Interesting perspective, but I'd actually push back a bit on the humidity regulation point. I've found that in older buildings especially, solid brick walls can sometimes create more challenges than they solve. Sure, they're breathable, but that breathability can also mean moisture issues if the exterior isn't maintained meticulously. I remember one renovation project where the solid brick walls had absorbed so much moisture over time, we ended up with persistent mold problems indoors.
On the flip side, modern veneer systems—when installed properly—can offer more predictable moisture control, especially with today's advanced barrier materials. Of course, as you mentioned, the key phrase there is "installed properly"...I've seen my share of shortcuts gone wrong too.
In the end, I think the decision hinges less on climate alone and more on how much ongoing maintenance the homeowner is realistically willing to commit to. Solid brick has undeniable charm and thermal benefits, but it isn't always the simpler or more practical choice in the long run.
"Solid brick has undeniable charm and thermal benefits, but it isn't always the simpler or more practical choice in the long run."
This hits home for me. A couple of years back, I did a build for a client who insisted on solid brick walls for authenticity. The aesthetics were fantastic, no doubt, but the moisture management was a constant headache. Despite careful detailing and regular maintenance, we still ended up dealing with efflorescence issues within two years. Nothing catastrophic, but certainly annoying enough to warrant repeated callbacks.
On another project around the same time, we went with a modern brick veneer system paired with a high-quality vapor barrier. Honestly, it felt like cheating—far fewer callbacks, fewer headaches overall. Sure, it lacks some of that old-world charm, but from a purely practical standpoint, it's been smoother sailing.
In my experience, if you're willing to stay on top of maintenance and appreciate the authenticity factor, solid brick can be rewarding. But if low-maintenance practicality is your priority...brick veneer might just be the smarter choice.
I've definitely seen similar issues pop up. Solid brick looks amazing, but honestly, from a green building standpoint, veneer with proper insulation and moisture barriers usually wins out. Less hassle, better overall energy efficiency...just my two cents.
We went through this exact debate when renovating our old place. I loved the charm of solid brick, but after dealing with drafts and moisture issues in our first home (which was solid brick), we ended up going veneer with proper insulation this time around. Gotta admit, it's been way more comfortable and energy-efficient. Curious though, has anyone found a good compromise—maybe reclaimed brick veneer or something—to keep that authentic feel without sacrificing efficiency?
Totally agree on the reclaimed brick veneer idea—it's a solid compromise. We went that route in our kitchen remodel and honestly, most people can't even tell it's veneer until they touch it. Plus, you get way better insulation and moisture control without losing that cozy, authentic feel. Just make sure your installer knows their stuff; uneven application can kinda ruin the illusion... learned that the hard way in our mudroom.
