Custom homes discussions and local services.
Choosing between energy efficiency or water savings for green building points?
CHOOSING BETWEEN ENERGY EFFICIENCY OR WATER SAVINGS FOR GREEN BUILDING POINTS?
I’ve noticed the same thing - energy upgrades almost always give you more bang for your buck in single-family homes. Water savings seem to matter more in places with high occupancy or crazy water rates. In one apartment project, switching to low-flow fixtures actually made a noticeable dent in the utility bills, but only because there were dozens of units. Otherwise, it sometimes feels like water points are just easier to grab for LEED, even if the impact isn’t huge. Anyone else ever feel like the water credits are a bit of a checkbox unless you’re in a drought-prone area?
Had a client last year who was obsessed with water-saving features, but honestly, the real difference in their bills came from updating insulation and switching to LED lighting. The low-flow fixtures were more about the checklist than real savings, at least in their case. Maybe it's different if you're in California or somewhere with strict water regs, but around here, energy tweaks seem to move the needle more.
CHOOSING BETWEEN ENERGY EFFICIENCY OR WATER SAVINGS FOR GREEN BUILDING POINTS?
That lines up with what I’ve seen, especially in the Midwest and Northeast. I had a project a couple years back where the homeowners were really focused on getting those green building points for water conservation - dual-flush toilets, low-flow everything, rain barrels, you name it. But when we actually tracked their utility bills, the biggest drop came after we air-sealed the attic and swapped out the old halogens for LEDs. The water bill barely budged, even with all the new fixtures.
I think a lot of folks get caught up in the checklist mentality, like you said. There’s this idea that every little thing will add up, but in reality, some upgrades just have a bigger impact than others, depending on where you live. Around here, water’s cheap and plentiful, so shaving a few gallons off a shower doesn’t really move the needle. But energy costs? That’s where you see real savings.
That said, I do get why people want to tick those boxes - sometimes it’s about resale value or just feeling like you’re doing your part. And in places like California or Arizona, where water’s at a premium, those same upgrades might make a much bigger difference. I remember reading about a project in San Diego where greywater systems and drought-tolerant landscaping cut their water use by half. Totally different ballgame.
It’s kind of funny how much the local context matters. I’ve even had clients who were surprised that their “green” home didn’t save them as much as they expected, just because the improvements weren’t matched to their actual utility costs. It’s all about picking your battles, I guess. Energy tweaks seem to give you more bang for your buck in most places, but I wouldn’t write off water-saving features entirely - just depends on what you’re trying to achieve and where you’re at.
Anyway, sounds like you steered your client in the right direction. Always satisfying when the data backs up the decisions.
CHOOSING BETWEEN ENERGY EFFICIENCY OR WATER SAVINGS FOR GREEN BUILDING POINTS?
- Not sure I’m totally on board with the idea that water savings don’t matter much outside the Southwest. Sure, energy bills usually drop more, but we’re seeing more unpredictable droughts even up north lately.
- I’ve had clients regret skipping rainwater catchment or permeable paving when the city suddenly put restrictions in place… utility rates can change fast.
- Also, some green building standards give equal weight to water and energy, so if you’re chasing certification, you can’t really ignore one or the other.
- Bottom line: I wouldn’t dismiss water upgrades just because the immediate savings aren’t huge. Sometimes it’s about future-proofing, not just today’s bills.
CHOOSING BETWEEN ENERGY EFFICIENCY OR WATER SAVINGS FOR GREEN BUILDING POINTS?
That’s a really good point about future-proofing. I used to think water savings weren’t a big deal in my area, but after last summer’s restrictions, I’m rethinking things. Energy upgrades are usually my go-to since the payback is obvious, but I’ve started looking at low-flow fixtures and rain barrels too. Sometimes it’s not just about the monthly bill - avoiding headaches down the line matters just as much.
Sometimes it’s not just about the monthly bill - avoiding headaches down the line matters just as much.
Totally get what you mean. I used to focus on energy stuff too - insulation, windows, all that. But after building last year, I realized water issues sneak up on you. We had a week where the city cut pressure and suddenly those “not a big deal” savings felt pretty important. Low-flow toilets are surprisingly decent now, and rain barrels are way less hassle than I expected. Honestly, I wish I’d planned for a greywater system from the start... retrofitting is a pain.
Honestly, I wish I’d planned for a greywater system from the start... retrofitting is a pain.
Totally relate to that. I thought energy upgrades would be the big challenge, but water stuff ended up way trickier than expected. Here’s what I learned:
- Rain barrels: way easier than I expected, but you need to plan overflow or you’ll have a swamp next to your foundation.
