Custom homes discussions and local services.

Choosing between energy efficiency or water savings for green building points?

292 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

CHOOSING BETWEEN ENERGY EFFICIENCY OR WATER SAVINGS FOR GREEN BUILDING POINTS?

I totally get where you’re coming from - insulation is rarely glamorous, but it’s such a game changer. I’ve worked on a few remodels where clients wanted every new water-saving gadget, but half the time, they ended up collecting dust. Meanwhile, simple energy upgrades like better windows or sealing drafts made a noticeable difference in comfort and bills. Sometimes it’s not about the latest thing, just what actually works for the space and climate.


Reply

CHOOSING BETWEEN ENERGY EFFICIENCY OR WATER SAVINGS FOR GREEN BUILDING POINTS?

You nailed it - sometimes the tried-and-true stuff like insulation or draft sealing ends up being way more impactful than the flashy tech. I totally get the appeal of all the new water-saving devices, but I’ve actually seen similar situations where people install fancy low-flow fixtures or smart irrigation, and then don’t really use them (or even disable them because they’re annoying). Meanwhile, you seal up a few gaps or swap out old windows, and suddenly the house just feels better - quieter, more comfortable, and the utility bills drop.

I’d say it’s worth stepping back and looking at the house as a whole system. Energy efficiency upgrades tend to have a more direct effect on comfort and long-term costs, especially in places with extreme temps. But if you’re in an area with water restrictions or droughts, water savings might tip the scales. Sometimes it’s not either/or...it’s about what makes sense for your space and how people actually live day-to-day. There’s definitely no one-size-fits-all answer, but your point about what actually gets used is spot on.


Reply

CHOOSING BETWEEN ENERGY EFFICIENCY OR WATER SAVINGS FOR GREEN BUILDING POINTS?

I’ve wrestled with this on a few projects, and honestly, the “whole system” idea is where I usually land too. Here’s how I break it down: First, I look at what’s actually driving costs and discomfort for the people using the space. In colder climates, tightening up the envelope - insulation, windows, air sealing - almost always gives you more bang for your buck, both in comfort and savings. I once worked on a mid-century house where just sealing up the crawlspace and adding attic insulation made it feel like a totally new home.

But, there are spots - think southwest or places with real water scarcity - where water-saving measures can be a game-changer. That said, if folks end up bypassing those low-flow showerheads because they hate them, it’s kind of wasted effort. I’d say start by talking to whoever’s actually going to live or work there. What do they care about? What habits are they willing to change? Sometimes the simplest tweaks end up sticking the most... and those are the ones that last.


Reply

CHOOSING BETWEEN ENERGY EFFICIENCY OR WATER SAVINGS FOR GREEN BUILDING POINTS?

I get where you’re coming from. When we renovated our place, we focused on insulation first, and the difference in winter was huge. Tried those low-flow faucets too, but honestly, my family just found them annoying and swapped them out. Sometimes comfort wins over savings, even if it’s not the “greenest” choice.


Reply

Sometimes comfort wins over savings, even if it’s not the “greenest” choice.

Totally get this. When we built our place, I went all-in on radiant floor heating - energy efficient but also super comfy. Tried low-flow showers once... let’s just say, never again. For me, luxury and efficiency can mix, but not at the cost of daily comfort.


Reply

Choosing Between Energy Efficiency Or Water Savings For Green Building Points?

I hear you on the comfort front - there’s a reason radiant floors have such a loyal following. That gentle, even heat is hard to beat, and you’re right, it can be both efficient and luxurious. It’s one of those rare cases where the “green” choice actually feels like an upgrade.

But I’ll admit, water-saving fixtures are a tougher sell. I’ve worked on plenty of projects where clients tried low-flow showers or faucets, only to swap them out later because they just didn’t deliver. The reality is, if something’s frustrating to use every single day, no amount of points or savings will make it worthwhile in the long run. There’s a balance to be struck between resource efficiency and livability.

One thing I’ve noticed is that the technology is getting better - some of the newer low-flow showerheads are surprisingly good. Still, there’s a world of difference between models, and what works for one person might not cut it for another. I always suggest trying out different options before committing across the board.

In terms of green building points (LEED or otherwise), sometimes you have to pick your battles. If water conservation measures compromise comfort too much, maybe focus on areas where efficiency doesn’t feel like a sacrifice - insulation, windows, smart thermostats, etc. You can still rack up points and save resources without making daily life less enjoyable.

At the end of the day, sustainable design only works if people actually want to live with it. If folks end up bypassing features because they’re inconvenient or uncomfortable, that defeats the purpose anyway. A little pragmatism goes a long way...


Reply

CHOOSING BETWEEN ENERGY EFFICIENCY OR WATER SAVINGS FOR GREEN BUILDING POINTS?

- I’m right there with you on the low-flow fixtures. We put in a “highly rated” low-flow showerhead during our build, and honestly, it felt like standing under a leaky faucet. Ended up swapping it out after a month. Not worth the daily annoyance, no matter what the sticker says about gallons per minute.

