Honestly, I used to side-eye vinyl too, but the newer stuff is way better than what I remember from the '90s. Edge lifting can be a pain, but a solid underlayment and careful install really do help. For rentals or quick updates, it’s hard to beat—especially if you’re not keen on scrubbing grout lines every month.
For rentals or quick updates, it’s hard to beat—especially if you’re not keen on scrubbing grout lines every month.
Totally get this. I’ve seen some rental units where the vinyl looked way better than the old tile ever did. Still, I do miss the feel of real tile sometimes... but my knees don’t!
Funny you mention the knees—mine have a grudge against old-school tile too. I do love the look and heft of real ceramic, but after a few years in a place with those tiny hex tiles, I started eyeing vinyl with fresh appreciation. Have you ever tried any of those newer luxury vinyl tiles that actually have a bit of texture? Wondering if they scratch that “real tile” itch or if it’s just wishful thinking...
I hear you on the knees—those little hex tiles are murder after a while. I tried some of those “luxury” vinyl tiles in my laundry room, and honestly, they look decent from a distance. Up close, though, the texture’s just not quite there. The warmth underfoot is nice, but if you’re hoping for that solid, cold feel of real tile... it’s not quite the same. Still, my joints are happier these days, so maybe that’s the tradeoff.
Honestly, I think you nailed it—sometimes comfort has to win out over aesthetics. I used to be all about the “real” materials, but after a few marathon reno weekends, my back and knees convinced me otherwise. There’s something to be said for a floor that doesn’t punish you every time you do laundry. If it looks good enough and feels better, that’s a solid trade in my book.