Custom homes discussions and local services.

Digging up the backyard: found more than just dirt

750 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

DIGGING UP THE BACKYARD: FOUND MORE THAN JUST DIRT

- I hear you about things looking messy, but honestly, I think a little imperfection adds character.
- With a tight budget, I’ve had to get creative - sometimes that means mismatched pavers or odd bits of stone.
- Trick is, I lay stuff out first and play with patterns until it looks intentional, not accidental.
- Maintenance is real, though. If it’s gonna fall apart after one season, I’m out.
- For me, the charm outweighs the risk... most of the time.


Reply

DIGGING UP THE BACKYARD: FOUND MORE THAN JUST DIRT

With a tight budget, I’ve had to get creative - sometimes that means mismatched pavers or odd bits of stone.

That’s honestly the best way to approach it. I’ve seen plenty of high-end projects where everything matches perfectly, but they end up looking a bit sterile. There’s something about using what you have on hand - old bricks, leftover flagstone, even broken concrete - that gives a space a sense of history. It’s like the yard tells its own story.

I do agree with you on maintenance, though. There’s a fine line between “charmingly rustic” and “trip hazard.” I’ve learned the hard way that if you don’t set those stones right, you’ll be re-leveling them every spring. Sometimes I’ll use a bit of sand or gravel underneath to help keep things in place, especially if the ground shifts a lot over winter.

One thing I’ve noticed is that when you lay things out first, like you mentioned, it really does make a difference. I’ll sometimes sketch out a rough plan or just move pieces around until it feels right. It’s almost like putting together a puzzle, except there’s no wrong answer.

I get the appeal of perfection, but honestly, most people don’t notice the little imperfections unless you point them out. And if they do, it usually just sparks a conversation about how you put it all together. That’s half the fun, isn’t it?

Anyway, sounds like you’re making the most of what you’ve got. That’s what makes a backyard feel lived-in and personal, not just another cookie-cutter space.


Reply

DIGGING UP THE BACKYARD: FOUND MORE THAN JUST DIRT

I get the charm of mixing materials, but I’ll admit I lean toward a more uniform look, especially if you’re thinking about long-term value. In my experience, buyers tend to notice when things feel a bit too “DIY,” and it can actually make a space seem unfinished rather than intentional. There’s definitely a balance - unique is great, but sometimes too much variety can end up looking cluttered instead of characterful. Guess it depends on whether you’re fixing up for yourself or thinking resale down the line.


Reply

Honestly, I kinda like when there’s a bit of a mix. I’ve used reclaimed brick and gravel together and it turned out looking intentional, not messy. Sometimes that “DIY” vibe actually gives a place some soul, you know? Uniform is safe, but it’s not always interesting.


Reply

Mixing materials can totally work - sometimes it’s those little imperfections or contrasts that make a space memorable. I’m always curious, though: do you ever worry about it looking too “thrown together”? I’ve seen some projects where the blend feels effortless, and others where it just looks like leftovers... Maybe it’s about balance? I love using old pavers with new gravel, but I’ll usually repeat a color or texture somewhere else to tie things together. Ever tried adding plants in between the bricks? That can soften the whole look.


Reply

Digging Up The Backyard: Found More Than Just Dirt

Totally get what you mean about things looking “thrown together.” I used to worry about that a lot, especially since I’m mostly working with whatever materials I can get cheap or free. Sometimes it feels like my backyard’s a patchwork quilt of random finds. But honestly, I’ve noticed that if I repeat even one element - like the same type of stone in two spots, or similar colored mulch - it just sort of pulls everything together. Doesn’t have to be perfect.

I did try the plant-between-bricks idea last summer, using creeping thyme. It took a while to fill in, but now it’s my favorite part of the path. Plus, it hides some of the cracks and unevenness from my very DIY brickwork. I actually think the little bits of green make the mix of old and new materials look more intentional.