- Energy efficiency has been a better investment for us. Insulation, windows, and a heat pump made a noticeable difference in comfort and bills. No regrets there. Plus, you don’t have to think about them once they’re in - they just work.

- Water savings... I get the appeal, especially in drought-prone areas. But if you’re not in a place where water is super expensive or scarce, it’s hard to justify sacrificing comfort for a few extra points.

- One thing I wish I’d known: some of the newer dual-flush toilets and aerated faucets are actually decent. But you really have to test them out first. What works for one person might drive someone else nuts.

- If I had to do it again, I’d focus on energy upgrades first - stuff that pays off every single day and doesn’t mess with your routines. Water-saving stuff is great if you find models that don’t feel like a downgrade, but I wouldn’t force it just for the points.

- At the end of the day, if you hate using something, you’ll end up replacing it anyway... and then what was the point? Go for the upgrades that make your life better *and* save resources. The rest is just greenwashing, honestly.


Reply

CHOOSING BETWEEN ENERGY EFFICIENCY OR WATER SAVINGS FOR GREEN BUILDING POINTS?

I totally get the frustration with low-flow fixtures. I once picked out a “designer” low-flow faucet for a client’s powder room, thinking it would be a win for both style and sustainability. It looked amazing, but guests kept asking if the water was even on... not ideal. Now, I always test fixtures in person before recommending them. For most projects, I suggest starting with energy upgrades - better insulation and windows really do make a difference you can feel every day. Water-saving features are great, but only if they don’t make daily routines a hassle. Comfort and usability matter just as much as the points, honestly.


Reply

CHOOSING BETWEEN ENERGY EFFICIENCY OR WATER SAVINGS FOR GREEN BUILDING POINTS?

- Totally hear you on the low-flow fixture struggle. I’ve had clients complain about “fancy” faucets that barely trickle, too - looks aren’t everything if you can’t wash your hands properly.
- Energy upgrades really do pay off, especially with insulation and windows. You feel the difference every day, not just on your utility bill.
- Water-saving is great, but if it makes daily life annoying, it’s not worth it. There’s a balance between points and practicality... sometimes you just need a faucet that works.
- Testing in person is key. I’ve learned the hard way that specs on paper don’t always match real life.
- Comfort matters just as much as sustainability - totally agree there.


Reply

CHOOSING BETWEEN ENERGY EFFICIENCY OR WATER SAVINGS FOR GREEN BUILDING POINTS?

I still remember the first time I toured a “green” show home with all the bells and whistles - triple-glazed windows, radiant floors, and these ultra-modern, supposedly water-saving faucets. The house looked like something out of a design magazine, but when I went to wash my hands, it felt like I was trying to rinse off in a gentle spring rain. Not exactly the spa-like experience I’d imagined.

That’s kind of stuck with me. I love the idea of saving water, but if it means you’re standing there forever just to fill a glass or rinse a pan, it loses its charm fast. I’ve seen friends swap out those fancy fixtures after a few months because they just couldn’t deal with the trickle. It’s funny how something so small can impact daily life so much.

On the flip side, energy upgrades have always felt like a win. We redid our insulation and windows last year - nothing flashy, but the difference was immediate. The house is quieter, cozier, and honestly, it just feels better. The lower bills are nice, but it’s more about that everyday comfort. You don’t notice what you’re missing until you finally get it.

I get why people chase those green building points, but sometimes I wonder if the checklist misses the point - pun not intended. There’s got to be a sweet spot where sustainability doesn’t mean sacrificing what makes a home feel good to live in. For me, if I had to pick one, energy efficiency wins out every time. Water savings are great in theory, but not if they make your morning routine a hassle.

Guess it comes down to what matters most to you - points on paper or how your home actually feels day-to-day.


Reply

CHOOSING BETWEEN ENERGY EFFICIENCY OR WATER SAVINGS FOR GREEN BUILDING POINTS?

That’s a good point about the water-saving fixtures - sometimes they just don’t work for real life. I’ve seen buyers get frustrated with low-flow showers or toilets that need double-flushing, which kind of defeats the purpose. On the other hand, energy upgrades like insulation or better windows are pretty much invisible once they’re in, but you notice the comfort and savings right away. Curious if anyone’s actually found water-saving tech that doesn’t feel like a compromise? Or is it just something we have to accept if we want those points?


Reply

CHOOSING BETWEEN ENERGY EFFICIENCY OR WATER SAVINGS FOR GREEN BUILDING POINTS?

I get where you’re coming from - some of those early low-flow toilets were a pain. But I’ve actually had good luck with newer dual-flush models in a couple projects. They seem to work just as well as standard ones, and clients haven’t complained. Maybe it’s a matter of picking the right brand or model? Energy upgrades are definitely less noticeable day-to-day, but I wouldn’t write off water-saving tech entirely.


Reply

Maybe it’s a matter of picking the right brand or model?

I’ve noticed the same thing. I swapped out some old fixtures in my own place last year - went with a mid-range dual-flush, and honestly, no issues so far. The early models were rough, but tech’s definitely improved. Energy savings are great, but seeing the water bill drop is pretty satisfying too.


