Custom homes discussions and local services.

Trimming down expenses on project supplies

1,024 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

TRIMMING DOWN EXPENSES ON PROJECT SUPPLIES

I get where you’re coming from on the caulk - cheap stuff just cracks or shrinks and you end up redoing it anyway. But I’ll push back a bit on drop cloths. I’ve seen folks use old sheets or plastic tarps, and honestly, sometimes it’s more hassle than it’s worth. Paint seeps through, or you’re tripping over bunched-up fabric. I’d rather have a couple of solid canvas ones that last forever. As for tape, I swear by the blue stuff, even if it stings a little at checkout. It saves so much time fixing mistakes later.


Reply

TRIMMING DOWN EXPENSES ON PROJECT SUPPLIES

Totally get what you mean about the canvas drop cloths. I tried using old bedsheets once - never again. Paint went straight through, and I ended up with weird splotches on my hardwood. The blue tape is pricey, yeah, but it’s saved me from some seriously crooked lines. Haven’t found a good cheap alternative for that yet. Sometimes you just gotta pay up for the stuff that actually works and lasts.


Reply

Paint went straight through, and I ended up with weird splotches on my hardwood.

That’s rough. I tried the bedsheet trick too - total disaster, especially with oil-based paint. The blue tape is one of those things I keep trying to swap out for something cheaper, but nothing else gives me those crisp lines. Have you ever tried the green tape? I found it a bit less expensive, but honestly, it didn’t stick as well for me. Maybe it’s just my walls? Sometimes I wonder if there’s a secret pro hack for this stuff that we’re all missing...


Reply

Trimming Down Expenses On Project Supplies

Yeah, I hear you on the tape. I’ve tried the green stuff too - didn’t love it. It peeled off some of my primer once, which was a pain. Honestly, I’ve just accepted that blue tape is one of those things you can’t really cheap out on if you want clean lines. As for drop cloths, I switched to those canvas ones a while back. They’re not super cheap up front, but they last forever and don’t let anything through. Old bedsheets are just asking for trouble... learned that the hard way too.


Reply

Trimming Down Expenses On Project Supplies

Blue tape really is the gold standard - every time I try to save a few bucks with the generic stuff, I end up regretting it. The cleanup just isn’t worth it. I’m with you on canvas drop cloths too. They’re not cheap, but after ruining a hardwood floor with a leaky plastic sheet (never again), I’m convinced they pay for themselves. One thing I do skimp on is paint trays - I just line ‘em with grocery bags and reuse the same tray forever. Not glamorous, but it works.


Reply

Trimming Down Expenses On Project Supplies

Totally agree on the blue tape - every time I try to cut corners with the off-brand stuff, I end up spending more time scraping paint off trim. It’s just not worth the hassle. Canvas drop cloths are a must for me too, especially after one client’s dog managed to tear a hole in a plastic sheet and tracked paint everywhere... lesson learned.

One thing I’ve found helps is buying certain supplies in bulk, like roller covers or sandpaper. The upfront cost is higher, but you get better quality and it lasts longer. For paint trays, I’ve actually started using those heavy-duty aluminum roasting pans from the dollar store. They’re sturdy, easy to clean, and if one gets too gross, I don’t feel bad tossing it.

I do wonder about brushes, though. I’ve tried both cheap and expensive ones, and sometimes the mid-range ones seem to hold up just as well if you clean them right away. Anyone else notice that, or am I just lucky with my brush choices?


Reply

Trimming Down Expenses On Project Supplies

I do wonder about brushes, though. I’ve tried both cheap and expensive ones, and sometimes the mid-range ones seem to hold up just as well if you clean them right away. Anyone else notice that, or am I just lucky with my brush choices?

I’ve had the same debate with myself every time I’m standing in the aisle staring at a wall of brushes. Honestly, I think you’re onto something with the mid-range ones. The super cheap brushes always seem to shed bristles everywhere - nothing like picking hairs out of fresh paint to make you question your life choices. But the top-shelf ones? I’ve splurged a couple times and didn’t notice a huge difference, as long as I cleaned them right after.

