I get what you're saying about hail and metal roofs—it's definitely something to consider. I've seen a few metal roofs after storms, and honestly, dents can happen, especially with larger hailstones. But usually they're just cosmetic, nothing structural. One thing to keep in mind is the gauge of the metal; thicker panels handle hail better. Asphalt shingles might be cheaper upfront, but replacing them every 15-20 years adds up... metal could actually save you headaches down the road.
"Asphalt shingles might be cheaper upfront, but replacing them every 15-20 years adds up... metal could actually save you headaches down the road."
That's exactly why I went with metal when we redid our roof a few years back. Honestly, I was skeptical at first—worried about noise during rainstorms and hail damage—but it's been surprisingly quiet and held up great. Sure, there are a couple minor dents from a nasty hailstorm last summer, but you'd have to really look to notice them. Plus, the peace of mind knowing I won't have to deal with another roof replacement anytime soon is priceless.
"Honestly, I was skeptical at first—worried about noise during rainstorms and hail damage—but it's been surprisingly quiet and held up great."
Glad to hear the noise isn't an issue... that's been my main hesitation. Did you go with any special insulation underneath, or is it just standard installation?
I had similar concerns initially, but from my experience, standard installation with a quality underlayment was sufficient. If you're particularly sensitive to noise or your home has vaulted ceilings, you might consider upgrading insulation for extra peace of mind. Personally, I didn't find it necessary—rain noise is minimal and actually quite relaxing. But if you're in an area prone to hail, investing in a slightly thicker underlayment could be worthwhile just for added protection.
"Personally, I didn't find it necessary—rain noise is minimal and actually quite relaxing."
Interesting perspective, but have you considered the long-term impact of noise on resale value? I agree rain can be soothing, but potential buyers might not share that sentiment, especially if they're sensitive sleepers or have young kids. Also, while thicker underlayment helps with hail, have you looked into metal roofing options? They offer superior durability against hail and wind, plus they can significantly boost your home's curb appeal and resale potential. I went with a standing seam metal roof myself, and while the initial cost was higher, the peace of mind knowing it can handle severe weather without damage has been worth every penny. Just something else to think about before you commit to traditional shingles...
