"synthetics can mimic slate or cedar beautifully at first, but I've noticed some brands lose their realistic texture over time."
Yeah, that's what worries me too. Anyone know if there's a noticeable difference in durability between synthetic slate vs synthetic cedar styles? Wondering if one's better long-term...
I've seen both synthetic slate and cedar roofs hold up pretty well, but from what I've noticed, synthetic slate tends to keep its look a bit longer. Cedar styles sometimes fade or lose texture quicker, especially in harsher climates. But honestly, it might depend more on the brand and installation quality than the style itself. Have you looked into how warranties differ between the two? That might give you a better idea of long-term durability...
Good point about warranties—I didn't even think to check that when I redid mine. Went with synthetic slate and it's held up great so far, even after some rough winters. Cedar looks amazing at first, but my neighbor's roof faded pretty quick... could just be bad luck though.
Synthetic slate's a solid choice, especially if you're dealing with harsh weather. I've installed it on a few projects, and clients have been pretty happy—holds up well against hail and wind, plus it's lighter than real slate, so less stress on your framing. Cedar definitely has that initial wow factor, but you're right about the fading. I've seen plenty of roofs go from vibrant to dull grayish-brown in just a couple seasons, even with proper sealing. Some folks love that weathered look, though... personal preference, I guess.
One thing I'd add about warranties: always check the fine print for transferability if you think you might sell down the line. Some manufacturers make it easy; others, not so much. Learned that one the hard way on a client's house—lesson stuck with me ever since.
"Synthetic slate's a solid choice, especially if you're dealing with harsh weather."
True, synthetic slate has perks, but have you considered metal roofing? Installed one about 8 years ago—no leaks yet, handles snow loads like a champ, and surprisingly quiet during rain. Might be worth checking out...
