Custom homes discussions and local services.

Need advice on replacing an old leaky roof

1,744 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

I’ve always wondered about the attic temp thing too. When we swapped to synthetic underlayment, I swear the upstairs felt warmer that first summer. Maybe it was just in my head, but I ended up adding a couple more soffit vents just in case. Anyone ever try one of those solar attic fans? Curious if they actually help or just another gadget.


Reply

Anyone ever try one of those solar attic fans? Curious if they actually help or just another gadget.

We had a solar attic fan installed a couple years back, mostly because the HVAC guy swore by them. Honestly, I did notice a slight drop in attic temp, but nothing dramatic. The upstairs was still warm, just maybe not as stuffy. Hard to say if it was worth the cost - might depend on your roof size and how much direct sun you get.

I’ve found that more soffit and ridge venting usually does more for airflow than a single fan. Synthetic underlayment can trap more heat compared to felt, in my experience, especially with darker shingles. Did you notice any difference in your energy bills after adding vents? Sometimes it’s small changes that add up over time.

Curious if anyone’s tried one of those thermostatically controlled fans instead of solar - wondering if they make a bigger impact or just chew up electricity.


Reply

I’ve actually gone the other direction and skipped the solar fan altogether. Instead, I invested in high-quality ridge and soffit venting when we redid our roof last year. Honestly, I think passive ventilation does more for overall comfort and energy efficiency than a single powered fan, solar or not. The thermostatically controlled ones sound good on paper, but I’ve heard they can end up pulling conditioned air out of the house if your attic isn’t sealed up tight, which kind of defeats the purpose. Sometimes simpler is better, especially if you’re already spending on a new roof.


Reply

Sometimes simpler is better, especially if you’re already spending on a new roof.

I hear you on keeping things simple. I’ve seen a few projects where folks went all-in with powered fans, but without sealing up every little gap, it just ended up wasting energy. Out of curiosity, did you notice any difference in your attic temps after switching to just ridge and soffit vents? I’ve always wondered how much passive setups really move the needle, especially during those brutal summer stretches.


Reply

NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF

That’s actually something I’ve been wondering about too. We just finished our build last year, and I went with ridge and soffit vents because everyone kept saying “don’t overcomplicate it.” Honestly, I was a little skeptical at first - like, is passive airflow really enough when it’s 95° out and the sun’s baking the shingles?

I’ve been up in the attic a few times during the hottest days, mostly to check for leaks (paranoid first-timer here), and it definitely feels warm, but not like a sauna or anything. I don’t have a temp sensor up there yet, but it seems like the air moves pretty well. The insulation guys said as long as you’ve got good intake at the soffits and a clear path to the ridge, you’re in decent shape.

One thing I did notice: before we finished sealing up some of the little gaps around the eaves, there was a weird draftiness in certain spots. After we buttoned those up, it felt more consistent. Maybe that’s why powered fans don’t always help - if you’ve got leaks everywhere, they’re just pulling in hot air from wherever they can.

Curious if anyone’s actually tracked attic temps before and after switching vent setups? Or maybe even noticed a difference in cooling bills? I keep hearing mixed things about whether passive vents are enough in places with crazy summers. Would love to know if anyone regrets not going with powered fans or if it’s just one of those “set it and forget it” deals once everything’s sealed up tight.

Also - has anyone had issues with critters getting in through soffit vents? We had a squirrel situation early on, but that might just be my luck...


Reply

Passive ridge and soffit venting is usually fine if your intake and exhaust are balanced and there’s no insulation blocking airflow. I’ve measured attic temps before and passive setups tend to keep things within 10–15 degrees of outside air, even in hot climates. Powered fans can actually pull conditioned air from the house if the attic isn’t sealed tight, which can backfire on cooling bills. As for critters, metal mesh over soffits is a must - plastic just doesn’t cut it for squirrels.


Reply

NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF

I’ve been down this road a few times, and honestly, I’d take a well-balanced passive vent setup over powered fans any day - unless you’re dealing with some wild humidity issues. Powered fans sound fancy, but they can end up sucking your AC right out of the house if your attic isn’t sealed up like Fort Knox. That’s a quick way to watch your cooling bills climb.