I’m a bit skeptical about the “buy once, cry once” logic for brushes. Maybe if you’re doing fine detail work or staining cabinets, but for walls and trim, a decent $8-12 brush seems to last me through several projects if I don’t get lazy about rinsing it out. The only time I regretted going cheap was when the handle snapped mid-job... lesson learned there.

Bulk buying is a good call for stuff like roller covers and sandpaper. I’ve also started reusing those plastic grocery bags as liners for paint trays - works in a pinch and saves a few bucks. The roasting pan idea is clever, though. Never thought of that.

Blue tape, though... yeah, there’s no substitute. Tried the bargain stuff once and ended up repainting half the baseboards. Sometimes saving a couple bucks just isn’t worth the headache.

Anyway, I guess it comes down to what you’re willing to risk. I’ll cut corners on some things, but not on anything that’ll cost me double in cleanup or repairs later.


Reply

The only time I regretted going cheap was when the handle snapped mid-job... lesson learned there.

That’s exactly why I stopped grabbing the bargain bin brushes. I’ve had a couple literally fall apart in my hand - bristles everywhere, ferrule loose, just a mess. I agree, mid-range is the sweet spot for most jobs. And blue tape? Tried to save a few bucks once, ended up cursing and scraping paint for hours. Some things just aren’t worth the gamble.


Reply

I’ve had a couple literally fall apart in my hand - bristles everywhere, ferrule loose, just a mess.

- Had the same thing happen with a roller frame - cheap metal bent and started squeaking halfway through the wall. Not fun.
- I’ll still grab discount drop cloths though. Haven’t noticed any difference there... paint still lands on ‘em just fine.
- Curious if anyone’s found any “budget” items that actually hold up? Or is it pretty much always mid-range or bust?


Reply

TRIMMING DOWN EXPENSES ON PROJECT SUPPLIES

I’ll admit, I’ve tried to cheap out on a few things over the years - usually ends up costing more in the long run, at least for the “tools with moving parts” category. Brushes and rollers from the bargain bin? Never again. I had a roller handle snap mid-stroke once and splatter paint all over my hardwood. Not a fun day.

Drop cloths though, yeah, I’m with you there. Haven’t noticed much difference between the $5 and $20 ones - paint doesn’t care what it lands on, just as long as it’s not my rug. I just make sure they’re not plastic, because those things are basically slip-n-slides waiting to happen.

One thing I actually do buy on the cheap: painter’s tape. The blue stuff is great, but I swear half the time I get better lines with the generic green roll. Maybe I just got lucky? Or maybe it’s all in how you press it down.

Honestly, for most tools, mid-range is usually my sweet spot. The ultra-budget stuff falls apart, but high-end sometimes feels like paying for a logo or fancy packaging. If it’s something I’m only going to use once (like weird specialty caulk guns), then yeah, I’ll grab the cheapest one and hope for the best.

But brushes... learned that lesson too many times. If you find a budget brand that actually holds up for more than a weekend - let us know. Until then, I’m sticking with my trusty Purdy and Wooster for anything that matters.


Reply

TRIMMING DOWN EXPENSES ON PROJECT SUPPLIES

I hear you on the brushes - cheap ones just end up in the landfill way too fast, which bugs me. I try to go for the ones with recycled handles or natural bristles if I can find them, even if they cost a bit more. Funny enough, I’ve had better luck with those lasting longer too. As for drop cloths, totally agree about avoiding plastic... not just slippery but also a pain to get rid of responsibly. If you ever spot reusable canvas ones on sale, grab ’em - they last forever and you can wash out most paint stains (ask me how I know).


