"make sure whoever installs the spray foam knows what they're doing."
Couldn't agree more. When we replaced our old roof last summer, we had a similar experience. We went with spray foam around the chimney and vents, but used fiberglass batts elsewhere. Worked great overall, but I had to hover over the foam crew constantly—they nearly missed sealing around one vent completely. Definitely worth being extra cautious... it saved us from potential headaches later on.
Definitely worth being extra cautious... it saved us from potential headaches later on.
Good point about hovering over the crew—been there myself. When we built our place, I assumed the spray foam guys knew exactly what to do (rookie mistake). Later, we found a couple spots near the attic corners that were barely covered. Had to call them back out, which was a hassle. Definitely learned my lesson: trust but verify, especially when it comes to insulation...
"trust but verify, especially when it comes to insulation..."
Yeah, insulation mishaps can be sneaky. When we redid our roof, I hovered a bit too much probably, but caught them skipping the ice barrier in one spot. Curious—did you guys opt for metal or shingles?
Yeah, good catch on the ice barrier—it's easy to miss those details if you're not watching closely. I've seen my fair share of insulation and roofing shortcuts over the years, and you're right: trust but verify is spot-on advice.
As for metal vs shingles, both have their merits. Metal roofs can be pricey upfront but they're durable, energy-efficient, and pretty low-maintenance. Shingles, though, are usually easier on the budget and simpler to install. If you do go shingles, make sure they're installing a proper underlayment—I've seen contractors skimp here too, and it can lead to leaks down the line.
Either way, you're already ahead by paying attention to these details. It's always better to hover a bit and catch a potential issue early than to deal with leaks and repairs later...speaking from experience here.
"Either way, you're already ahead by paying attention to these details."
Couldn't agree more—catching those little shortcuts early saves a ton of headaches later. When we replaced ours, I went with shingles mainly for budget reasons, but I splurged a bit on upgraded underlayment and ventilation. Made a huge difference in attic temps and overall comfort. Curious if anyone else has experience with roof ventilation upgrades...worth the extra cost in your opinion?