Reply

Honestly, I wrestled with this same question when planning my build. Energy efficiency gets all the hype, but water savings can be just as impactful - especially if you’re in an area with high water rates or drought issues. I did a ton of research and ended up prioritizing water-saving fixtures over some of the pricier energy upgrades. Dual-flush toilets, low-flow showerheads, and efficient dishwashers made a bigger dent in my monthly bills than I expected.

That said, not all brands are created equal. Some of the cheaper models felt flimsy or didn’t perform well (learned that the hard way with a bargain faucet that barely trickled). Spending a bit more for quality paid off in the long run. If you’re chasing green building points, sometimes it’s about finding that sweet spot between upfront cost and long-term savings. Personally, seeing both my utility bills drop was pretty satisfying... but if I had to pick one, water savings edged out energy for me. Maybe it’s just because those numbers are easier to see month-to-month?


Reply

Choosing Between Energy Efficiency Or Water Savings For Green Building Points?

Funny, I’ve had clients get way more excited about their new low-flow showerhead than their fancy insulation. There’s just something satisfying about seeing the water bill drop, right? But I do think energy upgrades can sneak up on you in terms of savings - especially with heating and cooling. Sometimes it’s not as obvious until you hit a cold snap or a heatwave and realize your house is actually comfortable without the AC running nonstop. I’m with you on quality fixtures, though. Cheap stuff always seems to come back to haunt you... learned that lesson with a “budget” kitchen faucet that wobbled like a loose tooth.


Reply

Choosing Between Energy Efficiency Or Water Savings For Green Building Points?

I get why people geek out over the water bill dropping, but honestly, the energy side is where I see the biggest long-term impact. Had a project last year - client was all about the fancy rain shower and dual flush toilets, but once their first winter hit, the real “wow” moment was how steady the temps stayed inside. They barely touched their thermostat. Water savings feel more immediate, but energy upgrades can be a quiet game-changer... even if they’re not as flashy. Sometimes it’s the stuff you don’t see that really pays off.


Reply

Water savings feel more immediate, but energy upgrades can be a quiet game-changer... even if they’re not as flashy.

Funny how true that is. I’ve seen clients get excited about low-flow fixtures, but when you run the numbers, energy efficiency usually wins out over time - especially in larger developments. Insulation, smart HVAC, better windows... those things just keep paying dividends, year after year. Water’s important, no doubt, but energy costs can really sneak up on you if you don’t plan ahead. Sometimes the “boring” upgrades are the ones that make people happiest in the long run.


Reply

Sometimes the “boring” upgrades are the ones that make people happiest in the long run.

That’s the thing, isn’t it? Everyone loves a fancy rain shower or touchless faucet, but nobody gets excited about insulation. Still, I wonder - do those “boring” upgrades always deliver as much as promised? I’ve seen some high-end homes where the windows were top-of-the-line, but the HVAC was an afterthought. The owners ended up with big bills anyway. Maybe it’s about balance more than picking one over the other. Does anyone actually regret going heavy on energy efficiency, though? I haven’t seen it yet...


Reply

Energy Efficiency Regrets? Not Really, But...

I get what you’re saying. The “boring” stuff like insulation and air sealing just doesn’t have the wow factor, but it’s what makes a house comfortable year-round. I’ve seen people grumble about spending on that, but I can’t think of anyone who actually regretted it once they saw lower bills and fewer drafts. If anything, folks usually wish they’d done more.

That said, I have seen projects where people got a bit tunnel-visioned about one aspect - like going all-in on fancy windows but cheaping out on the HVAC or skipping proper air sealing. It kind of defeats the purpose. You need the pieces to work together or it’s just money down the drain.

Water-saving features are cool too, but unless you’re in an area with crazy water prices or restrictions, energy upgrades usually pay back faster. Still, if you’re chasing green building points, sometimes it’s just about checking boxes rather than real-world savings… Seen that more than once. It really comes down to priorities and climate, I guess.


Reply

CHOOSING BETWEEN ENERGY EFFICIENCY OR WATER SAVINGS FOR GREEN BUILDING POINTS?

- Gotta admit, I’m always a bit skeptical of “green points” if they don’t actually translate to real comfort or savings. Seen too many projects where folks chase certifications but end up with a house that’s still drafty or costs a fortune to run.
- Energy upgrades - especially insulation and air sealing - are the backbone. They’re not flashy, but you feel the difference every single day. I’ve never heard anyone say, “Wish I hadn’t made my house more comfortable and cheaper to heat.”
- Water-saving stuff is nice, but unless you’re in California or somewhere with crazy water bills, it’s usually more about bragging rights than payback. Low-flow fixtures are fine, but they don’t exactly change your life.
- If you’re after actual results, focus on the basics first: tight envelope, solid HVAC, then maybe windows if you’ve got budget left. The “wow” features can wait.
- Chasing points for the sake of a plaque on the wall? Meh. But if you want a house that feels good and saves money, energy efficiency wins almost every time.

Just my two cents... Seen too many people get distracted by shiny add-ons and miss the fundamentals.


Reply
Scroll to Top