Custom homes discussions and local services.

Digging up the backyard: found more than just dirt

750 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

“Sometimes I wonder if just re-leveling every year is less hassle than dropping a ton of cash up front...”

- Totally get where you’re coming from.
- I’ve done the “thin base + tamp” route too - saves a lot up front, and honestly, a little shifting isn’t the end of the world.
- Geogrid’s nice in theory, but yeah, that price tag is rough.
- For me, spending a couple hours each spring re-leveling beats shelling out hundreds all at once.
- If it’s holding up “okay,” you’re probably doing just fine.


Reply

Digging Up The Backyard: Found More Than Just Dirt

I hear you on the yearly re-leveling. Honestly, I’ve seen plenty of patios and walkways that get a little wavy after winter, even with a “proper” base. Sometimes I think the soil just does what it wants, no matter how much geogrid or gravel you throw at it. I did a project last year where we went all-in on the base, and it still shifted a bit - nothing major, but enough to make me question if the extra cost was worth it. If you don’t mind a bit of maintenance, saving the cash upfront isn’t a bad tradeoff.


Reply

Sometimes I think the soil just does what it wants, no matter how much geogrid or gravel you throw at it.

- Definitely agree - nature has its own plans.
- I’ve done the “extra deep base” thing too, and honestly, the difference wasn’t huge for me either.
- If you’re handy and don’t mind re-leveling every year or two, skipping the premium materials seems reasonable.
- For me, the cost savings outweighed the hassle. Just budget a little time each spring to fix any dips or shifts.
- Only exception: if you’re putting in something like a hot tub or heavy structure. Then I’d probably splurge on the base. Otherwise, maintenance isn’t that bad.


Reply

For me, the cost savings outweighed the hassle. Just budget a little time each spring to fix any dips or shifts.

That’s been my approach too. I tried the “premium” route once - spent way more than I wanted, and honestly, the patio still settled a bit after winter. Now I just accept a little annual maintenance and keep the extra cash for other projects. Unless you’re building something super heavy, it’s just not worth overengineering every square foot.


Reply

Honestly, I get the appeal of saving cash and just patching things up each year. But I’ve seen a few patios where “just a little settling” turned into trip hazards or drainage issues after a couple seasons. Not saying you need to go overboard, but sometimes a bit more prep - like compacting the base properly - pays off long-term. Guess it depends how much hassle you’re willing to deal with down the road...


Reply

“just a little settling” turned into trip hazards or drainage issues after a couple seasons

- I get what you mean about the long-term hassle, but sometimes patching is all you need - especially if you’re not planning to stay in the house forever.
- Spent a weekend patching my old brick walkway every spring for years. Never had a big issue, and honestly, it gave me an excuse to get outside and mess around.
- Not everyone wants to tear up the whole backyard for a patio that’ll outlast them. Sometimes “good enough” really is good enough, at least for now.


Reply

Not everyone wants to tear up the whole backyard for a patio that’ll outlast them. Sometimes “good enough” really is good enough, at least for now.

That’s fair - sometimes you just want it to look decent and not trip over loose bricks every time you grab the mail. I’ve found that if you tamp down the base and use polymeric sand when patching, it holds up a lot better, even if it’s not a permanent fix. Curious - has anyone tried using gravel under bricks instead of sand? I’ve heard mixed things about drainage but never tried it myself.


Reply

Title: Digging Up The Backyard: Found More Than Just Dirt

I get the appeal of “good enough,” but I’ve seen too many quick fixes turn into bigger headaches down the line. Gravel under bricks can work, but it really depends on the type - pea gravel shifts a lot, which means your bricks might start wobbling after a season or two. Crushed stone is better since it locks together, but you still want a layer of sand on top for leveling. I once tried skipping the sand layer to save time... ended up redoing half the walkway after the first big rain. Sometimes those extra steps are worth it, even if you’re not aiming for a forever patio.


Reply

Crushed stone is better since it locks together, but you still want a layer of sand on top for leveling.

Couldn’t agree more about the crushed stone. Pea gravel’s a nightmare for anything load-bearing. Here’s what I usually do: dig down at least 6 inches, lay 4 inches of compacted crushed stone, then an inch or so of coarse sand. Set your bricks, tamp them down, and sweep more sand into the joints. Skipping steps just means you’ll be fixing it later - learned that the hard way after a shortcut patio turned into a rollercoaster after one winter.


Reply

Crushed stone really does make all the difference - pea gravel just moves around too much, especially if you’re dealing with freeze-thaw cycles. I usually go a little deeper, closer to 8 inches, especially if I’m worried about drainage or heavier loads. The point about compacting is huge. I’ve seen folks just dump the stone in and skip the plate compactor, figuring it’ll settle on its own, but that’s asking for trouble. One winter and you’ll have bricks popping up like whack-a-mole.

That said, I’ve run into situations where the soil underneath was way softer than expected - almost like clay soup down there. In those cases, even with a textbook base, things can shift. Sometimes geotextile fabric helps, sometimes you’ve got to dig out even more and backfill with extra stone. Not the most fun job, but better than tearing things up later.

Curious if anyone here has run into weird stuff buried in their yard during these projects? Last summer I found a bunch of old bricks and what looked like a chunk of concrete foundation about a foot down. Had to haul all that out before I could even start the base. Makes you wonder what else is lurking under there... Anyone else ever find something strange when digging out for a patio or walkway?