- Greywater: agree 100% - should’ve roughed it in during framing. Retrofitting means tearing into finished walls, which is just... ugh.
- Low-flow fixtures: was skeptical at first, but modern ones don’t feel like a downgrade at all. Showerheads especially surprised me.
One thing I’d add - don’t underestimate how much landscaping can eat up water. Native plants saved me a ton during last summer’s dry spell.
Energy stuff’s important, but when you’re staring at empty pipes for a week, priorities shift fast. If I could do it over, I’d balance both from the start instead of treating water as an afterthought.
Greywater: agree 100% - should’ve roughed it in during framing. Retrofitting means tearing into finished walls, which is just... ugh.
That’s the part people rarely budget for - how invasive water retrofits can get. Energy upgrades like insulation or even window swaps are usually less disruptive. I’ve seen folks try to add greywater lines after the fact and it’s almost always a mess, especially with slab foundations. If you’re building new, running those pipes early is so much cheaper and cleaner.
Landscaping’s a good callout too. I’ve had clients shocked at their irrigation bills until we swapped out turf for drought-tolerant stuff. Water savings there can be bigger than you’d think.
Title: Choosing Between Energy Efficiency or Water Savings for Green Building Points?
- 100% with you on the headaches of water retrofits. People always underestimate how much demo is involved. I’ve seen “simple” greywater installs turn into full-blown remodels, especially in older homes with tight crawlspaces or slabs.
- Energy upgrades are usually less messy, but not always a walk in the park either. Dense-pack insulation in old walls can get tricky, and window swaps sometimes mean reframing. Still, you’re right - less invasive than plumbing.
- Landscaping is a sneaky big deal. Swapping out grass for natives or xeriscape can drop water use by half or more. Had a neighbor who cut their bill by 60% just by ditching their lawn.
- One thing I’d add: local climate matters a ton. In dry areas, water savings might be more valuable than energy points, especially with droughts getting worse. In colder places, energy upgrades might pay off faster.
- Honestly, it’s rarely either/or. The best projects I’ve seen tackle both, but if you have to pick, look at what’s most expensive or disruptive to retrofit later. Water systems are almost always harder to add after the fact.
I’ve run into the same headaches with water retrofits - especially in older homes where you just never know what’s behind those walls. One thing I always tell clients: if you’re already opening up floors or walls for another reason, that’s your golden window to tackle plumbing upgrades. Otherwise, energy stuff like insulation or swapping out lighting is way less disruptive and usually more cost-effective per point. For interiors, even just switching to low-flow fixtures can get you a chunk of water savings without the drama of a full-on plumbing overhaul. If you’re stuck choosing, I’d lean toward whatever’s going to be a bigger pain to add later...and in my experience, that’s almost always the water systems.
Totally agree about the “open wall = do all the things” approach. I’ve learned the hard way that skipping plumbing upgrades when you have access just means you’ll be cursing yourself later. Curious - has anyone tried running PEX lines as a partial retrofit? I’ve found it’s a bit easier to snake through tight spaces, but not sure how it holds up long-term compared to copper.
Choosing Between Energy Efficiency Or Water Savings For Green Building Points?
I’ve actually done a partial PEX retrofit in my own place, and I’ll admit, I was skeptical at first. Grew up in a house with copper pipes, so it felt weird trusting plastic for something as important as water. But after wrestling with old galvanized lines behind plaster walls, I was ready to try anything that didn’t involve tearing out half the house.
PEX is a dream to snake through tight spots - especially if you’re dealing with weird angles or old framing. I used it for a bathroom reno, and it saved me a ton of time and patchwork. As for longevity, I did a lot of research and talked to a couple plumbers. Most said PEX holds up really well, especially if you avoid direct sunlight and use proper fittings. There’s always the “what if” factor, but honestly, I’d do it again.
If you’re thinking green points, PEX can help with water savings too - less heat loss from hot water lines, and fewer joints mean less chance of leaks. It’s not perfect, but it’s a solid option if you’re opening up walls anyway.
I hear you on the PEX skepticism - I was in the same boat. My old place had copper, and I always thought it was the gold standard. But after a slab leak (nightmare), I went with PEX for the repair. It’s wild how much faster hot water gets to the tap now, which I guess helps both energy and water use. That said, I still wonder if focusing on insulation or better appliances would’ve made a bigger dent in my utility bills. Sometimes it feels like you fix one thing and three more pop up... but at least I’m not chasing leaks anymore.
