"installation isn't nearly as itchy or unpleasant as fiberglass."
Totally agree there—fiberglass is the worst! Glad to see cellulose getting some love. Wool sounds lovely, but yeah, cellulose is a solid choice, especially if you're balancing budget and sustainability... Good call.
"cellulose is a solid choice, especially if you're balancing budget and sustainability..."
Cellulose definitely has its merits, especially from a sustainability standpoint, but I wouldn't dismiss fiberglass entirely. I've overseen several projects where fiberglass insulation was installed properly, and honestly, when handled correctly—with proper protective gear and careful installation—it's not nearly as nightmarish as some make it out to be. Sure, it's itchy if you're careless, but that's true of many building materials.
One thing to consider is moisture resistance. Cellulose can sometimes absorb moisture more readily than fiberglass, potentially leading to mold issues down the line if your attic isn't perfectly ventilated. I've seen this happen firsthand in a renovation project we tackled a few years back. The homeowner had opted for cellulose insulation because of its eco-friendly reputation, but unfortunately, the attic ventilation wasn't adequate. Within a couple of years, we had to rip it all out due to mold growth—definitely not ideal from either a budget or sustainability perspective.
Fiberglass, on the other hand, tends to be more resistant to moisture-related problems. It's also generally easier to find contractors who are experienced with fiberglass installation, which can make a difference in terms of overall quality and longevity.
Don't get me wrong—I'm all for exploring greener alternatives like cellulose or wool. But it's important to weigh all factors carefully, including your home's specific conditions and climate. Sometimes the "itchy pink nightmare" isn't quite as bad as it seems, especially if you take the right precautions during installation. Just something to keep in mind before completely ruling it out...
Good points on fiberglass, but honestly, cellulose isn't always a mold magnet. I've had it in my attic for 6 years now, zero mold issues—though ventilation is key, like you said. Guess it really depends on your home's setup and local climate...
Good to hear your cellulose insulation's holding up well. A few quick thoughts from my experience:
- Totally agree ventilation makes or breaks it—good airflow solves a lot.
- Local humidity and attic setup definitely play a huge role. I've seen cellulose do great in one home, then struggle in another just down the street.
- Mold worries can sometimes be overstated online; proper install usually prevents most issues.
Sounds like you've nailed the balance for your place, nice job.
Switched to cellulose myself last year after dealing with fiberglass for ages... best decision ever. My attic used to be a sauna in summer and freezing in winter, but now temps are way more stable. Agree ventilation is key, but honestly, proper install made the biggest difference for me.