Reply

DIGGING UP THE BACKYARD: FOUND MORE THAN JUST DIRT

You’re spot on about compacting - skipping that step is just asking for uneven surfaces down the line. I’ve seen people try to “save time” and it always comes back to haunt them, especially with our freeze-thaw cycles.

Running into buried debris is more common than most folks expect. I had a client’s patio project stall for days because we uncovered what turned out to be an old septic tank lid about 18 inches down. Not exactly a fun surprise, but better to find it before laying anything permanent. It’s frustrating in the moment, but clearing out those old bricks and concrete chunks really does pay off in the long run. You’re creating a much more stable foundation, which is key if you want things to last.

Honestly, it’s impressive you took the time to do it right, even with all the extra work. Sometimes those little setbacks are what make the finished space feel even more satisfying.


Reply

You nailed it about the freeze-thaw cycles - those can really mess with anything that isn’t properly compacted. I’ve seen patios shift a good inch or two over a winter just because someone rushed the prep. Digging up old junk is a pain, but honestly, it’s way better than dealing with a cracked slab or sinking pavers later. Sometimes I wonder what people were thinking when they buried half a demolished garage in their yard... but at least it keeps things interesting.


Reply

You’re right, dealing with old buried debris is a pain, but it’s so much better to do the hard work up front. Have you ever noticed how some folks just throw down pavers over whatever’s there and hope for the best? I always wonder if they think the ground won’t move... but nature always wins. You’ll thank yourself later for putting in the effort now.


Reply

Digging up the backyard: found more than just dirt

I totally get where you’re coming from about doing the hard work now instead of dealing with a mess later. I’ll admit, I’ve been tempted to just slap some pavers down and call it a day - especially when my budget’s already stretched thin. But yeah, every time I’ve tried to cut corners like that, it’s come back to bite me. Wobbly patio, weeds poking through, random mystery lumps underfoot... not worth it.

Here’s what’s worked for me (and my wallet):
1. Grab a shovel and do a quick scan for anything weird under the surface - old bricks, chunks of concrete, random pipes (found a rusty bike frame once, no joke).
2. If you hit something big, try to dig it out or at least break it up so it won’t shift around later. Sometimes I just use a cheap pry bar or even an old crowbar if I’m feeling stubborn.
3. Once the debris is out, tamp down the soil as best you can. I’ve used everything from an actual tamper to a big piece of wood and some jumping up and down (not pretty but hey, it works).
4. Lay down some landscape fabric if you can swing it - it’s not expensive and saves a ton of hassle with weeds later on.

Honestly, I think people underestimate how much the ground moves over time. My neighbor did the “quick and dirty” method last year and now his pavers look like a rollercoaster track. He keeps blaming moles but... we all know what really happened.

It’s definitely more work up front but if you’re on a budget like me, fixing things later is usually way pricier than just doing it right once. Plus, there’s something kind of satisfying about knowing what’s under your feet isn’t going to surprise you next spring.

Anyway, just my two cents from someone who’s learned the hard way (more than once).


Reply

He keeps blaming moles but... we all know what really happened.

That made me laugh - always easier to blame the wildlife than admit to skipping a step. I’ve definitely been there with the “mystery lumps” underfoot. Once found half a cinder block about six inches down, right where I wanted to put a garden bed. Took way longer to dig out than I expected, but I was glad I did when I saw how much it would’ve messed up the drainage.

I’m curious - did you ever run into any old pipes or wires you had to work around? I hit an old metal pipe once and had no clue if it was still in use. Ended up calling the city just in case. Kind of a pain, but better than accidentally cutting something important. Wondering if anyone else has had to deal with that kind of surprise.


Reply

I hit an old metal pipe once and had no clue if it was still in use. Ended up calling the city just in case.

That’s smart - better safe than sorry. I once found what looked like a buried cable right where I planned to put a patio. Had to pause everything while I figured out if it was live or not (turned out to be ancient and dead, but still). Made me rethink my “just dig” approach... Now I always map things out first, even if it feels like overkill.


Reply

Honestly, I don’t get why people still “just dig” without checking first. One wrong move and you’re either flooding your yard or knocking out the neighbor’s internet. I always say - spend an hour planning, save yourself a week of headaches.


Reply

I used to think calling 811 was overkill for small stuff, but after hitting an old irrigation line (and getting a mud geyser in the face), I’m on board with the planning crowd. It’s wild how many cables and pipes are just under the surface. Even if you’re trying to save money, fixing a broken water line costs way more than a quick check. Learned that the hard way...


Reply

- Totally get it. I used to think 811 was just for big projects, but after slicing through a cable once, I’m not taking chances.
-

“fixing a broken water line costs way more than a quick check”
- couldn’t agree more. The repair bill stings way worse than waiting a day or two.
- Even if you’re just planting shrubs, there’s always something lurking under there. Not worth the risk, especially if you’re on a tight budget.
- Only takes one surprise to realize how much hassle you’re saving by planning ahead... learned that the hard way too.


Reply

I used to think calling 811 was overkill for small stuff, but after moving in and seeing how random the utility lines are, I’m not risking it. Found an old pipe just a few inches down - definitely not where I expected. Better safe than sorry, honestly.


Reply
Scroll to Top