Custom homes discussions and local services.

Cramped spaces and weird tile choices - anyone else?

434 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

“partial fixes are underrated. I used to think you had to rip everything out at once or it wouldn’t look right, but swapping out the worst tiles first really made a difference for me too.”

- Honestly, I get the appeal of tackling things bit by bit, but sometimes patchwork fixes can end up making the space feel even more cramped or mismatched.
- In my experience, especially with weird tile choices from the 90s, a bold move - like painting over the whole mess with tile paint - can actually unify the look way better than swapping a few tiles here and there.
- Caulk is a solid stopgap, but if you’re already pulling out tiles, it might be worth thinking about a bigger change. Even just regrouting everything in a fresh color can make old tiles look intentional, not accidental.
- I’ve seen folks spend months swapping tiles one by one, only to wish they’d just gone for a full refresh sooner. Sometimes the “rip the band-aid off” approach saves sanity in the long run, even if it’s a little more upfront work.
- That said, budgets are real. Just don’t underestimate how much a unified surface (even if it’s just paint or new grout) can open up a cramped space.

Partial fixes work, but sometimes a bold, simple change is less stressful than dragging it out.


Reply

Honestly, I totally get the urge to just paint over everything and call it a day. We tried swapping a few tiles in our tiny hallway bathroom, and it just made the weird patterns stand out even more... Ended up regrouting with a dark color and it actually pulled things together way better than I expected. Sometimes you don’t need to go full demo, just something to make it look intentional.


Reply

Title: Cramped Spaces And Weird Tile Choices - Anyone Else?

Funny thing, I’ve actually seen the opposite happen in a few projects. There was this one apartment - tiny bathroom, original 70s tile, all sorts of avocado and mustard tones. The owner tried to “make it work” by regrouting with a charcoal color, thinking it’d look intentional and modern. But honestly, it just made the old tiles pop even more, like they were outlined for emphasis. It was almost like putting a frame around a painting you don’t really like.

I get the appeal of not going full demo - demo is messy, expensive, and sometimes you just want to be done with it. But sometimes I wonder if these quick fixes draw more attention to the stuff we’re trying to hide? I’ve had better luck leaning into the weirdness or going for a bigger change in a small space. One client went wild and painted the ceiling a deep blue, which somehow distracted from the floor entirely. Another time, we just covered the old tile with peel-and-stick vinyl - looked surprisingly good and didn’t feel as “patched together” as swapping out a few tiles.

I guess what I’m saying is, sometimes those “intentional” fixes can backfire if the underlying pattern or color is just too out there. But then again, maybe that’s part of the fun - seeing what works and what doesn’t. Every space has its own quirks. Sometimes you win with grout, sometimes you just end up staring at avocado green for another decade...


Reply

It’s wild how much a grout color can change the vibe - sometimes for the worse. I tried using a trendy gray grout on some 80s peach tiles in our first house, thinking it’d “modernize” the look, but it just made them stand out more. Ended up regretting not just covering them up or biting the bullet with a bigger update. In small spaces, I’ve found that embracing the weird tile with bold paint or art works better than trying to disguise it. Quick fixes are tempting, but they don’t always blend in like you hope...


Reply

Quick fixes are tempting, but they don’t always blend in like you hope...

That’s the truth. I once tried to “fix” a dated bathroom in a rental by painting the tile grout white, thinking it’d look crisp and clean. Instead, it just highlighted every uneven line and made the old tile look even older. Sometimes leaning into the original character works better than fighting it. Has anyone here actually had success with peel-and-stick tile covers or is that just another band-aid?


Reply

Cramped Spaces And Weird Tile Choices - Anyone Else?

Peel-and-stick tiles are kind of a mixed bag. I tried them in a laundry room once, thinking it’d be a quick win. Here’s the thing: surface prep is everything. If the tile underneath isn’t squeaky clean and flat, those stickers start peeling at the corners within a few months. They look decent from a distance, but up close, you can usually spot the seams. Honestly, sometimes I think it’s less hassle just to re-grout or even embrace the retro vibe... avocado green and all.


Reply

Cramped Spaces And Weird Tile Choices - Anyone Else?

Totally get what you mean about peel-and-stick tiles. I tried them in a tiny bathroom, and yeah, they looked fine at first but started curling up at the edges after a while. I always wonder about the environmental impact too - are these things just destined for landfill after a couple years? Sometimes I think it’s better to just stick with old-school tile and grout, even if it means living with some funky colors from the 70s. At least those last forever... avocado green included.


