Good point about the bricks—older reclaimed ones definitely vary a lot depending on their original firing process and clay type. I've seen some older bricks crack under high heat, probably from moisture or uneven density inside. As for spark screens, stainless steel is popular because it holds up well over time, but I've had decent luck with coated steel mesh too. Has anyone tried copper screens? Curious if they'd hold up or warp easily...
- Haven't tried copper myself, but I did use a coated steel mesh screen last summer. Worked fine at first, but after a few months it started warping slightly from the heat. Wonder if copper would hold up better or just discolor quickly...?
Copper screens do look great at first, but based on what I've seen they tend to discolor pretty quickly—turning dark or even greenish after repeated heat exposure and weather. Structurally, copper might actually hold up a bit better than coated steel since it's more resistant to warping. Still, the discoloration could be a downside if aesthetics matter to you. Wonder if stainless steel might be a better compromise between durability and appearance...?
Copper definitely has its quirks, doesn't it? When we first moved into our custom home, I was dead set on a copper fire pit screen—thought it'd give the backyard that cozy, rustic charm. And honestly, at first, it did. The glow from the fire reflecting off the copper was pretty magical, especially during those early evenings in fall.
But yeah, you're totally right about the discoloration. After a few months of regular use and some rainy weekends, ours started getting that greenish patina. At first, I panicked a little—felt like I'd ruined something beautiful. But then, weirdly enough, I started to appreciate it. It reminded me of those old copper roofs you see on historic buildings, how they age gracefully and tell a story over time. Now when friends come over, it's actually become a conversation starter; everyone seems intrigued by the unique look.
Still, if you're someone who prefers things looking pristine and polished, stainless steel might be the way to go. My neighbor went with stainless steel for his fire pit screen, and it's held up beautifully so far—no discoloration or noticeable warping after nearly two years. It doesn't have quite the same warm vibe as copper initially does, but it's sleek and modern-looking, which suits his style perfectly.
I guess it really comes down to what kind of aesthetic you're aiming for and how much you're willing to embrace the changes that come with natural materials. Either way, building your own space and making these decisions is part of the fun...even if it means learning to love a little imperfection along the way.
Totally agree about copper's charm growing over time. We went with copper accents around our outdoor kitchen, and at first, I was constantly polishing them to keep that shiny look. Eventually, I let it go, and now the patina actually complements the stonework beautifully. Funny how sometimes the imperfections end up being the best part...though I get why stainless steel appeals if you're after a more modern vibe.
