Custom homes discussions and local services.

Need advice on replacing an old leaky roof

1,744 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

Interesting points, but I'm wondering - couldn't the effectiveness of fans vs. insulation depend a bit on your local climate or attic setup? I mean, insulation is definitely important, but what if your attic has decent insulation already, just poor ventilation? Wouldn't fans make a bigger difference then? I'm new to this stuff (first home here!), but maybe it's not always insulation-first for every scenario...?


Reply

That's a thoughtful angle, actually. If your attic already has solid insulation but poor airflow, fans could indeed have a more noticeable impact. Insulation primarily helps maintain indoor temperatures by reducing heat transfer, but if hot air gets trapped up there, even good insulation might struggle to keep things comfortable.

That said, climate plays a huge role too. In humid or very hot climates, attic ventilation fans can significantly reduce moisture buildup and lower attic temps. On the flip side, in colder climates, too much ventilation might actually pull warm air from your home and make heating less efficient.

Have you checked if your attic has any existing passive ventilation like soffit or ridge vents? Sometimes just improving or clearing these can help airflow without needing powered fans... I'm curious - what kind of setup do you currently have up there?


Reply

"Sometimes just improving or clearing these can help airflow without needing powered fans..."

Exactly. I've seen plenty of cases where homeowners jump straight to powered ventilation when a bit of passive vent cleanup would've done the trick. Ridge and soffit vents are often overlooked or blocked by insulation or debris. Might be worth poking around up there first - could save you some hassle (and cash). Also, if you're replacing the roof anyway, it's the perfect time to reassess your vent setup.


Reply

"Might be worth poking around up there first - could save you some hassle (and cash)."

Good point, but how often does a simple vent cleanup really fix things long-term? I've seen vents cleared only to clog again within months...maybe powered fans aren't always overkill? Just wondering.


Reply

"maybe powered fans aren't always overkill?"

Honestly, powered fans can be a solid solution if you're dealing with persistent moisture buildup. Cleaning vents helps temporarily, sure, but if you're constantly battling humidity...a fan upgrade might actually save you headaches down the road. Just my two cents!


Reply

I used to think powered fans were just an unnecessary expense until I replaced my roof a couple years back. We had constant moisture issues, even after patching leaks and cleaning vents regularly. Eventually, we bit the bullet and installed a powered attic fan. Honestly, it made a noticeable difference - humidity dropped significantly, and the attic felt fresher overall. So yeah, I'd agree that

"powered fans can be a solid solution if you're dealing with persistent moisture buildup."
Sometimes spending a bit more upfront saves you from bigger headaches later on...


Reply

Powered attic fans can definitely help in some situations, but they're not always the best fix. Couple thoughts from my own experience:

- If your attic ventilation is already adequate (ridge vents, soffit vents, etc.), adding a powered fan might actually disrupt natural airflow. I've seen cases where powered fans ended up pulling conditioned air from the home through small gaps or leaks, raising energy bills.

- Proper insulation and sealing air leaks between your attic and living spaces often do more to control moisture and humidity than an active fan. When we renovated our place a few years back, focusing on sealing gaps around recessed lighting and plumbing vents made a huge difference. We skipped the powered fan altogether.

- Also worth mentioning: powered fans need electricity and maintenance. Not a huge deal, but it's another consideration.

Not saying powered fans can't help - they clearly worked for you. But if someone's replacing their roof anyway, I'd suggest exploring passive ventilation improvements and better insulation first... might be simpler and more cost-effective overall.


Reply

Good points overall, but I gotta say, we installed a powered attic fan last summer, and it noticeably cooled our upstairs bedrooms. Passive vents are great, but sometimes they just don't move enough air when it's really hot out... depends on your climate and house layout, I guess.


Reply

Fair enough, powered attic fans can help, but they're not always the best solution:

- Powered fans can sometimes pull conditioned air from inside your living space, making your AC work harder.
- If your attic isn't sealed properly, you might actually increase energy costs rather than reduce them.
- I've found that improving insulation and sealing air leaks around attic access points and ducts often makes a bigger difference overall.

Definitely depends on your specific setup, but worth considering before jumping straight to powered ventilation.


Reply

Good points about the attic fans, especially the bit about sealing and insulation. Have you checked how well your attic is sealed around vents and ducts? I remember when I replaced my roof a few years back, I thought ventilation was the main issue, but turns out I had some pretty big gaps around the attic hatch and ductwork. Once I sealed those up and added some extra insulation, it made a noticeable difference in comfort and energy bills.

Also, what kind of roofing material are you leaning toward? If you're already replacing the roof, it might be worth looking into reflective shingles or metal roofing to help keep things cooler up there. Might cost a bit more upfront, but could save you headaches (and money) down the road. Just something else to think about...


Reply

Reflective shingles are solid advice, but depending on your climate, metal roofing might be overkill. Have you considered checking out composite shingles? They're durable and energy-efficient without the higher upfront cost of metal...might be worth a look.


