Chatbot Avatar

AI Chatbot

Ask me anything about our forum!

v1.0.0
Notifications
Clear all

Need advice on replacing an old leaky roof

1,072 Posts
944 Users
0 Reactions
16.1 K Views
diy639
Posts: 12
(@diy639)
Active Member
Joined:

Yeah, venting through soffits can work, but did you check if your soffit vents were clear and unobstructed? Sometimes insulation or debris can block airflow, causing moisture to linger. Glad you caught it early though—attic moisture issues can escalate quickly.


Reply
Posts: 16
(@jackl36)
Active Member
Joined:

Good point about the soffit vents, but honestly, if you're already dealing with moisture issues and leaks, I'd strongly suggest looking beyond just venting. Clearing soffits helps, sure, but it's usually a temporary fix if your roof is already compromised. I've seen homeowners spend months chasing ventilation problems only to realize their shingles were shot or flashing was improperly installed.

If your roof is older and leaking, it's probably time to bite the bullet and replace it entirely. Band-aid solutions like patching or adding extra vents rarely solve the underlying issue long-term. Plus, once moisture gets into your attic space, you're risking mold growth and structural damage—problems that can get expensive real fast. Trust me, I've had clients who waited too long and ended up paying double because they had to fix interior damage as well as replace the roof.

When you do replace the roof, make sure your contractor checks the decking underneath thoroughly. A lot of times, leaks mean you've got compromised plywood or OSB sheathing beneath those shingles. If you skip replacing damaged decking now, you'll regret it later when your brand-new shingles start buckling or sagging.

Also, consider upgrading your underlayment to a synthetic product instead of traditional felt paper. It's pricier upfront but provides better protection against moisture infiltration if shingles ever fail again down the road. And don't skimp on flashing around chimneys, skylights, valleys—those are prime leak spots.

Bottom line: clear soffits are great for airflow maintenance, but they're not gonna save a failing roof. Better to tackle this head-on now before things escalate further...


Reply
Posts: 10
(@hollygamerpro)
Active Member
Joined:

Good advice overall, but I'd add a couple quick points from experience:

- Definitely agree on synthetic underlayment—worth every penny. Traditional felt tears way too easily during install, especially if you're DIYing it.
- Don't underestimate drip edge installation. I've seen plenty of roofs leak prematurely because someone skipped or botched that step.
- And yeah, flashing is key. If you're not confident installing it yourself, hire someone who knows what they're doing... it'll save headaches later.


Reply
Posts: 14
(@michelle_thomas)
Active Member
Joined:

Great points, especially about the drip edge—it's one of those things people tend to overlook because it seems minor, but it makes a huge difference down the line. Ever notice how the smallest details end up causing the biggest headaches later?

I tackled my own roof replacement a couple years back, and honestly, the flashing was the part that had me second-guessing myself the most. Watched a ton of videos, read forums, and still felt unsure. Ended up calling in a buddy who'd done roofing professionally for a few years. Best decision ever. He showed me a few tricks that weren't obvious from the tutorials, like how to properly overlap the flashing around chimneys and vents. Saved me from a potential disaster, I'm sure.

Synthetic underlayment was a game changer too. I remember helping my dad reroof our old shed years ago with traditional felt, and it was a nightmare—tore constantly, especially if the wind picked up even slightly. Synthetic stuff was night-and-day easier to handle. Plus, it gave me peace of mind knowing it wouldn't rip apart if I stepped wrong or if the weather turned unexpectedly.

Have you thought about ventilation yet? That's another sneaky one. I didn't realize how important proper attic ventilation was until I started researching. Turns out, poor ventilation can shorten your roof's lifespan significantly. I ended up adding ridge vents and soffit vents, and it made a noticeable difference in attic temps during summer.

Anyway, sounds like you're on the right track. Roofing can feel intimidating at first, but once you get going, it's pretty rewarding to see it all come together. You've got this... just take your time and don't rush the details.


Reply
Posts: 8
(@zeushawk450)
Active Member
Joined:

Good call on the synthetic underlayment—I switched to that for my garage last summer and it was a breeze compared to the old felt. One thing I'd add about ventilation: ridge vents are great, but make sure your soffit vents aren't blocked by insulation. I didn't check mine initially and ended up having to crawl back in there later to clear it out...not fun. Definitely worth double-checking before you close things up.


Reply
Page 59 / 215
Share:
Scroll to Top