Custom homes discussions and local services.

Need advice on replacing an old leaky roof

1,744 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF

I get the hesitation. Metal roofs are great for durability, but the insulation question is legit - I've seen some folks skimp on underlayment and regret it when summer hits. Personally, I’d push for a solid radiant barrier and beefed-up attic insulation. The right setup can actually keep things cooler than shingles, but if you cheap out, you’ll bake. Contractors love to gloss over that part because it’s not as flashy as the roof itself. Don’t let them talk you out of proper prep just to save a few bucks.


Reply

Contractors love to gloss over that part because it’s not as flashy as the roof itself. Don’t let them talk you out of proper prep just to save a few bucks.

That’s the truth right there. When we replaced our roof a couple years back, I almost got talked into skipping the radiant barrier - contractor said “it’s optional, you’ll be fine.” Glad I didn’t listen. Our attic used to turn into an oven by noon in July, but with the new metal roof and a proper radiant barrier, it’s noticeably cooler now.

One thing I’d add: pay attention to ventilation too. We upgraded our soffit vents and added a ridge vent at the same time. It made a bigger difference than I expected. Metal reflects a lot, but if the hot air can’t escape, you’re still stuck with heat buildup.

Also, don’t forget about noise. Some folks say metal roofs are loud in the rain, but with decent underlayment and insulation, it’s really not bad - just a gentle patter most days. If you get the prep right, metal can be a huge upgrade over shingles in every way that matters.


Reply

I’ve noticed the same thing with attic temps - before we built, I did a lot of research and almost skipped the radiant barrier too. It’s easy to underestimate how much that and proper ventilation matter until you live with it. We went with a standing seam metal roof, full ridge vent, and extra insulation. The difference in summer is huge, but I will say, the noise is still a bit more noticeable than shingles during heavy rain. Not bad, just different. If you’re sensitive to sound, it’s worth thinking about the underlayment options.


Reply

Metal roofs really do change the game for attic temps, but you’re right about the sound. I’ve had clients who loved the rain noise, others not so much. Underlayment makes a big difference - synthetic options can help dampen it, but nothing’s going to make it as quiet as asphalt shingles. Did you look into spray foam insulation at all? Sometimes that combo with metal can really cut down on both heat and noise, though it’s not cheap. Curious what made you pick standing seam over other metal profiles?


Reply

NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF

I get the appeal of spray foam, but honestly, I’ve seen it cause more headaches than it solves in some high-end builds. Tricky to install right, and if there’s ever a leak, finding it is a nightmare. I actually went with a double-batten system under my standing seam - bit more old-school, but it lets the roof breathe and keeps things cooler. Not as dead-quiet as shingles, but the thermal performance is worth it for me.


Reply

I actually went with a double-batten system under my standing seam - bit more old-school, but it lets the roof breathe and keeps things cooler.

Couldn’t agree more about the headaches with spray foam. I’ve seen projects where it traps moisture and you end up with rot before you even realize there’s an issue. The double-batten approach might not be flashy, but long-term durability beats chasing leaks inside a sealed-up roof any day. Ventilation is underrated, honestly.


Reply

Ventilation is underrated, honestly.

Totally get that - when we started our build, I had no idea how much stuff could go wrong just from poor airflow. We almost went with spray foam but backed out after hearing some horror stories. Curious if you noticed any noise differences with the double-batten setup? Our old roof was LOUD in storms, so I'm wondering if this helps at all.


Reply

Curious if you noticed any noise differences with the double-batten setup? Our old roof was LOUD in storms, so I'm wondering if this helps at all.

You’re not alone - noise was a big concern for us too. I kept reading about how some setups can actually make things worse, especially if you go cheap on materials or skip insulation. We were on a tight budget, so I had to weigh every option. Ended up going with a single-batten system and regular fiberglass insulation, mostly because the double-batten was just out of reach cost-wise. Honestly, it’s still a bit noisy in heavy rain, but definitely better than before. Not perfect, but I guess you get what you pay for.

I’ve heard from a couple neighbors who did double-batten plus mineral wool and they swear it’s quieter - like, noticeably less drumming during storms. But then again, their total bill was almost double ours. Makes me wonder if the extra cost is worth it just for the noise factor, especially if your main issue is leaks and not sound.

About spray foam - I get why you backed out. We almost went that route too until we saw some of those nightmare stories about trapped moisture and mold. Seemed like a gamble, especially since we’re not planning to gut the whole attic.

If you’re still deciding, maybe see if you can get a sample or demo of the noise difference? Some contractors will let you check out jobs they’ve done nearby. Either way, good on you for thinking about ventilation early - it’s one of those things that’s easy to overlook but makes a huge difference down the line.


