Custom homes discussions and local services.

Finally upgraded my living room lights - anyone else tried smart bulbs?

1,190 replies 64.4 K views
 
0 posts

FINALLY UPGRADED MY LIVING ROOM LIGHTS - ANYONE ELSE TRIED SMART BULBS?

I swapped out a couple switches last year, and honestly, it wasn’t as scary as I thought. Biggest hurdle was figuring out if I had that neutral wire hiding in the back (turns out, I did... after some poking around). The nice part is you can use whatever bulbs you want, and nobody has to remember which switch not to touch. If you’re even a little handy, it’s doable - just double check your wiring diagrams and don’t rush. I will say, though, if you’ve got three-way switches, things get a bit trickier.


Reply
0 posts

FINALLY UPGRADED MY LIVING ROOM LIGHTS - ANYONE ELSE TRIED SMART BULBS?

Getting those switches swapped is a solid move, especially if you’re thinking long-term about energy use and flexibility. I’ve gone the smart bulb route in a few rooms, but honestly, I ended up preferring smart switches for most spaces - mainly because guests (and my kids) kept flipping the wall switch off and killing power to the bulbs. With switches, you keep your regular bulbs and don’t have to worry about compatibility or weird app updates.

Curious if you noticed any difference in your energy bill after the upgrade? I found that dimming features on both smart bulbs and switches can help cut down usage, but it’s not always dramatic unless you’re running lights all day. Also, did you run into any issues with older wiring? Some of my circuits didn’t have a neutral at all, which was a pain... had to get creative there.


Reply
0 posts

“Some of my circuits didn’t have a neutral at all, which was a pain... had to get creative there.”

- Ran into the same neutral wire issue in my 70s house. Ended up using Lutron Caseta switches since they don’t need a neutral. Not cheap, but way less hassle than rewiring.
- I’ve tried both smart bulbs and switches. Honestly, switches win for me - especially in shared spaces. Like you said, someone always kills the power at the wall and then Alexa can’t do squat.
- Energy bill difference? Hard to say. Dimming helps a bit, but unless you’re lighting up the place like an airport runway every night, it’s not a game-changer.
- Only spot I still use smart bulbs is in lamps or fixtures with no wall switch - otherwise, switches are just more reliable.

One thing I’ll add: if you go with smart bulbs, label your switches or put on those little switch guards. Saves a lot of “why won’t the lights work?” moments...


Reply
0 posts

Title: Finally Upgraded My Living Room Lights - Anyone Else Tried Smart Bulbs?

- Had the same “no neutral” headache in my place. Ended up staring at the wiring for way too long before realizing I needed a different switch.
- Tried smart bulbs first, but my family kept flipping the wall switch off. It was like a game of “why is it dark in here?” every other night.
- Honestly, switches just feel more natural. The only spot I stuck with bulbs is this weird corner lamp that’s impossible to reach otherwise.
- Haven’t noticed any wild changes on my energy bill either. Maybe a few bucks, but nothing to write home about.
- Those little switch guards are lifesavers... unless you live with someone who rips them off out of spite (ask me how I know).


Reply
0 posts

Totally get where you’re coming from with the “no neutral” mess. I had to do a bit of research and ended up swapping out a couple switches for ones that work without a neutral wire - definitely not as straightforward as I’d hoped. The whole smart bulb thing was a similar story here. First week, my partner kept hitting the wall switch out of habit, so half the time the bulbs were offline and the automations didn’t work. Ended up putting a little sticky note on the switch for a while, but that only lasted about two days before it got ignored.

Honestly, I found smart switches way more reliable for main lights. For lamps or spots where running new wiring would be a pain, smart plugs or bulbs make sense. If anyone’s thinking about it, I’d say: start with one room, see how your household actually uses the lights, and go from there. Energy savings are nice, but for me it’s more about convenience. And yeah, those switch guards… let’s just say they don’t survive long in a house with kids.


Reply

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

Scroll to Top