Custom homes discussions and local services.

Building base structures - what if you had to start over?

1,320 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

"Our builder thought grading was fine, but after one storm we realized runoff patterns were totally different than expected..."

This is such a good point. I've seen this happen more times than I can count - clients thinking everything's set, only to discover a mini lake forming in their backyard after the first big rain. It's funny how water always seems to have its own plans, no matter what the blueprints say...

One thing I'd add from experience is to also think about drainage when planning landscaping and outdoor spaces. I've worked on projects where the patio or garden beds unintentionally redirected water toward the house foundation. Beautiful design, but not exactly practical. A quick tip: if you're planting trees or shrubs, consider their mature root systems and how they'll affect drainage down the line. It's easier to adjust your landscaping plans early than to deal with soggy surprises later.


Reply

Couldn't agree more - grading can be tricky. I learned the hard way on one project where a slight slope adjustment completely changed runoff direction. Now I always recommend clients visit the site right after a heavy rain...it's eye-opening.


Reply

"Now I always recommend clients visit the site right after a heavy rain...it's eye-opening."

That's actually pretty solid advice. Even though I'm usually skeptical about clients visualizing technical details, seeing it firsthand after rainfall makes sense. Might save everyone some headaches down the road...


Reply

- Good point about rain visits - reminds me of a project where drainage issues became painfully obvious only after heavy storms...
- Definitely worth the extra hassle upfront to avoid nasty surprises later, right?


Reply

Speaking of drainage, ever tried using natural landscaping to handle runoff? A couple years back, I was on a tight budget and couldn't afford extensive drainage systems. Ended up planting strategic rows of shrubs and grasses to guide water flow naturally. Took some trial and error, and admittedly a few muddy weekends, but it saved me a chunk of money. Wonder if anyone else has experimented with landscaping solutions instead of traditional drains...?


Reply

I've actually recommended natural landscaping to clients before - it's surprising how effective it can be. One homeowner had constant pooling near their patio, and we ended up using a gravel bed combined with ornamental grasses to soak up and redirect water. Took a season to fully mature, but it looked great and solved the drainage issue without breaking the bank. Curious if you noticed any specific plants working better than others...?


Reply

I've had mixed luck with ornamental grasses myself - some varieties seem to thrive and soak up water like a sponge, while others just sit there looking sad. Miscanthus has been pretty reliable for me, especially in areas that get a lot of runoff. But I've also seen good results with native sedges; they're hardy and seem to handle fluctuating moisture levels better than most.

Funny enough, I once tried cattails near a client's pond area thinking they'd be perfect for drainage... big mistake. They took over everything within a season and turned into a maintenance nightmare. Lesson learned the hard way, haha.

Have you experimented much with groundcovers or creeping plants? I've been curious about using things like creeping thyme or ajuga in combination with gravel beds - wondering if they'd help stabilize the soil without getting too invasive.


Reply

I've tried creeping thyme in gravel beds before, and honestly, it wasn't as effective as I'd hoped. It looked great at first, but after heavy rains, it struggled to hold the soil together. Ajuga did better stability-wise, but it spread faster than I anticipated - borderline invasive in spots. Personally, I've had better luck with dwarf mondo grass; it's tidy, handles moisture fluctuations well, and doesn't creep out of control. Might be worth considering instead...


Reply

Interesting you've had luck with dwarf mondo grass - I haven't tried that one yet. But from a design perspective, I'm curious about how it holds up visually over time. Does it maintain that neat, tidy look long-term, or does it eventually get patchy or uneven like some grasses I've used before?

Also, you mentioned ajuga spreading aggressively - do you think using barriers or edging might help control it, or is it just too persistent? I've seen it used effectively in contained areas, but I've never personally dealt with managing it in open beds.

One other thought - have you ever experimented with sedums or other succulents in gravel areas? I've had clients request them in rock gardens and decorative gravel beds, and they usually look fantastic. But I'm not sure how well they'd perform stability-wise if heavy rains are an issue. Do you think they'd offer enough root structure to make a difference, or would they just wash out too?

Honestly, plant choice is always trickier than people think...especially when you're balancing aesthetics and practicality.


Reply

I've actually had pretty good luck with dwarf mondo grass holding its shape over time. It stays neat and compact, but you do have to watch out for areas with heavy foot traffic - it can thin out a bit there. Still, compared to some other grasses I've tried, it's definitely more consistent visually.

As for ajuga...honestly, barriers help somewhat, but that stuff is determined. I once put in edging thinking I'd keep it contained, and it just laughed at me and hopped right over. If you're okay with regular maintenance, it's manageable, but if you're looking for something low-maintenance, I'd steer clear.