Reply

Honestly, I think you’re making smart calls here. I’ve seen plenty of folks go all-in on the double-batten and mineral wool, and yeah, it’s quieter, but the price tag can be a shock. Sometimes the single-batten with decent insulation is a solid middle ground, especially if leaks are the bigger headache. Ventilation’s huge - can’t tell you how many times I’ve seen beautiful new roofs get wrecked by poor airflow. You’re definitely ahead of the game thinking about that now.


Reply

NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF

I get where you’re coming from with the double-batten and mineral wool setup - it’s like the Cadillac of roof insulation, but man, that price tag can sting. I’ve been down that road before, thinking “go big or go home,” and then my wallet started weeping quietly in the corner. Honestly, unless you’re living right under a flight path or your house is basically a drum for rain noise, single-batten with solid insulation usually does the trick.

Here’s how I’d break it down, step by step (and yeah, learned some of this the hard way):

1. **Figure out your real pain points.** If leaks are what’s keeping you up at night (or waking you up with that drip-drip), focus on getting a proper underlayment and flashing sorted first. No amount of fancy insulation will help if water’s sneaking in around the chimney or skylights.

2. **Don’t cheap out on ventilation.** I know it feels like an “extra,” but I’ve seen gorgeous roofs go moldy in a year because someone thought a couple of vents would do. Ridge vents plus soffit vents are usually a safe bet - keeps air moving so your insulation actually works and your rafters don’t rot.

3. **Insulation: balance is key.** Mineral wool is great for sound and fire resistance, but if you’re not dealing with crazy noise or code requirements, a good quality fiberglass or even rigid foam can be plenty - especially if you’re layering it right.

4. **Think about future headaches.** If you ever want to add solar panels or skylights later, make sure whatever system you pick won’t make that a nightmare down the line. Some of those double-batten setups are a pain to modify.

One thing I’ll mildly disagree on - I’ve found that sometimes people overdo the “quiet” factor and end up with a roof that doesn’t breathe at all. You want quiet, not hermetically sealed... unless you like mystery leaks and weird smells.

Anyway, sounds like you’re already ahead by thinking about airflow now instead of after the fact (been there... attic smelled like an old gym bag for months). Good luck - just remember: dry beats fancy every time when it comes to roofs.


Reply

“No amount of fancy insulation will help if water’s sneaking in around the chimney or skylights.”

That part really hits home. I’m in the middle of my first major roof project and honestly, leaks have been my biggest worry. I almost got sucked into the “more insulation is always better” mindset, but after talking to a few contractors, it sounds like getting the basics right - underlayment, flashing, and ventilation - matters way more than stacking up layers of expensive material.

I did a single-batten with rigid foam and fiberglass combo, mostly because mineral wool was out of my budget. Haven’t noticed any noise issues, but I’m not near an airport or anything. The one thing I wish I’d done differently: paid more attention to vent placement. My attic temp swings a lot more than I expected, so I might need to add another soffit vent.

Totally agree about planning ahead for solar or skylights. My neighbor had to rip up half his new roof just to add panels... not fun. Dry beats fancy for sure, but “future-proof” is a close second for me.


Reply

Getting the basics right really does make all the difference. I’ve seen folks spend a fortune on high-end insulation, only to end up with water stains because they skimped on flashing or didn’t seal around penetrations. Vent placement is one of those things that’s easy to overlook until you’re living with the consequences - been there myself. If you ever do add more soffit vents, just double-check your intake vs exhaust balance; too much of one can actually make things worse. Planning for future upgrades is smart, but I’d still put “dry” at the top of the list every time... nothing ruins a roof faster than moisture sneaking in where it shouldn’t.


Reply

Funny you mention vent placement - I once worked on a 1920s bungalow where someone had decided more was always better. They’d added so many roof vents over the years it looked like a submarine up there, but the attic was still musty and damp. Turned out, they’d totally ignored the intake side, so the exhaust vents were basically just letting conditioned air escape instead of pulling in fresh air from the soffits. It’s wild how easy it is to get that balance wrong.

I’ve also seen some folks get a little too focused on the latest “miracle” underlayments or high-end shingles, thinking they’ll solve every problem. But if you’ve got a single spot where flashing’s not tight, or a plumbing vent that’s not sealed right, all that fancy stuff doesn’t matter much. Water finds the tiniest gaps, and once it’s in, you’re chasing rot for years.

One thing I always wonder - why do so many contractors gloss over the details around chimneys and skylights? Maybe it’s just not as flashy as new shingles, but those spots are where I see the most leaks start. I’ve started asking roofers to walk me through exactly how they’re handling penetrations and transitions before I sign off on anything. Sometimes they look at me like I’m being fussy, but I’d rather be the picky one than end up with a soggy ceiling.

Curious if anyone’s had luck with those newer self-sealing flashing tapes? I keep hearing mixed reviews. Part of me still trusts old-fashioned metal flashing and a good bead of sealant, but maybe I’m just stuck in my ways.

Anyway, couldn’t agree more - keep it dry first, then worry about fancy upgrades. A dry roof is a happy roof, no matter how basic the materials.


