Had to laugh at the Alexa update thing—been there. When we moved in, I got a little too excited and tried to automate literally everything. My partner was not impressed when the bathroom lights decided to turn off mid-shower because of a motion sensor “timeout.” Ended up dialing it back and sticking with smart switches for the rooms we use most. I’m still tempted by Home Assistant, but honestly, I just don’t have the patience for constant tinkering right now. Keeping it simple has made life way less stressful.
“My partner was not impressed when the bathroom lights decided to turn off mid-shower because of a motion sensor ‘timeout.’”
That’s exactly why I’m wary of going all-in on automation. It’s easy to get caught up in the hype, but honestly, simple switches and timers usually do the trick—and they’re way less likely to annoy everyone in the house. I get the appeal of Home Assistant, but unless you’re ready to treat it like a hobby, keeping things basic is just more sustainable. Sometimes “smart” ends up being more hassle than it’s worth.
Honestly, I’ve seen more than a few “smart” bathrooms go sideways because of motion sensors with short timeouts. It’s funny until you’re the one standing in the dark, covered in shampoo. I do like automation for things like climate control or blinds, but for lights—especially in spaces like bathrooms—I usually recommend a hybrid setup. Manual override is your friend. Sometimes the old-school switch just works better, you know?
Honestly, I’ve seen more than a few “smart” bathrooms go sideways because of motion sensors with short timeouts. It’s funny until you’re the one standing in the dark, covered in shampoo.
Honestly, I get the “manual override is your friend” argument, but I’ve had the opposite issue—family members always leave lights on and our bill goes up. Motion sensors with longer timeouts have saved us a bit, even in the bathroom. Not perfect, but for me it’s worth the trade-off if it means not nagging people to flip switches all day. Maybe it depends on how forgetful your household is...
Motion sensors with longer timeouts have saved us a bit, even in the bathroom. Not perfect, but for me it’s worth the trade-off if it means not nagging people to flip switches all day.
That’s pretty much where I landed too. I used to think smart switches were overkill, but after seeing our electric bill creep up month after month (thanks to kids who apparently believe lights should be on 24/7), I caved. The motion sensors aren’t flawless—sometimes they turn off if you’re just sitting still, which is awkward mid-shave—but honestly, I’d rather deal with that than chase everyone around reminding them to hit the switch.
I did end up tweaking the timeout settings a bit higher, and that helped. If you’re on a budget, there are some decent options out there that don’t require a full smart home overhaul. It’s not perfect tech, but for me it’s better than playing “light police” every night...
