisible” steps end up being the real MVPs. Funny how the stuff you can’t even see makes the biggest difference, huh?

That hits home. Years ago, I worked on a retrofit where the owner was laser-focused on recycled shingles and solar panels, but didn’t want to “waste” budget on proper soffit and ridge venting. Fast forward two summers - roof looked great, but the attic was a sauna and mold started creeping in. It’s always the hidden details that save you headaches down the line. I’d argue venting and air sealing are just as “green” as any visible upgrade, even if they don’t get the same bragging rights.


Reply

That’s a good point about the “invisible” stuff. I’m always torn when it comes to spending on things like venting or insulation, since you don’t really see the payoff right away. Has anyone found a way to balance those hidden upgrades with more visible improvements, without blowing the budget?


Reply

I totally get where you’re coming from - spending money on stuff you can’t see feels weird, especially when you’re on a tight budget. When we did our roof, I had to pick between upgrading the insulation and getting nicer shingles. Ended up going with basic shingles but put more into insulation and venting. The energy bills dropped a bit, which helped justify it... but I still wish I could’ve done both. Maybe focus on the “invisible” stuff that’ll save you money long-term, then tackle the cosmetic upgrades as you can? It’s not as satisfying right away, but it does pay off over time.


Reply

Honestly, I wrestled with this exact thing last year. It’s tough to spend on stuff you can’t see, but here’s how I broke it down: First, I made a list of “must-haves” (like fixing leaks and insulation) vs. “nice-to-haves” (fancier shingles, skylights, etc). Then I got quotes for each part separately. Ended up patching the leaks and adding attic insulation first - my heating bill dropped noticeably. The curb appeal upgrades are still on my wishlist, but at least the house is dry and warmer now. It’s not flashy, but it made a difference.


Reply

I get where you’re coming from - those “invisible” fixes never feel as satisfying as a new roof you can show off. But honestly, I’d always prioritize leaks and insulation too. Water damage is sneaky and expensive if you let it go. I did the same a few years back: patched leaks, beefed up the attic insulation, and my utility bills dropped a ton. The cosmetic stuff can wait, but keeping the structure sound is non-negotiable in my book. Sometimes the boring fixes are the smartest ones.


Reply

Couldn’t agree more about the “boring” fixes being the smart ones. I once splurged on fancy copper gutters before dealing with a minor roof leak - big mistake. Ended up redoing drywall and insulation anyway. Lesson learned: always tackle leaks first, even if it’s not glamorous.


Reply

NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF

That’s a classic trap - gutters look great but leaks are sneaky and always win in the end. If you’re tackling a roof replacement, I’d break it down like this: first, get a thorough inspection (don’t just eyeball it). Next, prioritize structural repairs - rot or soft spots need fixing before anything else. Then, pick your roofing material based on climate and budget, not just looks. Flashing and underlayment matter more than people think... skip those and you’ll be back to drywall repairs before you know it. Fancy upgrades are fun, but a dry house is way more satisfying in the long run.


Reply

NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF

You nailed it about the underlayment and flashing - those get ignored way too often. I learned the hard way that skipping proper flashing around chimneys is just asking for trouble. Curious if you’ve considered metal roofing at all? It’s pricier up front, but in my experience, it’s held up better than asphalt, especially in areas with wild weather swings. Wondering what kind of climate you’re dealing with, since that really changes what makes sense.


Reply

NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF

Metal roofs are great, especially if you’re in a spot with hail or big temp swings - less maintenance long-term. One thing folks overlook is noise during rain, though. If you go metal, add a solid underlayment and maybe some soundproofing. Flashing is non-negotiable either way... had to redo a whole section once just because of one bad joint around a vent.


Reply

NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF

Metal roofs are great, especially if you’re in a spot with hail or big temp swings - less maintenance long-term. One thing folks overlook is noise during rain, though.

- Not gonna argue, metal is tough. But honestly, don’t sleep on modern architectural shingles.
- They’ve come a long way - impact-resistant options, better wind ratings, and some even mimic slate or wood shake.
- Noise isn’t an issue with shingles, and you get a bit more forgiveness if your roof deck isn’t perfectly flat (metal can telegraph every bump).
- Metal’s great, but it can be tricky with complex rooflines - think valleys, dormers, lots of penetrations. More seams = more spots for leaks if the install isn’t perfect.
- Had a client swap from metal to high-end shingle after years of condensation issues in a poorly vented attic. Solved their problem, and the roof still looks sharp.
- Either way, flashing is the real MVP. Skimp there, and you’re just asking for headaches, no matter the material.

Just tossing out another angle - sometimes the “old school” option’s worth a look.


Reply

Either way, flashing is the real MVP. Skimp there, and you’re just asking for headaches, no matter the material.

Couldn’t agree more about flashing - seen too many “premium” roofs leak just because someone cheaped out there. Had a job last year where the homeowner wanted metal for the look, but their roof was all hips and valleys... install was a nightmare. Ended up recommending high-end shingles with proper ice & water shield, and it’s been bone dry since. Sometimes simpler is better, especially if your roof isn’t a basic gable.


Reply

Sometimes simpler is better, especially if your roof isn’t a basic gable.