Reply

TRIMMING DOWN EXPENSES ON PROJECT SUPPLIES

I get the appeal of canvas drop cloths, but honestly, I’ve had mixed results with them. They’re sturdy, sure, but sometimes paint still seeps through if you’re not careful - ask me how I learned that one... For quick jobs, I actually reuse old bedsheets or curtains. Not as fancy, but they do the trick and it’s one less thing to buy. As for brushes, totally agree about skipping the cheap ones. But I’ll admit, sometimes those mid-range synthetics surprise me and last longer than expected.


Reply

TRIMMING DOWN EXPENSES ON PROJECT SUPPLIES

Bedsheets as drop cloths - now that’s a move I can get behind. I’ve done the same with old shower curtains, actually. They’re waterproof, so you don’t get that “surprise paint blob on the floor” moment. But then again, they can be slippery if you’re not careful, and I’ve nearly wiped out more than once. Ever tried using cardboard for smaller paint jobs? Not the prettiest, but it’s sturdy and usually free if you’ve got some shipping boxes lying around.

About those canvas drop cloths - do you think it’s a thickness issue? I’ve noticed the cheaper ones are almost see-through, while the heavy-duty ones are basically indestructible (and cost twice as much). Sometimes I wonder if it’s worth investing in one good one and just washing it when needed, or if that’s just me trying to justify spending more up front.

Brushes are a whole other story. I used to buy those bargain packs thinking I was being clever, but they’d shed bristles everywhere and leave streaks. Now I stick with mid-range synthetics too. They seem to hold up better than natural bristle for water-based paints, at least in my experience. Anyone else find that cleaning them properly is half the battle? If I forget and let them dry out... well, they’re basically toast.

Curious if anyone’s found a way to reuse or recycle those plastic paint trays? I hate tossing them after one use, but cleaning them is such a pain. Maybe there’s a hack I haven’t tried yet...


Reply

TRIMMING DOWN EXPENSES ON PROJECT SUPPLIES

I’ve tried the shower curtain trick too, but I had the same problem - nearly busted my tail when I stepped on a paint blob and slid across the room. Cardboard’s decent for touch-ups, but if you spill a lot, it’ll soak through fast. I’ve started saving those big brown paper bags from grocery runs and slicing them open for smaller jobs. Not perfect, but at least they don’t slide around as much.

On the canvas drop cloths, I used to buy the cheap ones and just double them up, but honestly, I’ve ended up spending more over time replacing them. The heavy-duty ones are a pain to wash, but they last forever. I’m still using one I bought five years ago, so maybe it’s worth the upfront cost if you’re doing projects semi-regularly.

Paint trays are a headache. I’ve lined them with plastic grocery bags or even aluminum foil to make cleanup easier, but it’s not a perfect solution. I wish there was a better way that didn’t just add more plastic waste. If someone invents a reusable tray that’s actually easy to clean, I’d be all over it.


Reply

TRIMMING DOWN EXPENSES ON PROJECT SUPPLIES

Totally agree on the heavy-duty canvas drop cloths - mine’s been through at least a dozen rooms and still kicking. Upfront cost stings, but it’s paid for itself.

- Tried the brown paper bag trick too. Works for quick jobs, but I’ve had paint seep through if I’m not careful.
- For paint trays, I’ve started using those cheap plastic food containers (the big ones from takeout). They’re sturdy enough to rinse out and reuse a few times, and I don’t feel as bad tossing them when they finally give up.
-

“If someone invents a reusable tray that’s actually easy to clean, I’d be all over it.”
Same here. The grooves are always a pain to scrub. Closest I’ve found is just using a roller grid in a 5-gallon bucket - less mess, but not perfect.

Honestly, sometimes spending a bit more upfront saves a lot of hassle down the line.


Reply

TRIMMING DOWN EXPENSES ON PROJECT SUPPLIES

- I get the appeal of reusing takeout containers for paint trays, but honestly, I’ve had mixed luck. The plastic warps if you use anything stronger than latex, and sometimes the edges crack when you try to clean them out. Not saying it’s a bad hack, just not as reliable as it sounds - especially if you’re doing more than a quick touch-up.