Reply

Composite shingles are definitely worth considering - I actually went with them myself about two years ago when we replaced our roof. Initially, I was leaning toward metal roofing because I liked the modern look and durability, but when I got the quotes...well, let's just say my budget didn't exactly agree with my taste, haha.

I ended up looking into composites after a friend recommended them. They turned out to be a great compromise between cost, durability, and aesthetics. The installation was straightforward, and honestly, I've been really happy with the results. They're holding up well against heavy rains and some pretty intense summer sun. Plus, I've noticed a slight improvement in energy efficiency - my attic space doesn't get nearly as hot as it used to.

One thing I'd suggest, though: don't just pick based on price or looks alone. Consider your home's style and surrounding architecture. Composite shingles come in a ton of different colors and textures, so you can really match them to your home's personality. I went for a slate-gray color that complemented our siding perfectly, and it made such a difference in the overall curb appeal.

Also, don't forget to check if your local utility company offers rebates or incentives for energy-efficient roofing materials - mine did, and it helped offset some of the upfront costs. Good luck with your roof replacement...it's a big decision, but definitely rewarding once it's done.


Reply

Good points on composites. I replaced my roof about 5 years ago and went with architectural shingles - similar idea, just slightly different materials. A few quick thoughts from experience:

- Definitely echo the advice on checking rebates; saved me a couple hundred bucks.
- Don't skimp on underlayment or flashing. My neighbor did, and he's already dealing with leaks again.
- Color matters more than you'd think. Darker shingles looked great but made my attic hotter in summer.

Overall, just take your time deciding...it's a big investment.


Reply

Good advice overall, but I'd push back a bit on the darker shingles point. While it's true darker colors absorb more heat, attic ventilation and insulation play a much bigger role in controlling attic temperatures. I've seen plenty of homes with dark roofs stay cool because they invested in proper ridge vents and soffit ventilation. If you really prefer the look of darker shingles, don't rule them out completely - just make sure your attic is properly ventilated and insulated first.

Also, architectural shingles are solid, but if you're open to alternatives, metal roofing might be worth considering. It's pricier upfront, but the durability and lifespan can offset that cost over time. Plus, metal roofs reflect heat better, which can help with energy efficiency. Just something else to think about before you commit...


Reply

Good points on ventilation and insulation - those really do make a huge difference. A few things I'd add from experience:

- If you're going darker, consider reflective granules. Some newer shingles have reflective coatings that help offset heat absorption.
- Metal roofs are great, but if budget's tight, look at synthetic composite shingles too - durable, lighter weight, and can mimic slate or wood shakes pretty convincingly.
- Whatever you pick, don't skimp on underlayment... that's your real leak barrier.

Roofing's one area where upfront investment usually pays off down the road.


Reply

Great suggestions here, especially about the reflective shingles. Hadn't really thought about those before, but it makes sense they'd help with heat issues. I'm definitely leaning toward synthetic composite shingles myself - metal sounds awesome, but the quotes I've gotten so far are pretty steep.

One thing I'm still unsure about though is lifespan vs. cost. I mean, composites seem durable enough, but do they really hold up as long as metal or traditional shingles? I've heard mixed things from friends who've gone composite - some swear by them, others say they start looking worn sooner than expected. Maybe that's just brand-specific or installation-related though...

Has anyone here had composite shingles for a good 10+ years now? Curious how they're holding up over time compared to other materials.


Reply

I've had composite shingles on my place for about 12 years now. Here's my quick take:

- Durability-wise, they've held up pretty well - no leaks or major issues yet.
- Appearance is decent, but I have noticed some fading and minor wear around the edges, especially on the south-facing side.
- Definitely seems brand-specific; my neighbor's composites (different brand) look noticeably better after roughly the same time.

Overall, composites are solid, but I'd say metal still wins if longevity is your top priority.


Reply

Interesting to hear your experience - I've always leaned toward metal myself, especially for longevity. But I've also heard some folks complain about noise during heavy rain or hailstorms with metal roofs. Have you (or anyone else here) noticed that being an issue? Curious if that's just an exaggerated concern or something worth considering before making the switch...


Reply

"But I've also heard some folks complain about noise during heavy rain or hailstorms with metal roofs."

I've had a metal roof for about five years now, and honestly, the noise isn't as bad as some people make it out to be. Sure, during a really heavy downpour or hailstorm, you'll notice it more than with shingles, but it's not deafening or anything. Actually, I find it kind of relaxing - like white noise - but that's just me.

One thing I'd definitely consider, though, is insulation. Good insulation underneath can really cut down on the noise factor. Did you already look into insulation options or are you planning to just swap the roofing material itself?


Reply

I agree, the noise factor really depends on insulation and installation methods. I've seen some metal roofs installed directly onto the decking without proper underlayment or insulation, and those can get pretty loud during heavy storms. But if you add a good insulating layer or even a sound-dampening underlayment, it makes a huge difference. My brother-in-law recently replaced his shingles with metal and went all out with insulation - honestly, it's quieter now than it ever was before.


Reply
Scroll to Top