Title: Choosing Between Energy Efficiency or Water Savings for Green Building Points?
PEX really does change the game with hot water delivery - it's kind of wild how much of a difference pipe material and layout make. I get where you’re coming from on the “fix one thing, three more pop up” feeling... building systems are like that game of whack-a-mole sometimes.
From a design perspective, insulation usually gives you the biggest bang for your buck in terms of energy savings. It’s not flashy, but better insulation can cut both heating and cooling loads, which is huge over time. That said, appliances have come a long way too - swapping out an old water heater or washing machine can make a noticeable dent in utility bills.
Water savings are trickier. PEX helps with wait times and leaks, but unless you’re in a drought-prone area or paying high water rates, the impact on your bottom line might not be as dramatic as energy upgrades. Still, not having to worry about another slab leak? That’s peace of mind you can’t really put a price on...
You’re spot on about insulation being the unsung hero. It’s not glamorous, but it really does pay dividends over the years - sometimes in ways people don’t even notice, like more consistent indoor temps and less strain on HVAC systems. I’ve seen projects where just upgrading attic and wall insulation made a bigger difference than any fancy tech.
I do think water savings get overlooked, though. Even in areas without high water costs, there’s a long-term resilience factor that’s hard to quantify. I had a client who was skeptical about low-flow fixtures, but after a year, they were surprised by how much their usage dropped (and how little they missed the old ones). PEX is great for peace of mind, too - no one wants to deal with leaks hidden behind drywall.
It really comes down to what matters most for the project or the client. Sometimes it’s about points, sometimes it’s about comfort or future-proofing. Either way, it sounds like you’re weighing the options thoughtfully, which is half the battle in green building.
It really comes down to what matters most for the project or the client. Sometimes it’s about points, sometimes it’s about comfort or future-proofing.
That’s honestly the trickiest part - figuring out what’ll actually make life better for whoever’s living there. I’ve had clients get super excited about solar panels, but then they’re shocked by how much just sealing up drafts changes their day-to-day comfort. Water savings is a tough sell sometimes, but you’re right, it adds up in ways people don’t expect. I guess there’s no one-size-fits-all answer, but it sounds like you’re really thinking it through. That’s huge.
You nailed it - sometimes the “sexy” upgrades get all the attention, but it’s those less glamorous fixes like insulation or low-flow fixtures that really change how a home feels. I’ve seen people rave about their new rain shower, then quietly admit they love how even the draftiest room finally feels cozy. You’re right to weigh it all out. There’s no perfect formula, but being thoughtful about what actually improves daily life is half the battle.
Choosing Between Energy Efficiency Or Water Savings For Green Building Points?
I’ve been in the trenches on a few projects where the debate between energy and water savings got pretty heated - no pun intended. Funny thing is, the “wow” factor upgrades always get the spotlight, but it’s the insulation, air sealing, and those boring-sounding water fixtures that actually make people happier long-term. One time, we put in all these fancy smart thermostats and solar panels, but what folks kept bringing up was how their utility bills dropped after we beefed up the attic insulation and swapped out old windows.
I’ll admit, I lean toward energy efficiency first because it’s got that compounding effect - better insulation means less heating/cooling, which means smaller systems, which means more savings down the line. But I’ve also seen drought-prone areas where water savings are just as critical. It really depends on the site and what’s actually going to matter for the people living there. Sometimes you gotta go with what’s going to make the biggest dent in comfort and costs, even if it’s not the flashiest upgrade.
Totally get where you’re coming from. I’ve lost count of how many times folks get excited about the “cool” upgrades, but it’s the stuff like weatherstripping and low-flow showerheads that actually make life better day-to-day. Sometimes feels like the unglamorous choices are the real MVPs. I’m with you - depends on where you live, but those basic improvements always seem to pay off more than people expect.
CHOOSING BETWEEN ENERGY EFFICIENCY OR WATER SAVINGS FOR GREEN BUILDING POINTS?
You know, I used to chase after the “fun” upgrades - fancy thermostats, smart lights, all that jazz. But honestly, the first winter we lived in our current place, I realized a $10 roll of weatherstripping was worth more than any gadget. The house stopped feeling drafty overnight. As for water savings, I’ll admit I was skeptical about low-flow showerheads (I like my showers, what can I say?), but turns out I barely noticed a difference and our bills dropped. It’s not flashy, but sometimes boring is best... or at least the most practical. Anybody else ever regret skipping the “boring” stuff?