Custom homes discussions and local services.

291 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

Open Shelves: Love-Hate Relationship

I hear you on the dust. Maybe it’s just my luck, but I swear the second I put something on an open shelf, it starts collecting a layer of fuzz. Doesn’t matter if I use it daily or not - my kitchen seems to be a magnet for it. I do think you’re right about open shelves being best for stuff you grab all the time, though. My coffee mugs and bowls get rotated enough that dust isn’t a huge issue there.

Mixing open and closed storage is definitely the sweet spot. I tried going all-in on open shelves once because it looked so good in photos, but in real life? It was a constant battle to keep things looking tidy, and I got tired of wiping down every plate and glass. Now I keep the “pretty” stuff behind doors and just a few essentials out. Also, I can’t be trusted with more than six mugs, so open shelves are a built-in limit for me too...


Reply

Open Shelves: Love-Hate Relationship

You’re not alone - open shelves are definitely a double-edged sword. They look awesome in photos, but real life is a different beast. I tried to fight the dust with weekly cleanings, but honestly, it felt like a losing battle after a while. Mixing open and closed storage is a smart move and actually helps keep your kitchen functional without sacrificing style. If you ever want to cut down on the dust, I’ve found that placing items at a slight angle (so less surface faces up) helps a bit... not perfect, but better than nothing. And yeah, limiting the number of mugs out is probably saving you from way more cleaning than you realize.


Reply

OPEN SHELVES: LOVE-HATE RELATIONSHIP

I hear you on the dust - it’s relentless. I’ve worked on a few projects where clients insisted on open shelving, and every time, it’s the same story: looks great for about a week, then reality sets in. One thing I’ve noticed is that the type of material matters more than people expect. Wood shelves seem to collect dust faster than metal or glass, probably because of the texture. If you’re set on open shelves, going with smoother surfaces can make wiping down less of a chore.

Mixing open and closed storage is definitely the way to go. I’ve seen some kitchens where they use open shelves just for display pieces - stuff that doesn’t get touched much - while all the daily-use items are tucked away behind doors. Keeps things looking curated without turning into a daily cleaning job.

Funny enough, I once had a client who put LED strip lights under their open shelves thinking it’d make everything look “showroom ready.” It did... but it also highlighted every speck of dust and fingerprint. Sometimes less is more.

If you’re designing from scratch, maybe consider glass-front cabinets as a compromise? You still get that airy vibe but with way less exposure to dust. Or even partial doors - like half-glass, half-solid - if you want to show off your favorite mugs but hide the rest.

At the end of the day, it comes down to how much time you want to spend maintaining the look versus actually using your kitchen. For most folks I work with, a little bit of both seems to keep everyone sane.


Reply

OPEN SHELVES: LOVE-HATE RELATIONSHIP

You nailed it with the LED lights - those things are brutal for showing off every smudge. I’ve tried open shelves in my own place and honestly, the dusting gets old fast. Still, I get the appeal. Mixing in a few closed cabinets is just practical. If you’re set on open, I’d second the smoother materials - easier to wipe, and they just look cleaner longer. Glass-fronts are a solid compromise, too. It’s all about finding that balance between style and sanity.


Reply

OPEN SHELVES: LOVE-HATE RELATIONSHIP

Mixing in a few closed cabinets is just practical.

That’s what I ended up doing, too. I wanted all open shelves at first, but after a month of wiping off dust (and cat hair, somehow), I caved and added some doors. Does anyone actually keep their open shelves looking “styled” all the time, or does it just become a dumping ground? I feel like mine always end up cluttered no matter how hard I try.


Reply

OPEN SHELVES: LOVE-HATE RELATIONSHIP

I get where you’re coming from, but honestly, I still prefer mostly open shelves. Yeah, they need more upkeep, but for me, it’s worth it to actually see what I have and keep things accessible. I’ve found that if I limit what goes on them - just the stuff I use daily - the clutter doesn’t build up as much. The trick is not letting them turn into “catch-all” zones...easier said than done, I know. Still, I’d rather deal with a little dust than dig through closed cabinets for everything.


Reply

OPEN SHELVES: LOVE-HATE RELATIONSHIP

Funny, I used to be all about open shelves too - until I built my own kitchen. Thought it’d be super practical, but I didn’t realize how much dust and grease builds up, especially near the stove. Ended up having to wipe down my coffee mugs every couple days. On the flip side, I do like grabbing stuff without opening doors, especially when my hands are full. Guess it’s a trade-off... I’ve started mixing in a few closed cabinets just to hide the messier stuff.


Reply

OPEN SHELVES: LOVE-HATE RELATIONSHIP

Totally get where you’re coming from. Open shelves look amazing in those Pinterest kitchens, but real life is a whole different thing. I’ve designed a few spaces with open shelving and, honestly, the “easy access” perk is great until you realize your favorite cereal bowl has a thin layer of dust every time you grab it. And don’t even get me started on the oil splatter if the shelves are anywhere near the stove - unless you love cleaning as a hobby.

That said, I’m still a fan of using open shelves for stuff that gets used daily - plates, glasses, whatever - since they don’t have time to collect grime. Mixing in closed cabinets is kind of the sweet spot. You get that airy, open vibe without having to display your mismatched Tupperware or half-empty spice jars. It’s all about balance... and maybe being honest about how much cleaning you’re actually willing to do.


Reply

OPEN SHELVES: LOVE-HATE RELATIONSHIP

I hear you on the dust and splatter - open shelves are definitely not for the faint of heart. But honestly, I think they’re worth it if you’re intentional about what goes on them. I’ve built a few kitchens where we kept open shelves away from the stove and sink, just to dodge the worst of the mess. Also, grouping everyday stuff together makes it way less of a hassle. Closed cabinets for the chaos, open shelves for the pretty (and practical) stuff... that’s usually my go-to combo.