Here’s something I keep wondering: when you’re on a tight budget, do you ever feel stuck with the “leftover” look? Like, sometimes I see these magazine-worthy gardens and think, yeah, if I could buy all matching stuff, maybe mine would look less random. But then again, there’s something kind of cool about making it work with what you’ve got. Maybe it’s just about owning those imperfections?

Curious if anyone’s found a cheap trick for making different materials blend better - besides plants. I’ve tried painting old concrete pavers to match newer ones, but it didn’t really hold up through the winter. Any other hacks?


Reply

Digging Up The Backyard: Found More Than Just Dirt

Matching everything is overrated, honestly. In my experience, the “leftover” look can actually add character if you’re strategic about it. One trick I’ve used is gravel or decomposed granite as a unifying layer - just a thin border or path can tie mismatched materials together and it’s pretty cheap. Also, edging with salvaged bricks or even timber offcuts helps define spaces and makes the mix look more deliberate. Paint rarely lasts outdoors unless you use a concrete stain or sealer, but even then, weather takes its toll. Sometimes it’s just about embracing the patchwork and making sure there’s some kind of rhythm to it.


Reply

Totally get where you’re coming from - sometimes that “collected over time” vibe just feels more inviting than a showroom-perfect yard. I’ve mixed old flagstones with random pavers before and honestly, it looked way better once some moss crept in. The only thing I’d add is maybe throw in a couple of big planters or a statement sculpture if you want to distract from the patchwork. Makes it feel intentional, even if it’s a bit wild.


Reply

I hear you on the “collected over time” look - honestly, it’s way less stressful than trying to match everything perfectly. When I redid my patio, I ended up using leftover bricks and some random stones I found buried in the yard (seriously, who buries bricks?). It’s not exactly Pinterest-worthy, but once the weeds started popping through, it looked kinda cool. I’m not big on sculptures, but I did grab a couple of cheap planters from the hardware store and that helped tie things together without spending much. Sometimes a little chaos just works.


Reply

Sometimes a little chaos just works.

Totally get what you mean. I’ve tried the “everything matches” route before and honestly, it just ends up feeling stiff (plus, my wallet was not happy). There’s something about using what you’ve got lying around that makes the space feel more lived-in, you know? I did a similar thing with some old pavers and random rocks - didn’t even bother lining them up perfectly. Once the grass started growing in between, it actually looked intentional.

I’m with you on the planters too. I picked up a couple of those cheap plastic ones and spray painted them different colors. Not fancy, but it pulls things together without looking like I spent a fortune. Sometimes I think the “Pinterest-perfect” look is overrated anyway... a little mess gives it personality.


Reply

That’s a good point about the “lived-in” look - sometimes those mismatched elements end up being the most functional too. I do wonder, though, how well those painted plastic planters hold up outside over time? I tried repurposing some old containers once and the paint started peeling after a season. Have you found any tricks for making them last longer, or is it just a redo every year kind of thing? Sometimes I think about investing in recycled materials instead, but not sure if it’s worth the extra upfront cost.


Reply

Honestly, I’ve never had much luck getting paint to stick to plastic planters long-term either. Even with primer, the weather just beats them up. I finally caved and splurged on some planters made from recycled composite - pricey at first, but they look sharp and have survived three summers without any peeling or fading. If you’re after something that lasts and still feels eco-friendly, they’re worth a shot. The upfront cost stings a bit, but it beats repainting every spring... plus, less hassle means more time for actually enjoying the garden.


Reply

- Totally get what you’re saying about paint just not sticking - been there, tried every “plastic primer” on the shelf. The sun and rain just chew it up.
-

“If you’re after something that lasts and still feels eco-friendly, they’re worth a shot.”

