Custom homes discussions and local services.

Digging up the backyard: found more than just dirt

750 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

Honestly, I’ve had the same struggle with cardboard - sometimes it feels like it’s still hanging around long after everything else has broken down. One trick I picked up: if you run a box cutter over the surface and score it up a bit before laying it down, it seems to break apart faster. Not sure if that’s just in my head or if the worms appreciate the extra effort.

I do agree about the tape and labels being a pain. I’ve started peeling off as much as I can, but there’s always that one stubborn strip that refuses to budge. As for the glue smell, yeah, some boxes are way worse than others. I once used a batch from an electronics store and my whole compost pile smelled like a weird mix of glue and plastic for weeks... lesson learned.

Mixing in grass clippings or even a little kitchen scrap (nothing too wild - no meat or dairy) helps speed things up too. And honestly, if you’re patient, even the stubborn stuff eventually disappears. Nature’s slow but thorough - kind of like me on a Sunday morning.


Reply

Honestly, I’d skip cardboard altogether if you’re after efficiency. Here’s why:

- Even “clean” boxes can have hidden coatings or glues that mess with compost.
-

“my whole compost pile smelled like a weird mix of glue and plastic for weeks...”
That right there is why I just use shredded paper or wood mulch - breaks down faster, no weird smells.
- Grass clippings and kitchen scraps do the job on their own, no stubborn tape to deal with.

I get the appeal of recycling, but sometimes it’s just not worth the hassle.


Reply

Honestly, I’m with you on skipping cardboard - too many unknowns. If you want a luxe, low-maintenance compost, here’s my go-to: layer wood mulch (bonus if it’s cedar for the scent), then toss in kitchen scraps and a sprinkle of shredded paper. No gluey mess, and it looks tidy while breaking down. I tried cardboard once... ended up picking out bits for months. Not worth the hassle when there are cleaner options.


Reply

I tried cardboard once... ended up picking out bits for months.

Yeah, I’ve had the same thing happen - those little waxy stickers or tape bits just never seem to disappear. I do like the cedar mulch idea, though. Ever notice if the shredded paper attracts critters? I’ve always worried about mice or bugs getting into my pile when I use anything papery. Wondering if I’m just being paranoid or if that’s actually a thing.


Reply

Honestly, I’ve never had an issue with critters going after shredded paper in my piles, but I’m careful about what kind of paper goes in - no glossy stuff or anything with food residue. I do think mice are more interested in food scraps than plain paper, but maybe it depends on the neighborhood. Cedar mulch is great for keeping pests down, though. Ever tried mixing wood chips and paper, or do you keep them separate? That combo seems to break down better in my experience, but maybe that’s just me.


Reply

Mixing wood chips and shredded paper has worked pretty well for me, too. Here’s what I’ve noticed:

- The combo seems to balance out moisture. Paper alone gets soggy fast, but wood chips help keep things aerated.
- Breakdown is definitely faster with both, especially if you toss in a handful of finished compost to kickstart the microbes.
- I’ve never had mice go after plain paper either, but I did have a raccoon dig through a pile once when I accidentally tossed in a greasy pizza box. Lesson learned - no food residue, ever.

Cedar mulch is solid for pest control, but I’ve found it slows decomposition if you use too much. I usually stick to hardwood chips for the bulk and just sprinkle cedar around the edges where critters might sneak in. Not sure if that’s overkill, but it seems to help.

Curious - do you ever get weird smells when you mix paper and chips? I had one batch go a bit sour, probably too wet, but I’m not totally sure. Maybe it’s just the ratio or the weather. Also, what’s your take on using cardboard in the mix? I’ve heard mixed things about how fast it breaks down, especially the thicker stuff.


Reply

Curious - do you ever get weird smells when you mix paper and chips? I had one batch go a bit sour, probably too wet, but I’m not totally sure. Maybe it’s just the ratio or the weather.

I’ve definitely noticed that “sour” smell when things get too damp, especially in spring when rain sneaks in under the tarp. I wonder if layering more chips on top would help wick off some of that moisture, or if it just traps it in? About cardboard - does anyone else find that the glossy stuff never really breaks down? I try to stick to plain brown, but sometimes even that takes ages. Maybe it’s a temperature thing or just the thickness?