Reply

OPEN SHELVES: LOVE-HATE RELATIONSHIP

Closed cabinets for the chaos, open shelves for the pretty (and practical) stuff... that’s usually my go-to combo.

That’s a solid approach. I’ve found that open shelves can actually make people more mindful about what they keep out - almost forces you to edit down to what you really use or love. Have you ever tried using glass-front cabinets as a middle ground? They cut down on dust but still let you show off your favorite pieces. Curious if you’ve run into any issues with shelf depth or bracket placement - sometimes those little details end up making or breaking the look.


Reply

OPEN SHELVES: LOVE-HATE RELATIONSHIP

Glass-front cabinets look nice, but honestly, they’re usually way pricier than open shelves or basic cabinets. I tried open shelves in my last kitchen to save money, but the dust drove me nuts. Ended up just sticking stuff in baskets - cheaper and hides the mess. Shelf depth is tricky too... sometimes you can’t even fit a dinner plate without it looking awkward.


Reply

OPEN SHELVES: LOVE-HATE RELATIONSHIP

I get the dust issue, but honestly, I think it comes down to what you store. If you only keep daily-use stuff on open shelves, it doesn’t really have time to collect dust. I measured my plates before installing shelves - ended up going with 12” deep so nothing sticks out awkwardly. Not as cheap as the shallow ones, but still way less than glass-front cabinets. Just takes a bit of planning.


Reply

OPEN SHELVES: LOVE-HATE RELATIONSHIP

If you only keep daily-use stuff on open shelves, it doesn’t really have time to collect dust.

Totally agree - open shelves are way less of a dust magnet if you’re actually using what’s on them. I’ve seen folks put their “fancy” dishes up there and then wonder why they’re wiping down plates every week. Deep shelves are smart too. I’ve had clients regret going too shallow... mugs hanging off the edge just look awkward. Planning ahead saves a lot of headaches.


Reply

OPEN SHELVES: LOVE-HATE RELATIONSHIP

Yeah, totally with you on the daily-use stuff. If it’s in constant rotation, dust barely stands a chance. One thing I’d add - think about what the shelves are made of, too. Wood with a natural finish can be easier to wipe down and feels warmer in the space. I’ve also found that staggering shelf heights helps with airflow and makes cleaning less of a chore. Deep shelves are key, but don’t forget to anchor them well... nothing like a shelf disaster to ruin your day.


Reply

OPEN SHELVES: LOVE-HATE RELATIONSHIP

Funny you mention anchoring - learned that the hard way when my “floating” shelf decided to float right off the wall. Took half my spice jars with it. I do love the look of open shelves, but man, they keep you honest about clutter. I’m with you on wood, though - nothing beats that warm, lived-in vibe.


Reply

OPEN SHELVES: LOVE-HATE RELATIONSHIP

I do love the look of open shelves, but man, they keep you honest about clutter.

That’s exactly what I’m nervous about. We’re just finishing our kitchen and I keep going back and forth - open shelves look so good in photos, but I’m not sure I can keep them looking tidy in real life. For those who have them, do you regret it at all, or does the “honest about clutter” thing actually help you stay organized? And how do you handle stuff that’s not so pretty, like mismatched mugs or random gadgets?


Reply

OPEN SHELVES: LOVE-HATE RELATIONSHIP

We put in open shelves last year, and honestly, they do force you to keep things in check. I use baskets for the ugly stuff - think random gadgets or mismatched mugs. It’s not perfect, but it works. Some days they look great, other days... not so much. But I don’t regret it. It actually made me get rid of a lot of junk I never used.


Reply

OPEN SHELVES: LOVE-HATE RELATIONSHIP

I totally get the “some days they look great, other days not so much” thing. Open shelves are like that friend who’s super fun but also a little high-maintenance. I’ve always wondered - do you find yourself buying prettier dishes just to keep the shelves looking good? I keep thinking about switching to open shelving in my kitchen, but I’m worried I’ll end up obsessing over fingerprints and dust.

Also, how do you handle stuff like spices or oils? I love the idea of baskets for the random bits, but I’m not sure if that would work for everything. Part of me loves the curated look, but part of me knows my family would just toss things up there and call it a day...

Did you have to get rid of a lot of things to make it work, or did you just hide the chaos in baskets?


Reply

OPEN SHELVES: LOVE-HATE RELATIONSHIP

Funny you mention the “curated look” vs. family reality - I tried open shelves in our last kitchen, and honestly, it forced us to pare down way more than I expected. I had to ask myself, do I really need six mismatched mugs or just the ones we actually use? Dust is a thing, but I found it manageable if I kept the shelves less crowded. For spices and oils, I went with glass jars and a couple of recycled wood boxes, but it’s true, not everything fits the aesthetic. I did end up hiding some stuff in baskets, but I wonder if that kind of defeats the purpose? Sometimes I think closed cabinets are just easier, especially with kids grabbing things all the time...


Reply

OPEN SHELVES: LOVE-HATE RELATIONSHIP

I’m right in the middle of this debate with myself as we plan our kitchen. I love the idea of open shelves - makes everything look so airy and “Pinterest-y” - but then I remember my current mug collection (half chipped, all sentimental) and wonder if I’m just setting myself up for daily dusting. My partner’s already joking that our shelves would just become a shrine to random water bottles and sippy cups. Maybe baskets are the compromise? But yeah, feels a bit like cheating...


Reply
Scroll to Top