Sedums in gravel beds are great visually - clients love them - but yeah, heavy rains can be tricky. I've found that if you choose varieties with deeper roots (like Sedum rupestre or spurium), they hold up better. But even then, if your site gets serious runoff, you'll probably need some strategic rock placement or subtle terracing to keep things stable.

You're totally right though - plant selection always seems simple until you're knee-deep in runaway groundcover or watching your carefully placed succulents float downstream after a storm...


Reply

Totally agree about the ajuga - it’s relentless. I tried it once thinking it'd be a nice filler around stepping stones, but within a year it was everywhere. Lesson learned. Also, dwarf mondo grass is solid, but I've noticed it can look patchy in shade-heavy spots. For shaded areas, I've had better luck mixing in creeping thyme or Corsican mint - smells great underfoot too, bonus points there.


Reply

I had a similar experience with ajuga - thought it would be manageable, but it quickly became invasive and difficult to control. Creeping thyme has been a reliable alternative for me as well, particularly in shaded areas. One thing I'd add is that Irish moss can also work nicely between stepping stones. It stays relatively compact, tolerates shade decently, and gives a clean, tidy appearance without spreading aggressively. Worth considering if you're looking for another option.


Reply

Interesting point about Irish moss - never thought of using it between stepping stones. Does it handle foot traffic pretty well, or do you find yourself stepping around it more carefully? Might give it a try myself...


Reply

I've thought about Irish moss too, but honestly, it seems a bit delicate for regular foot traffic. Maybe creeping thyme would hold up better? I've seen neighbors use it, and it smells great when stepped on... just a thought.


Reply

Creeping thyme sounds like a solid idea - plus, who doesn't love a nice scent underfoot? Have you thought about how it holds up in winter though? Curious if it'd bounce back easily after snow and ice...


Reply

I've actually been looking into creeping thyme myself, and from what I've read:

- Pretty hardy overall, handles cold winters decently.
- Might look a bit rough right after snow melts, but usually perks back up once spring kicks in.
- Good drainage seems key - standing water or ice buildup can cause issues.

I'm still debating it though...my yard gets pretty soggy in spots. Wonder if anyone's had luck mixing it with gravel or sand underneath for better drainage?


Reply

"Good drainage seems key - standing water or ice buildup can cause issues."

You're definitely right about drainage being crucial, but honestly, if your yard is consistently soggy, creeping thyme might not be the best choice. I've seen a few projects where people tried to compensate by mixing gravel or sand underneath, and it didn't always pan out well. Gravel can help somewhat, but sand can actually compact over time and make drainage worse, especially if your soil is heavy clay.

If you're set on creeping thyme, you might want to consider raising the planting area slightly - maybe a gentle berm or raised bed - to ensure water doesn't pool around the roots. I've had better luck with that approach than trying to amend the soil underneath extensively. Alternatively, have you thought about plants that naturally thrive in wetter conditions? Something like Irish moss or even certain sedges could give you a similar low-growing look without the headache of constantly fighting drainage issues.

Just my two cents from past experience... drainage fixes can get complicated fast, and sometimes it's easier to pick plants suited to your existing conditions rather than trying to force the conditions to fit the plant.


Reply

"Gravel can help somewhat, but sand can actually compact over time and make drainage worse, especially if your soil is heavy clay."

Yeah, learned that one the hard way myself. Thought adding sand would loosen things up, but it just turned into a muddy mess after a season or two. Ended up building a slight slope with some amended topsoil instead, and it made a huge difference. Curious though - anyone tried French drains for smaller garden areas? Seems like it could work, but maybe it's overkill...


Reply

French drains can definitely work in smaller areas, but honestly, it depends a lot on your particular setup. I put one in last year around the back corner of my garage because water kept pooling there after heavy rains. It wasn't a huge space, maybe 10 feet or so, and I just ran the drain out to a lower spot at the edge of the yard. Took a weekend to dig and set up, but it was pretty straightforward.

I wouldn't call it overkill exactly, but it's not always necessary either. If your slope and amended soil are already handling things well, you might not see much benefit. On the other hand, if you've still got persistent soggy spots even after grading, a French drain can be a lifesaver. Just make sure you've got somewhere suitable to direct the water - otherwise you're just moving the problem around...


Reply

Good points about the slope and drainage - it really does depend. I wonder though, did you notice any issues with erosion or shifting after installation? I’ve seen a few setups where french drains solved one problem but created another. Either way, sounds like you got yours dialed in pretty well...definitely worth the weekend if it keeps your garage dry long-term.


Reply
Scroll to Top