Reply

Yeah, I hear you on the peel-and-stick tiles. They’re convenient, but I’ve seen them peel up in kitchens too - especially near sinks where there’s moisture. The waste factor bugs me as well. Real tile might be a pain to install, but it’s way more durable and doesn’t end up in the trash every few years. I’d rather live with retro colors than keep replacing stuff that just doesn’t last. Plus, there’s something kind of charming about those old avocado greens and burnt oranges... at least they have character.


Reply

I get what you mean about the old colors - my last place had this wild mustard yellow tile in the bathroom. At first, I thought it was hideous, but honestly, it grew on me. It held up way better than any peel-and-stick I’ve seen. I’ve tried those in rentals and they never lasted more than a year, especially near water. Real tile’s a hassle upfront, but you only do it once. Sometimes that “dated” look ends up being the most reliable thing in the house.


Reply

Funny how those bold tiles stick around. I once worked on a renovation where the client wanted to rip out these avocado green bathroom tiles from the '70s. They were convinced nothing could be worse, but after we looked at the cost and durability, they decided to keep them and just update the grout. Honestly, those tiles were still in perfect shape after decades - can’t say that for most modern materials. Sometimes the “weird” stuff is just built better.


Reply

CRAMPED SPACES AND WEIRD TILE CHOICES - ANYONE ELSE?

I get what you’re saying about the old tiles holding up, but do you ever wonder if durability alone is enough? I’ve seen some vintage tile jobs that were basically indestructible, but the color or pattern just made the whole room feel dated or even smaller. Sometimes I think it’s worth swapping out the “weird” stuff if it means the space feels more inviting. Or maybe there’s a way to blend the old with new finishes - like keeping the tile but adding modern fixtures? Curious if anyone’s tried that balance and actually liked the result.


Reply

Totally get where you’re coming from. I once worked on a bathroom that had these avocado green tiles - super sturdy, but man, they made the space feel like a cave. We kept the tile but swapped in a floating vanity and some sleek lighting. It actually looked intentional after that, kind of retro-modern. Sometimes just updating the fixtures and paint can make those old tiles feel less overwhelming.


Reply

Yeah, I hear you on the tile. I’ve tried painting over old tile before, but honestly, it didn’t hold up as well as I hoped. Swapping out hardware and adding a big mirror made a bigger difference for less cash. Sometimes you just gotta work with what you’ve got.


Reply

CRAMPED SPACES AND WEIRD TILE CHOICES - ANYONE ELSE?

- Totally agree - tile paint just doesn’t seem to last, especially in high-traffic spots or anywhere there’s moisture.
- Swapping out hardware is underrated. Quick change, big impact, and you don’t need a ton of tools.
- Mirrors are magic for tight rooms. I once put a giant one in a tiny powder bath and suddenly it felt twice as big.
- If you’re stuck with tile you hate, sometimes just re-grouting or using a grout pen can make it look cleaner without a full reno.
- I’ve seen folks use peel-and-stick vinyl tile over old ceramic - mixed results, but might be worth a shot if you’re desperate.

Honestly, sometimes you just have to embrace the weird and make it work for now...


Reply

Funny timing, I once inherited a bathroom with avocado green tile and zero natural light - total dungeon vibes. Ended up layering a big ornate mirror and swapping in some brass pulls. Didn’t fix the color, but it felt way more intentional after that. Sometimes you just gotta lean into the weird.


Reply

Didn’t fix the color, but it felt way more intentional after that. Sometimes you just gotta lean into the weird.

That’s honestly the best approach. I’ve run into my fair share of “what were they thinking?” tile choices - one place had this wild salmon pink and black combo in a powder room, which sounds kind of Art Deco but was more like ‘50s diner meets haunted house. At first I thought, no way am I living with this. But after a few failed attempts to disguise it, I ended up embracing the drama. Swapped in a vintage crystal light fixture and some heavy velvet curtains (yes, even in a tiny bathroom), and suddenly it looked like an intentional throwback instead of a design mishap.

I do think there’s something to be said for not fighting the bones of a space too hard. Sometimes those oddball details are what make a home memorable. Like your avocado green - sure, it’s not everyone’s dream shade, but paired with brass and an ornate mirror? That’s got character. And honestly, I’ve seen some high-end designers lately leaning into those retro palettes on purpose. Maybe we’re all just catching up to what our grandparents already knew.

