"At first, it felt like just another add-on to inflate the bill, you know?"
Haha, yeah, I was definitely in that camp too. When we had our roof replaced, the contractor tried to upsell us on extra attic ventilation. I remember thinking, "Really? More vents? Sounds like a gimmick." But I grudgingly agreed after doing some quick research, and honestly, it did help keep the upstairs cooler. Still not sure if it was worth every penny, but it wasn't the total waste I initially expected.
Interesting to hear the metal roof held up so well in hail. We went with architectural shingles because they seemed like a decent balance between cost and durability. They've held up fine so far, but we haven't had any extreme weather yet to really test them out. I guess time will tell.
One thing I'm still skeptical about is the whole "reflective shingles" marketing. They claim to lower attic temps significantly, but I've read mixed reviews. Anyone here actually tried those reflective shingles? Curious if they actually make a noticeable difference or if it's mostly hype...
"Still not sure if it was worth every penny, but it wasn't the total waste I initially expected."
Yeah, I totally get that feeling. When we redid our roof a couple years back, the contractor pushed reflective shingles pretty hard. I was skeptical too—felt like another upsell tactic. But we decided to give them a shot since our attic was basically an oven in the summer. Honestly, they made more of a difference than I expected. It wasn't night-and-day, but the upstairs rooms definitely felt less stuffy on hot afternoons.
That said, I still think good attic insulation and ventilation probably do more heavy lifting overall. Reflective shingles help, but they're not magic. And I agree about metal roofs—my sister has one, and it's held up incredibly well through storms. If I had to do it again, I'd probably consider metal more seriously, despite the higher upfront cost.
