Custom homes discussions and local services.

Figuring out the right lot size without losing your mind

213 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

Totally agree orientation can be a game changer. When we built our place, we initially focused way too much on total area and almost missed out on capturing the morning sun in our kitchen. Luckily, our architect nudged us to reconsider window placement. Now, even though our lot's modest, the house feels so much bigger and brighter - especially at sunrise. Sometimes it's the subtle things that make the biggest difference, you know?


Reply

We had a similar experience when planning our current home. Initially, we prioritized maximizing square footage, thinking more space automatically meant better living. But after visiting a friend's place that was smaller yet felt incredibly spacious due to thoughtful orientation and window placement, we reconsidered our approach. We ended up sacrificing some total area to position the living room windows facing southwest for afternoon light. Honestly, best decision we made - the quality of the space improved dramatically, even though it's technically smaller on paper.


Reply

"We ended up sacrificing some total area to position the living room windows facing southwest for afternoon light."

Interesting perspective, though I'd argue that orientation isn't always worth sacrificing square footage. We prioritized space for flexibility and future-proofing - natural light is great, but you can't easily add more room later...


Reply

We did something similar - ended up losing a bit of square footage to get better morning sun in the kitchen. Honestly, at first I was worried we'd regret it, but now it's my favorite spot in the house. Sure, extra space is always nice, but there's something about natural light that makes a home feel welcoming and cozy. Sounds like you made a thoughtful choice...bet you'll love those sunny afternoons.


Reply

"Sure, extra space is always nice, but there's something about natural light that makes a home feel welcoming and cozy."

Interesting perspective - I agree natural light can transform a space. Did you find it challenging to balance the desire for sunlight with privacy concerns from neighbors or street views? Curious how others navigated that trade-off...


Reply

Natural light's great, but honestly, privacy's never been a big issue for me. Decent blinds or sheer curtains usually do the trick. I'd rather have a bit more yard space for gardening or grilling than worry too much about sunlight angles...


Reply

"I'd rather have a bit more yard space for gardening or grilling than worry too much about sunlight angles..."

I get where you're coming from, but after building quite a few homes, I've learned the hard way that sunlight angles can make or break your outdoor experience. I had a client once who insisted on maximizing yard space without considering orientation. Turned out his dream patio was blazing hot in the afternoons when he wanted to grill - he ended up barely using it. Meanwhile, another family with a smaller yard but better sunlight positioning practically lives outside because it's comfortable all day.

Not saying you have to obsess over angles or anything, just something to keep in mind if you're planning to spend serious time outdoors. A little extra thought early on can save you from trying to grill burgers under the scorching sun later.


Reply

Good points here, but honestly, yard size and sunlight angles don't have to be mutually exclusive. I've seen plenty of people get creative with landscaping or shade structures to offset less-than-ideal sun exposure. A friend of mine had a similar issue - big yard, but the afternoon sun was brutal. He ended up building a pergola with adjustable shades and planting some fast-growing trees strategically. Now he grills comfortably even on hot days.

I agree orientation matters, but if you're already set on a bigger yard, there are definitely workarounds. Just factor in some budget for shade solutions or landscaping tweaks down the road. It's not always about choosing one or the other...sometimes it's just about planning ahead a bit.


Reply

Totally agree about the pergola idea - my backyard faces west and used to feel like a frying pan every afternoon. I tried umbrellas first, but they were always tipping over or blowing away (lesson learned there...). Eventually, we built a covered patio with some roll-down shades on the sides. Made a huge difference, and now it's actually pleasant out there even in July.

One thing I'd add is that landscaping can really help too. We planted some taller shrubs along the fence line to block that low-angle sun in the late afternoons. Took a couple years for them to fill in, but now they're doing double duty - shade plus privacy from neighbors.

Point is, bigger yards definitely have their perks, but you gotta be prepared to get creative sometimes. Just don't underestimate how much plants and structures can change your space once they're established.


Reply

"Just don't underestimate how much plants and structures can change your space once they're established."

Good point about landscaping - people often overlook how much difference it makes. Curious, did you consider deciduous trees at all? I've found they're great for blocking summer sun but still letting in warmth during winter. Takes patience, sure, but once they're grown in, it's like having adjustable shading built right into your yard. Just gotta plan carefully so roots don't mess with patios or foundations later on...