- I’ve looked at those composite planters too. Did you notice if they hold up to freezing temps? My winters are rough, and I’ve had a few “weatherproof” containers crack anyway.
- One trick I tried: roughing up the plastic with sandpaper before priming. Helped a little, but still ended up with chips by midsummer.
- Honestly, I’m starting to think the extra cost for quality up front is just part of the game if you want the look to last. Otherwise it’s an endless cycle of patching and repainting.
- Anyone else ever try repurposed materials like old metal buckets or wood crates? They don’t last forever either, but at least they weather in a way that looks intentional... sometimes even adds character.
- At this point, I’m more interested in what’ll survive my climate than saving a few bucks short term.


Reply

Digging Up The Backyard: Found More Than Just Dirt

You’re not alone on the endless paint struggle - plastic just doesn’t want to cooperate, no matter how much prep you do. I’ve had better luck with old galvanized tubs for planters. They get a bit rusty, but honestly, that kind of patina looks cool over time. Composite stuff is hit or miss in my winters too; had one crack last January after a cold snap. Sometimes paying more upfront is worth it, but I still can’t resist trying to DIY with whatever’s lying around... keeps things interesting, at least.


Reply

Composite stuff is hit or miss in my winters too; had one crack last January after a cold snap.

That’s been my experience as well - composite can be unpredictable once the temps really drop. I tried sealing the inside of a composite barrel with a low-VOC waterproofing agent, thinking it’d help buffer against freeze-thaw cycles. It held up for a couple years, but eventually the expansion got it. Galvanized is definitely more forgiving, and that weathered look just fits in with the rest of my backyard “collection.” Sometimes I wonder if the old-school materials just age better, quirks and all.


Reply

Funny, I had a similar thing happen with a composite planter - cracked right down the side after a brutal freeze. Tried patching it, but it never really looked right again. Galvanized tubs just seem to shrug off the cold. Anyone ever try terra cotta in these temps? I’ve always been wary.


Reply

Anyone ever try terra cotta in these temps? I’ve always been wary.

I hear you on the composite planters - once they crack, it’s tough to make them look decent again. I’ve had better luck with galvanized too, especially out here where winter swings are brutal.

About terra cotta, I’ll be honest - I stopped using them years ago after losing a whole row of rosemary to a cold snap. The pots looked great all summer, but once that first deep freeze hit, they split right down the middle. Even tried wrapping them up one year with burlap and bubble wrap... didn’t help much. Maybe if you’re in a spot with milder winters, you could get away with it, but around here, I’d say stick to metal or heavy-duty plastic if you want your planters to last more than a season or two.

Funny thing is, I dug up an old terra cotta shard just last week while trenching for drainage - guess some things never change.


Reply

I get where you’re coming from, but I’ve actually had some luck with terra cotta even in rough winters. Here’s what’s worked for me:

- Only use the thick-walled pots - thin ones crack way faster.
- Elevate them off the ground with pot feet or bricks to keep water from pooling underneath.
- Bring the empties into the garage once the plants die back.

Even tried wrapping them up one year with burlap and bubble wrap... didn’t help much.

Yeah, wrapping never did much for me either. But honestly, I’ve had more issues with plastic getting brittle and splitting after a couple seasons. Galvanized is solid, but I just like the look of terra cotta too much to give it up completely. Maybe I’m just stubborn.


Reply

Yeah, wrapping never did much for me either. But honestly, I’ve had more issues with plastic getting brittle and splitting after a couple seasons.

I hear you on the plastic pots - mine always seem to get brittle and crack right where the sun hits them most. I do like the look of terra cotta, but I’m always worried about the cost if I have to keep replacing them. Have you ever tried sealing the inside of your terra cotta pots? I read somewhere that it can help with moisture absorption and maybe even prevent some cracking, but I’m not sure if it’s worth the effort or just another gardening myth.


Reply

I tried sealing the inside of a couple terra cotta pots last year with that clear waterproofing stuff - honestly, didn’t notice much difference. They still got those hairline cracks over winter. Maybe it helps a bit with moisture, but I’m not convinced it’s worth the hassle.


Reply
Scroll to Top