The only thing I’d push back on is lighting - if there’s any way to sneak in more light (even if it’s just layering lamps or adding reflective surfaces), it can make those bold colors feel less oppressive and more playful. But yeah, sometimes you just have to roll with what you’ve got and let it become part of the story of the house.

Funny how these “flaws” end up being conversation starters when people visit. No one ever remembers a perfectly neutral bathroom, right?


Reply

Couldn’t agree more with this:

No one ever remembers a perfectly neutral bathroom, right?
That’s the thing - those “what were they thinking?” moments are what give a place its soul. I’ve toured so many high-end homes where everything is beige, beige, beige, and honestly, it just blurs together after a while. But the ones that stick in my mind? Always the ones with some wild tile or a color choice that makes you do a double take.

I’m with you on not fighting the bones of a space too hard. There’s a certain luxury in embracing what’s already there and making it work for you, rather than bulldozing every quirk into submission. I once saw a powder room with this almost lurid turquoise tile - think 1960s pool liner. The owners leaned in, added a gold-leafed ceiling and a massive, ornate mirror, and suddenly it felt like a jewel box instead of a design disaster. It’s all about confidence, honestly.

Lighting is a huge one, though. I’d even go a step further and say that in these quirky spaces, you can get away with more dramatic lighting than you’d expect. Sconces with colored glass, or even a statement pendant, can turn “weird” into “wow.” Reflective surfaces are underrated too - mirrored trays, metallic accessories, even a glossy paint finish can bounce light around and make those bold colors feel intentional.

One thing I’ll mildly disagree on: sometimes, if the tile is truly heinous (I’m talking hospital green or that muddy brown from the ‘70s), it’s worth considering a bold wallpaper or even a removable mural. Not to hide it, but to create a deliberate contrast. It’s like fashion - sometimes clashing on purpose is more stylish than trying to match.

At the end of the day, the best spaces are the ones that tell a story. I’d take a powder room that sparks conversation over a “tasteful” but forgettable one any day.


Reply

Cramped Spaces And Weird Tile Choices - Anyone Else?

- Had a similar situation in our first house. The main bathroom had this wild salmon-pink tile, floor to ceiling, with matching tub. At first, I thought about demoing the whole thing, but honestly, the cost was just not worth it for us at the time.
- Instead, leaned into it. Swapped out the old light fixture for a brass sconce and added a big round mirror with a chunky wood frame. Threw in some navy towels and a patterned shower curtain to break up all the pink. It actually started to feel intentional, not like we were stuck with someone else’s mistake.
- Agree on lighting making a huge difference. Even just switching bulbs to a warmer tone made the tile look less “hospital” and more retro-cool. People always commented on that bathroom, for better or worse... but at least they remembered it.
- I get the urge to cover up truly ugly tile, but sometimes those bold wallpapers just end up fighting with the tile instead of helping. Tried peel-and-stick wallpaper in our powder room (which had avocado green tile) and honestly, it looked busier than I expected. Ended up painting the ceiling a deep teal instead - way better.
- One thing I’ve learned: if you can’t hide it, highlight it. Add something unexpected - a funky piece of art, or even just a plant on the back of the toilet. Makes it feel like you meant for it to be that way all along.
- Not every “quirk” is worth saving, but sometimes it’s less about perfection and more about personality. Beige bathrooms are easy to forget. The weird ones stick with you, even if they make you shake your head a little.

Anyway, I’d rather have a bathroom that makes people laugh or ask questions than one that looks like a hotel lobby.


Reply

Honestly, I think you’re right - sometimes leaning into the weird is the best call. We had a bathroom with mustard yellow tile and I tried everything to “neutralize” it. In the end, a few black accents and some plants made it look like a choice, not a mistake. Beige bathrooms just fade into the background... at least the odd ones have character.


Reply

- Totally get where you’re coming from.
- Sometimes those “mistake” tiles end up being the most memorable part of a house.
- I’ve seen high-end homes with wild color combos - owners just leaned in and made it work.
- Plants and black accents? Smart move.
- Beige is safe, but honestly, it rarely feels special.
- Curious - did you ever consider going even bolder, like adding a funky mirror or art? Sometimes the weirder, the better...


Reply
Scroll to Top