Reply

Deciduous trees are great, but honestly they're not always the best fit for smaller lots. I've seen people underestimate just how big those trees can get - branches overhanging roofs, gutters clogged with leaves every fall... Plus, even careful root planning doesn't always pan out. Sometimes smaller shrubs or pergolas with climbing plants give you similar shade control without the long-term headaches. Just something else to think about.


Reply

"Sometimes smaller shrubs or pergolas with climbing plants give you similar shade control without the long-term headaches."

Fair point, but pergolas and climbers don't really match the cooling effect of a mature tree canopy. Maybe consider dwarf or columnar varieties - less invasive roots, manageable size, and still decent shade coverage.


Reply

True, dwarf or columnar trees can be handy, but honestly, I've found their shade coverage a bit underwhelming. A few years back, I planted some columnar maples thinking they'd be the perfect compromise - manageable roots, decent shade - but they just didn't spread enough to cool the patio effectively. Ended up adding a pergola with grapevines anyway. Not quite as cooling as a big tree canopy, but surprisingly effective once established...and bonus points for fresh grapes every summer.


Reply

"Ended up adding a pergola with grapevines anyway. Not quite as cooling as a big tree canopy, but surprisingly effective once established...and bonus points for fresh grapes every summer."

Funny you mention grapevines - I went through something similar. Thought I'd nailed it with dwarf fruit trees around the deck, but nope, shade was pretty meh. Eventually built a pergola too, but went with hops instead of grapes. Shade's decent, and hey, homegrown hops make for some pretty tasty homebrew batches. Guess sometimes DIY landscaping is just trial and error...mostly error in my case.


Reply

We went the pergola route too, but instead of grapes or hops, we tried passionfruit vines. Honestly, I underestimated how aggressively they grow - felt like I was trimming them every weekend at one point. Shade-wise they're pretty decent once fully established, and the fruit's great, but man...the maintenance was more than I bargained for. Definitely something to keep in mind if you're considering vine-covered pergolas as a shade solution.


Reply

"Honestly, I underestimated how aggressively they grow - felt like I was trimming them every weekend at one point."

Did you find the passionfruit vines affected the overall feel of your outdoor space? I've seen pergolas with passionfruit, and while they're beautiful and lush, sometimes they can make a space feel a bit closed-in or overly shaded. I wonder if something less aggressive, like jasmine or clematis, might strike a better balance between shade and openness. Jasmine especially has that bonus of fragrance without being quite as demanding on the pruning front. But then again, maybe the fruit makes all that extra maintenance worth it for you? Curious if you'd choose passionfruit again or try something different next time around...


Reply

"Honestly, I underestimated how aggressively they grow - felt like I was trimming them every weekend at one point."

I can definitely relate to this! Passionfruit vines have a way of quickly transforming a space, sometimes more than intended. From a design perspective, though, that lushness can be a real asset if you're aiming for a cozy, secluded feel. Jasmine is lovely too, but I've found it can take a while to establish. Maybe the passionfruit's rapid growth is a blessing in disguise - instant shade and fruit as a bonus...


Reply

"Maybe the passionfruit's rapid growth is a blessing in disguise - instant shade and fruit as a bonus..."

True, but I've seen passionfruit vines practically swallow fences whole if you're not careful. Ever tried kiwi vines instead? Similar lush look, tasty fruit, but maybe a bit easier to manage...


Reply

"Ever tried kiwi vines instead? Similar lush look, tasty fruit, but maybe a bit easier to manage..."

Kiwi vines can be great, but from my experience, they're not exactly low-maintenance either. A few years back, I was developing a small residential project and decided to incorporate kiwi vines along the perimeter fencing for aesthetics and privacy. They looked fantastic initially - lush, vibrant foliage, and the fruit was a nice bonus. But within two seasons, they were sprawling everywhere, and pruning became a regular chore. Not as aggressive as passionfruit, sure, but still pretty vigorous growers.

If you're looking for something manageable yet still attractive, you might consider grapevines. I've had good luck with them in urban developments - they grow steadily but aren't as overwhelming. Plus, homeowners tend to appreciate the added charm of grapes hanging around their patios. Just make sure you choose a variety suited to your climate and soil conditions... learned that lesson the hard way!


Reply

Kiwi vines do look great, but yeah, they can get pretty wild if you're not careful. Grapevines are nice too, but honestly, I've found hops to be a surprisingly good alternative. They grow fast enough to give you privacy without totally taking over your yard. Plus, they're pretty forgiving if you miss a pruning session or two... and hey, bonus points if you're into homebrewing beer. Just something else to consider.


Reply
Scroll to Top