- On the drop cloths: canvas is solid, but I’ve actually switched to those thick rubber-backed runners for certain jobs. They don’t bunch up or slide around like canvas can, especially on hardwood. Downside is they’re heavier and a pain to store, but I’ve never had a spill bleed through.

- Brown paper bags... tried that once. Never again. Maybe for baseboards or tiny spots, but anything bigger and you’re risking a mess. Learned that the hard way after a gallon of primer soaked right through onto new tile.

- As for reusable trays - honestly, I just line the metal ones with cheap plastic liners. Not exactly eco-friendly, but it saves time and scrubbing. The “easy to clean” part is always a myth in my experience; even with liners you end up with dried paint in the corners.

- Spending more upfront does make sense sometimes, but there’s a limit. I’ve seen folks buy every “pro” gadget out there and still end up with mediocre results because they rush prep or skip cleanup. Tools help, but technique matters more.

Guess my take is: cut costs where you can, but don’t expect shortcuts to always pay off. Sometimes old-school methods (and a little extra elbow grease) are still the best bet.


Reply

TRIMMING DOWN EXPENSES ON PROJECT SUPPLIES

I hear you on the takeout containers - tried using them for primer once and ended up with a warped mess. For drop cloths, I actually grabbed a couple of old shower curtains from a thrift store. They’re waterproof, super cheap, and fold up small. Not perfect for every job, but they’ve saved my floors more than once. I do agree that technique matters way more than fancy tools... learned that the hard way painting my first room.


Reply

TRIMMING DOWN EXPENSES ON PROJECT SUPPLIES

Shower curtains for drop cloths - now that’s thinking outside the box. I’ve tried those plastic tablecloths from dollar stores, but they’re a bit too slippery if you’re not careful. Honestly, I’m always torn between being frugal and just biting the bullet for the “real” supplies, but half the time it doesn’t even make a difference. Anyone else ever use cardboard boxes flattened out? Not pretty, but they did the trick for me during a messy demo job. Technique definitely saves more headaches than brand names.


Reply

TRIMMING DOWN EXPENSES ON PROJECT SUPPLIES

- Cardboard boxes are underrated. Used a bunch when I was painting our new place - just cut them open and taped them together for the hallway. Not the prettiest, but I didn’t care since it was all getting tossed anyway.
- Tried those cheap plastic tablecloths too, but they bunched up and slid around. Ended up with more paint on my socks than the floor. Maybe I just need to tape them better?
- Old bedsheets from thrift stores have been my go-to for drop cloths. They’re heavy enough to stay put, and you can usually grab a stack for a few bucks. Not waterproof, but for dust or light splatter, they’re solid.
- Shower curtains are a new one for me. Might try that next time, especially for bigger rooms.

I get what you mean about technique mattering more than the actual product. Sometimes I’ll spend ages prepping and still manage to miss a spot, but when I rush, that’s when I end up with a mess. The only thing I won’t skimp on is painter’s tape - tried the dollar store stuff once, and it ripped up half the wall when I pulled it off. Lesson learned.

Curious - has anyone found a good hack for covering up outlets and switches? I always end up with paint in the weirdest places, even when I think I’ve covered everything.


Reply

TRIMMING DOWN EXPENSES ON PROJECT SUPPLIES

- I’ve had the same issue with cheap painter’s tape - never again. The blue stuff is worth it.
- For outlets and switches, I usually just unscrew the covers and stick them in a ziplock bag until I’m done. If I’m feeling lazy, a bit of aluminum foil pressed around the edges works in a pinch. Not perfect, but it’s quick.
- Old cereal box cardboard cut to size can be wedged behind switches too, if you don’t want to mess with foil or tape.

Curious if anyone’s found a reusable solution for this? I always feel weird tossing so much tape and plastic after a project...


Reply
Scroll to Top