Reply

NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF

You’re spot on about the details making or breaking a roof. I’ve seen way too many “premium” roofs fail because someone got lazy with the flashing or didn’t bother to check the venting math. It’s wild how often people overlook intake vents - like, you can have all the fancy ridge vents in the world, but if there’s nowhere for air to come in, it’s just wasted money and energy.

I get what you mean about self-sealing tapes. They sound great in theory, but I’ve seen them peel or lose adhesion after a couple of freeze-thaw cycles. Maybe they’re getting better, but I still lean toward good metal flashing and careful install. There’s something to be said for methods that have stood the test of time.

And yeah, asking roofers to walk you through their plan isn’t being fussy - it’s just smart. Too many folks get dazzled by shingle samples and forget that water doesn’t care how pretty your roof looks. If you’re not picky now, you’ll be paying for it later... usually with moldy insulation and a headache.

Keep pushing for those details. It really does make all the difference.


Reply

NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF

- Went through this last year - thought picking “the best” shingles was the big deal, but it was all the little stuff that mattered.
- My old roof had zero intake vents. House always felt stuffy, and the attic was a sauna. New roof, proper venting? Huge difference.
- Flashing is where my last contractor cut corners. Had leaks around the chimney within two years. This time, I asked to see every step and made them redo some spots. Worth it.
- Self-sealing tape... mixed feelings. Used it on a shed and it’s already curling up after one winter. Wouldn’t trust it for the main house.
- Don’t let anyone rush you through the details. It’s your money and your headaches if they mess up.


Reply

NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF

You nailed it about the venting - people always focus on the shingles, but if the attic can’t breathe, you’re just asking for problems. I had a similar situation: old house, zero intake vents, and summers upstairs felt like living in a toaster. Once I got proper airflow up there, it was a night and day difference. My AC actually keeps up for once.

Flashing is one of those things you don’t appreciate until it fails. I’ve seen a lot of “quick fixes” that just lead to headaches down the line. Watching them work and asking questions is smart, even if it feels awkward. You’re paying for peace of mind, not just materials.

Self-sealing tape is kind of hit or miss, yeah. I’ve seen it work in dry climates, but where I am (lots of freeze/thaw cycles), it just doesn’t last. For main roofs, especially if you’re thinking about long-term performance or resale, I’d stick with tried-and-true methods - ice and water shield plus proper underlayment.

It’s easy to get overwhelmed by all the little decisions, but you’re right: the details make all the difference. Taking your time and making sure it’s done right will pay off every season. And honestly, you’ll probably notice your energy bills drop too if the venting and insulation are handled properly.

Hang in there - roof projects are stressful, but sounds like you’re asking all the right questions and learning from past mistakes. That’s half the battle.


Reply

NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF

You’re spot on about the venting and insulation - those details make such a difference, not just for comfort but for the whole feel of the house. I’ve seen people pour money into new roofs and still end up with hot, stuffy rooms or weird drafts because they skipped over airflow. It’s easy to get caught up in shingle colors or brands, but honestly, the “boring” stuff like flashing and underlayment is what keeps you dry and your interiors looking good. You’re definitely on the right track by focusing on the fundamentals. It’s a lot to juggle, but you’re making smart choices.


Reply

NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF

Funny you mention airflow - I thought I could get away with just new shingles a few years ago, but I skipped checking the attic vents. Ended up with condensation issues and some weird musty smells. Ever notice how the little things like flashing or even drip edge get overlooked until there’s a problem? Did you have to deal with any tricky spots, like around chimneys or skylights? Those always seem to be where leaks sneak in for me.


Reply

NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF

- Flashing is the sneaky villain, seriously. I’ve seen so many “mystery leaks” that end up just being a tiny gap around a chimney or vent pipe.
- Skylights? Don’t get me started... they look great but are basically leak magnets if not flashed right.
- Drip edge is underrated - skipping it is like forgetting socks with your shoes. You can do it, but you’ll regret it.
- I always tell folks: check the attic insulation and airflow before you even touch shingles. Otherwise, you’re just putting a hat on a wet head.
- If you’re redoing the roof, might as well upgrade the ventilation too. It’s not glamorous, but your future self will thank you when there’s no weird attic funk.


Reply

NEED ADVICE ON REPLACING AN OLD LEAKY ROOF

- Couldn’t agree more about the flashing. Had a “mystery” leak last year that turned out to be a gap behind a satellite dish bracket - took forever to find.
- Skylights... yeah, they look fancy but unless you’re ready to baby them, they’re just asking for trouble.
- Drip edge is non-negotiable. I learned that the hard way on my first house - water damage on the fascia is not a good look.
- Ventilation upgrades are worth every penny. I’d say go with ridge vents if you can swing it - quiet, effective, and you’ll never think about them again.
- Don’t skimp on underlayment either. The fancy stuff isn’t just marketing; it really does help with those surprise storms.


Reply
Scroll to Top