Reply

I’ve had that exact issue with the glossy cardboard - just sits there, looking the same months later. The plain brown stuff does break down, but it’s slow if the pile’s not heating up enough. I’ve tried ripping it up into smaller pieces, which helps a bit, but honestly, some of those thicker boxes are stubborn. As for the chips, I’ve found that mixing them in really well (not just layering) helps avoid that soggy, sour thing. If it smells off, I’ll toss in a bit of old straw or even some dry leaves to balance it out. Weather definitely plays a part... spring is always trickier.


Reply

DIGGING UP THE BACKYARD: FOUND MORE THAN JUST DIRT

That glossy cardboard is a pain, right? I’ve run into the same thing - found a chunk of cereal box in my compost after a whole year, barely changed. I’ve started avoiding anything with that shiny coating, even if it’s technically “recyclable.” For the brown stuff, I’ve had better luck when I run it through a paper shredder first. It’s tedious, but the smaller pieces seem to disappear way faster, especially if I layer them with kitchen scraps and turn the pile every week or so.

On the wood chips - totally agree, mixing is key. I made the mistake of dumping a thick layer on top once and ended up with this weird, compacted mat that just held water. Not great. Now I try to alternate chips with green stuff and fluff it up with a pitchfork. If things get too wet or smelly, I’ll even toss in some sawdust from untreated wood. Spring’s always unpredictable here too... sometimes the pile just sits there until we get a good warm spell.


Reply

DIGGING UP THE BACKYARD: FOUND MORE THAN JUST DIRT

I hear you on the glossy cardboard - tried composting some old packaging last year and it just sat there, looking exactly the same months later. Not worth the hassle, honestly. But about shredding the brown stuff: do you think it’s really necessary to invest in a shredder? I’ve just been tearing things up by hand, but it takes forever and I’m not sure it makes a huge difference. Is there a budget-friendly way to speed things up without buying more gear?

Also, with wood chips, I’ve been tempted to grab the free stuff from the city mulch pile, but I worry about what’s actually in it. Anyone had issues with weird chemicals or pests from that? I’m trying to keep costs down but don’t want to mess up my compost or garden.


Reply

DIGGING UP THE BACKYARD: FOUND MORE THAN JUST DIRT

Honestly, I wouldn’t bother with a shredder unless you’re dealing with mountains of cardboard. Tearing by hand is slow but it works - sometimes I just stomp on boxes or use garden shears if I’m feeling fancy. As for city mulch, I’ve used it a few times and never had issues, but I do let it sit for a season before putting it near veggies. You never really know what’s in there... but free is hard to beat.


Reply

DIGGING UP THE BACKYARD: FOUND MORE THAN JUST DIRT

I get the appeal of free mulch, but honestly, I’ve seen some questionable stuff in city loads - bits of plastic, random debris, even a rusty nail once. Maybe I’m just paranoid, but do you ever worry about contaminants leaching into your soil?


Reply

DIGGING UP THE BACKYARD: FOUND MORE THAN JUST DIRT

I get the appeal of free mulch, but honestly, I’ve seen some questionable stuff in city loads - bits of plastic, random debris, even a rusty nail once. Maybe I’m just paranoid, but do you ever worry about contaminants leaching into your soil?

You’re not being paranoid at all. I’ve had similar concerns with city mulch - and honestly, it’s smart to question what’s going into your soil. Here’s how I usually tackle it:

Step 1: Sift through the load. I know it sounds tedious, but spreading out the mulch and picking out obvious junk (glass, nails, plastic bits) makes a huge difference. You’ll never get every last speck, but it helps.

Step 2: Research where the mulch comes from. Sometimes cities will tell you if they’re using only yard waste or if it’s mixed with construction debris. If you can’t get a straight answer, that’s a red flag for me.

Step 3: Test the soil before and after. Home test kits are cheap and give you a baseline for heavy metals or other nasties. If something spikes after mulching, at least you know.

Step 4: Use “questionable” mulch for non-edibles only. Around trees or shrubs? Sure. Veggie beds? I’m way more picky.