Totally agree on the metal mesh for soffits. Squirrels are basically tiny demolition crews with tails. I tried plastic mesh once - lasted about a week before I heard the pitter-patter of little feet overhead. Lesson learned.

One thing I’d add: if you’re replacing the roof anyway, double-check that your insulation isn’t blocking those soffit vents. It’s amazing how often that gets overlooked, and it really messes with airflow. A little attention there saves a lot of headaches (and money) down the line.


Reply

Powered fans sound fancy, but they can end up sucking your AC right out of the house if your attic isn’t sealed up like Fort Knox.

Couldn’t agree more - powered fans are just another thing to break, and they’ll eat into your wallet over time. I’d rather spend that money on better insulation or upgraded shingles. Also, totally with you on the metal mesh. Those squirrels will chew through anything if you give them half a chance... learned that the hard way last winter.

One thing I’d add: don’t skimp on drip edge. It’s cheap insurance against water damage, and a lot of roofers try to skip it to save time. Not worth it in the long run.


Reply

- Totally hear you on the powered fans - my neighbor put one in and ended up with higher cooling bills and a fried motor after two summers.
- Insulation seems like a smarter spend, but is it really that much better than just thicker shingles?
- Drip edge - didn’t even know what that was until last year. My first roofer tried skipping it, then I found rot around the eaves... lesson learned.
- Anyone have thoughts on those “lifetime” shingles? They sound good, but I’m skeptical anything on a roof lasts forever.
- Squirrels: 1, me: 0. Those little guys are relentless.


Reply

NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF

Insulation over powered fans any day - learned that the hard way after chasing attic temps with gadgets instead of just sealing up the gaps and adding cellulose. The difference in comfort (and bills) was night and day. Thicker shingles don’t really do much for heat transfer, honestly. Most of the heat comes through the roof deck, not the shingle itself. Insulation is where you get real bang for your buck.

Drip edge is one of those things you don’t notice until it’s missing... and then you REALLY notice. Had a similar rot situation a few years back. Now I double-check every time.

“Lifetime” shingles always make me laugh a bit. Lifetime of what? The shingle? The house? The company? I’ve seen them curl and crack after 15 years if the attic’s not vented right or there’s moisture issues. They’re better than the old 3-tabs, but nothing’s truly forever up there.

And squirrels... yeah, they’re basically tiny demolition crews. I’ve surrendered and just keep patching the soffits.


Reply

Funny you mention the “lifetime” shingles - had a client who thought that meant their roof was set for good. Fast forward 12 years, and we’re up there replacing half of it because of poor ventilation and some sneaky leaks around the flashing. I’ve found that focusing on proper underlayment, solid insulation, and making sure every bit of flashing is tight does way more for longevity than just picking the thickest shingle. And yeah, squirrels... I swear they have blueprints for weak spots.


Reply

I’ve seen “lifetime” shingles mislead a lot of folks - marketing at its finest. Honestly, I’d argue ventilation is the most overlooked factor in roof longevity. Curious, did you end up using ridge vents or go with something else for airflow? I’ve had mixed results with different systems, especially on older homes.


Reply

Honestly, I’d argue ventilation is the most overlooked factor in roof longevity.

Can’t say I agree more - ventilation gets ignored until the attic’s basically a sauna and you’re dealing with curling shingles or worse. I lean toward ridge vents myself, but only if the roofline and attic space make sense for it. On some of the older bungalows I’ve worked with, gable vents or even adding powered fans ended up being more effective. Did you have to mess with your soffits at all, or were they already set up for proper intake? That’s where I see most folks run into trouble - everyone focuses on exhaust, not intake.


Reply

Yeah, soffit intake is where a lot of folks get tripped up. You can have all the ridge vents in the world, but if the air can’t get in, it’s just not gonna work. I’ve seen people slap on fancy exhausts and wonder why their attic still cooks. Sometimes you have to pop off the old soffit panels and cut bigger holes, or even add new vented panels. It’s not glamorous work, but it makes a difference. On one job, we found old insulation stuffed right up against the intake - might as well have had nothing at all. Always worth crawling up there and checking before you start swapping out shingles.