That’s been my experience too. I’ve lost count of how many times I’ve watched folks get talked into “high-end” or trendy roofing systems that just don’t suit the actual roof shape. Hips, valleys, dormers… all those details are where leaks love to show up, and if the flashing isn’t done right, it doesn’t matter what material you’re using.

One thing I’ll add - sometimes people focus so much on the visible parts (shingles, tiles, metal panels) that they forget about what’s underneath. You mentioned ice & water shield, which is huge in colder climates or anywhere with tricky roof geometry. I’d also say pay attention to ventilation and attic insulation while you’re at it. If you’re already tearing off the old roof, it’s a good time to check for any signs of moisture in the decking or mold up there.

I’m curious - when you switched from metal to high-end shingles for that job, did you run into any issues with the homeowner being disappointed about not getting the “look” they wanted? Sometimes I find people get really set on an aesthetic even if it’s not practical for their roof style or budget.

Also, have you ever tried one of those synthetic slate or shake products? I’ve had mixed results - looks great from a distance but sometimes the install gets complicated around valleys and transitions, just like metal.

If anyone else has tackled a complex roof recently, did you stick with traditional materials or try something new?


Reply

Sometimes people focus so much on the visible parts (shingles, tiles, metal panels) that they forget about what’s underneath.

- Had a similar situation last year - client wanted cedar shakes for the “storybook” vibe, but their roof was all hips and valleys. Ended up convincing them to go with architectural shingles and invest in better underlayment instead.
- They were a little bummed at first, but once they saw how clean it looked (and how dry the attic stayed), they were sold.
- Tried synthetic slate once - looked amazing from the curb, but the installer had a nightmare with all the weird angles. Not sure I’d do it again unless it was a simple roof.
- Honestly, sometimes less is more. The right details underneath matter way more than what you see from the street.


Reply

You nailed it with the underlayment focus. People get really hung up on aesthetics, but if the roof deck and underlayment aren’t solid, it’s just lipstick on a pig. I’ve seen “premium” roofs leak because the installer skimped underneath. I get the appeal of cedar or fancy synthetics, but on complex roofs, practical choices really do save headaches (and cash) down the line. Sometimes I think homeowners underestimate how much those hidden layers matter... until the first big storm rolls through.


Reply

if the roof deck and underlayment aren’t solid, it’s just lipstick on a pig.

Couldn’t agree more. I’ve inspected roofs where the shingles looked flawless, but underneath, the sheathing was rotted or the underlayment was barely there - total disaster waiting to happen. On steep pitches or valleys, I always recommend ice and water shield, even if local code doesn’t require it. It’s not glamorous, but it’s what keeps the “fancy” stuff above from turning into a liability. People get fixated on the visible layer, but honestly, the real value is in what you don’t see.


Reply

I get where you’re coming from about the importance of what’s under the shingles, but sometimes the budget just doesn’t stretch far enough for all the upgrades. When I had my roof done last year, I wanted to go all-in with ice and water shield everywhere, but the cost difference was pretty steep. Ended up just doing it in the valleys and around penetrations, which the roofer said was the most critical.

Honestly, I think there’s a balance. Not everyone can afford to rip up all the decking unless it’s really bad. Sometimes patching or reinforcing the worst spots is the only realistic option, at least for a few years. It’s not ideal, but it beats letting leaks keep getting worse. I’d love to do everything “by the book,” but sometimes you just have to prioritize and hope for the best.


Reply

“Ended up just doing it in the valleys and around penetrations, which the roofer said was the most critical.”

Honestly, that’s where I landed too when I did my place. Full ice and water shield everywhere sounds great, but my wallet had other plans. I focused on the valleys and chimney since that’s where leaks love to show up. Decking only got replaced where it was soft or rotted - no sense tossing good wood just for the sake of it.

I hear you on “by the book,” but sometimes you’ve just gotta be practical. If you can keep things dry for a few more years, that’s a win in my book.


Reply

“Decking only got replaced where it was soft or rotted - no sense tossing good wood just for the sake of it.”

That’s exactly what I was thinking when I started looking at estimates. I get why people want to do everything “by the book,” but honestly, if the rest of the decking is solid, why rip it out? I did end up splurging on better flashing around my skylight - figured that spot would bite me later if I cheaped out. Curious though, did anyone regret not doing full ice and water shield? It’s hard to tell if it’s just overkill or actually worth it long term.


Reply

I’ve seen plenty of roofs where just patching the bad decking worked out fine - no issues years later. As for ice and water shield, I only put it in valleys and around penetrations on my own place. Never had a problem, even through some nasty winters. Full coverage always seemed like overkill unless you’re in a spot with crazy ice damming.


Reply

NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF

I get where you’re coming from - patching bad decking can work, and I’ve seen it hold up for years too. But I’ve also walked into more than a few “quick fix” jobs that turned into full-on headaches later. Sometimes the rot or water damage isn’t obvious until you really open things up, and then you’re chasing leaks for ages.

On the ice and water shield, I used to think the same - just valleys and penetrations, call it a day. Then I worked on a place where the homeowner swore they never had ice damming issues, but one freak winter and suddenly water was sneaking in at the eaves. Full coverage would’ve saved a lot of drywall and flooring in that case.

Guess it depends on your risk tolerance and how much you want to gamble with future repairs. Sometimes “overkill” is just peace of mind, especially if you’re not planning to get back up there anytime soon...


Reply
Scroll to Top