I’ve found all sorts of weird stuff - once pulled out half a dog toy and a handful of roofing nails from one batch. Doesn’t mean city mulch is always bad, just that you gotta be vigilant.

Honestly, there’s no such thing as being too cautious when it comes to your soil health. But don’t let it scare you off entirely - just take a few extra steps and you’ll be fine. Sometimes free isn’t quite as free as it looks... but with a little effort, it can still be worth it.


Reply

DIGGING UP THE BACKYARD: FOUND MORE THAN JUST DIRT

I totally get the budget appeal - free mulch is hard to pass up when you’re trying to save a few bucks. Here’s my quick-and-dirty method: dump it out on a tarp, grab a rake, and just go to town picking out the weird stuff. I’ve found everything from bottle caps to what looked like a chewed-up flip-flop (no joke). If it’s sketchy, I just use it around the fence line or under trees. Veggie beds get the good stuff only. It’s not perfect, but hey, my wallet thanks me every time.


Reply

If it’s sketchy, I just use it around the fence line or under trees. Veggie beds get the good stuff only.

That’s exactly my approach too, but I gotta admit, sometimes I get a little paranoid about what’s actually in that free mulch. Last time I spread some, I pulled out what looked like part of a toy dinosaur (my kid was thrilled). I do wish the city would sift it a bit better, but hey, when you’re building a house and pinching pennies, priorities shift fast. The fence line is basically the mulch graveyard now.


Reply

Title: Digging up the backyard: found more than just dirt

I totally get the paranoia. I’ve been on a few build sites where we used city mulch, and you’d be surprised what turns up - bits of plastic, broken glass, random metal scraps. Once found half a brick in a load that was supposed to be “clean.” Makes you wonder about the source and what’s breaking down in there over time. I’m all for saving money, but sometimes I question if it’s worth risking weird stuff leaching into the soil, especially near anything edible.

That said, I’ve also seen some great results using the “sketchy” mulch just for weed suppression along property lines or under hedges. Maybe it’s just about managing expectations? If you’re not expecting perfection, you won’t be as frustrated when you dig up a mystery object. Still, I wish cities would invest a bit more in screening. It’d save a lot of headaches... and maybe fewer toy dinosaurs popping up in the yard.


Reply

Makes you wonder about the source and what’s breaking down in there over time.

This hits home. I was overseeing a small backyard studio build last year, and we brought in what was labeled as “premium” city compost. Ended up pulling out a handful of rusty screws and a chunk of what looked like an old phone case. Not exactly what you want near raised beds.

I get the appeal for weed suppression - honestly, for non-edible zones, it’s probably fine. But I’m with you on the screening. It’s not just about aesthetics; it’s about long-term soil health. Sometimes I wonder if the cost savings are worth the potential hassle down the line. Maybe it’s just a trade-off: save now, but be ready to dig up some surprises later.

Funny thing is, I’ve found fewer oddities in older, established beds than in new ones with fresh city mulch. Maybe stuff works its way out over time, or maybe I’ve just gotten used to ignoring the occasional Lego head...


Reply

Title: Digging Up The Backyard: Found More Than Just Dirt

Yeah, I’ve had similar surprises - once found a melted action figure arm in what was supposed to be “organic” mulch. It’s wild what slips through. I totally agree, screening is worth it, especially if you care about what’s going into the soil. Sometimes I wonder if the city compost folks just have different standards for “premium.” Still, I get tempted by the price every spring...


Reply

Had to laugh at the action figure arm - last year I dug up what looked like half a Hot Wheels car in my “premium” topsoil. Guess that’s what you get for trusting the bargain bins. I’ve started running everything through a homemade screen, but it’s a pain when you’re doing a big area. Still, better than pulling out weird plastic bits every time you plant something. Sometimes I think the city compost is just whatever they sweep off the street... but hey, can’t beat the price.


Reply

I hear you on the random junk in “premium” soil. I once found a rusty bolt and what looked like a piece of an old phone case. Ended up building a two-layer screen - hardware cloth over a finer mesh. It’s tedious, but honestly, worth it if you want to avoid surprises later. City compost is hit or miss... I’ve had batches that smelled like fresh earth, and others that were basically mulch with bonus plastic.


Reply
Scroll to Top