I've had mixed luck too—depends heavily on the wood type and finish. Last year, I scored some reclaimed oak cabinets and spent forever tweaking stains to match existing trim...looked decent, but still slightly off in certain lighting. Ever tried salvaging hardware instead? Seems easier to blend.
"Ever tried salvaging hardware instead? Seems easier to blend."
Hardware can indeed be less finicky—I've reused antique pulls and hinges before with decent results. But sometimes finding matching sets is more hassle than it's worth...still, worth considering if you're patient enough to hunt them down.
Totally agree on salvaging hardware—I've had some luck myself. A few quick thoughts:
- Check local flea markets or estate sales; sometimes you stumble onto matching sets without even trying.
- Mixing hardware styles can actually look intentional if you keep finishes consistent.
- Don't overlook online marketplaces; I've snagged some great deals from people clearing out renovation leftovers.
It does take patience, but the savings and unique look can be worth the extra effort.
"Mixing hardware styles can actually look intentional if you keep finishes consistent."
Totally agree with this point—matching finishes really ties the look together, even if the styles differ a bit. I'd also suggest checking out architectural salvage yards. They're goldmines for unique pieces at a fraction of retail prices. I've had projects where salvaged vintage hardware became conversation starters...clients loved the character it added. Sure, it takes extra legwork, but the payoff in both savings and style is usually worth it.
I've had mixed luck with salvage yards myself. Sure, you can find some real gems, but isn't it sometimes more hassle than it's worth? I once spent an entire weekend hunting down matching vintage handles only to realize later they needed custom screws. Ended up costing me extra time and money. Matching finishes does help blend styles, though—have to admit that's usually a safe bet. Guess it depends how much patience (and spare time) you've got...