Reply

- Not saying soffit intake isn’t important, but sometimes people go overboard cutting bigger holes or swapping panels when the real issue is just poor attic insulation or bad sealing elsewhere.
- I’ve seen houses with perfect intake and exhaust, but still sweating because of gaps around can lights or bathroom fans dumping warm air up there.
- Before hacking up soffits, I’d double-check for air leaks inside the house and make sure insulation isn’t blocking airflow.
- Sometimes it’s not about more vents, it’s about fixing what’s already there. Just my two cents...


Reply

Sometimes it’s not about more vents, it’s about fixing what’s already there. Just my two cents...

That’s a good point. I’ve been tempted to just add more vents or bigger ones, but honestly, my last place had all the vents in the world and still had issues - turned out the insulation was a mess and there were gaps everywhere. I’m with you, it’s easy to get caught up in “more is better” but sometimes it’s just about patching up what’s already there. Makes sense, especially if you’re trying to keep costs down.


Reply

Title: Replacing Roof - Vents vs. Insulation (Or Both?)

I get where you’re coming from about fixing what’s already there, but I’ve seen it swing both ways. Had a job last year - old farmhouse, leaky roof, drafty as heck. The owner was convinced it was just the insulation, so we spent a good chunk of time patching up gaps, sealing around the attic hatch, all that jazz. It helped, but the place still felt stuffy in summer and cold in winter. Turns out, the vents were so old and clogged with debris that barely any air was moving through the attic. Once we swapped those out and added a ridge vent, the difference was night and day.

I guess what I’m saying is, sometimes it’s not just one thing. You can have perfect insulation, but if the air’s not moving, moisture builds up and you get mold or rot. On the flip side, you can have all the vents in the world, but if there are gaps everywhere, you’re just letting conditioned air escape and wasting money.

It’s kind of like tuning a guitar - you can’t just tighten one string and expect it to sound right. Everything’s gotta work together. I know budgets are tight (they always are), but sometimes it’s worth looking at the whole system instead of just picking one fix. Not saying you need to go overboard with fancy vent systems or spray foam everything, but maybe a little of both goes a long way.

Funny enough, I’ve seen folks get obsessed with “energy efficiency” and end up making their house so airtight it can’t breathe. Then you get condensation and all sorts of weird smells. There’s a balance somewhere in there... just gotta find it for your place.


Reply

I get what you’re saying about balance, but honestly, I’m still not sold on the idea that you always need to mess with both vents and insulation at the same time. When we moved into our place last year, the inspector pointed out the roof was leaking in spots, but the attic insulation was actually decent. We ended up just replacing the roof and adding some modern vent covers - didn’t touch the insulation at all. Huge difference right away. The house felt less drafty and our heating bill dropped a bit.

I guess my point is, sometimes it’s just one thing that’s the real culprit. If your insulation isn’t trashed or full of gaps, maybe focus on getting those vents working first? I’ve seen people tear out perfectly good insulation because they thought they had to “do it all” at once, and it just seemed like a waste.

Not saying your experience is wrong - just that sometimes simple fixes work if you know where the actual problem is. Maybe I just got lucky, but I’d rather not overcomplicate things if I don’t have to...


Reply

NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF

Yeah, I hear you - sometimes it really is just one thing making all the trouble. I’ve seen folks rip out insulation that looked fine just because they thought it was “step one.” If your insulation’s solid and you’re not seeing drafts or weird temp swings, I’d say you did it right. Roof leaks can mess with airflow and make everything feel off, so fixing that first makes sense. I’m all for not making more work than you have to... unless you like crawling around in itchy insulation for fun.


Reply

NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF

Yeah, crawling around in insulation is about as fun as stepping on a nail - been there, done that, not in a hurry to repeat it. I get what you’re saying about not tearing out stuff that’s still doing its job. I’ve seen people go overboard and end up with more headaches than they started with. Last time I replaced a roof, I left the insulation alone since it was dry and didn’t smell musty. No sense fixing what isn’t broken.

Curious though - what kind of roof are you dealing with? Shingles, metal, something else? I’ve found some materials are way more forgiving if you’re doing the work yourself, while others can be a real pain. Also, did you notice any mold or water stains inside, or was it just the obvious leak? Sometimes the hidden stuff is what bites you later...


Reply
Scroll to Top