Custom homes discussions and local services.

Keeping the critters out: weird but effective tricks?

307 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

I’ve tried a lot of the “old school” methods and honestly, some of them work better than the fancy stuff. We used to string up CDs on fishing line around our veggie beds - looked ridiculous, but the glare kept rabbits and birds away most of the season. Motion sprinklers are decent, but they can be a pain if you forget to turn them off and end up soaked yourself. I’m not sold on glass panels either… birds just don’t seem to see them. Low-tech isn’t always pretty, but it’s usually reliable.


Reply

I’ve seen the CD trick in a few yards and always wondered if it actually worked or was just for show. Good to know there’s something to it. I’ve tried chicken wire buried a few inches down for burrowing critters, but it’s a pain to install and mow around. Ever mess with those fake owl decoys? I keep hearing mixed things - some folks swear by them, others say the birds just get used to ‘em after a while. Curious if anyone’s had luck with those or if it’s just another garden myth.


Reply

- Tried the fake owl a couple years back - looked cool for a week, but the squirrels figured it out pretty quick.
- I’ve had better luck with motion-activated sprinklers. They’re a little pricey but actually startled a raccoon once (and me, too).
- Wondering if anyone’s tried those solar-powered ultrasonic things? I’m skeptical, but maybe they work for certain critters...


Reply

Wondering if anyone’s tried those solar-powered ultrasonic things? I’m skeptical, but maybe they work for certain critters...

I’ve seen those ultrasonic gadgets pop up on job sites, but honestly, I haven’t noticed them making much difference. Maybe they work for rabbits or something, but squirrels and raccoons seem to just ignore ‘em. If you’re dealing with persistent critters, physical barriers (like mesh or hardware cloth) have always been more reliable in my experience. The fake owl thing - yeah, the squirrels are way too smart for that. They’ll be sitting on its head by week two.


Reply

I’ve always wondered about those ultrasonic things too - like, are the critters supposed to just pack up and leave because of a weird noise? I’m with you on the fake owl. I tried one on my balcony and the pigeons basically adopted it as their new roommate.

Honestly, I think the only thing that’s ever worked for me is making spaces less appealing in the first place. I had a client who swore by planting mint around her garden beds - apparently some animals hate the smell. Not sure if it’s foolproof, but her lettuce survived longer than mine did last year.

Physical barriers are a pain to install, but at least you know where you stand. The gadgets feel a bit like wishful thinking... unless someone’s got a magic brand I haven’t heard of?


Reply

Title: Keeping the critters out: weird but effective tricks?

- Totally get what you mean about gadgets feeling like wishful thinking. I’ve seen folks spend a small fortune on those ultrasonic things, and the squirrels just keep doing their thing.
- Mint’s a solid idea - never tried it myself, but I’ve heard similar stories. Sometimes the old-school stuff just works better.
- Physical barriers are a pain, yeah, but at least you know they’re not going to “wear off” like sprays or scents. Chicken wire isn’t pretty, but it’s saved a lot of tomatoes in my experience.
- Honestly, I think it’s about layering up - nothing’s 100%, but a few tricks together seem to make a difference.

Hang in there. Critters are persistent, but so are gardeners...


Reply

Title: Keeping the critters out: weird but effective tricks?

Honestly, couldn’t agree more about those ultrasonic gadgets - total waste of money in my experience. I’ve watched squirrels literally sit on top of the devices, looking smug as ever. Mint does seem to help a bit with smaller pests, but you’re right, nothing beats a solid physical barrier. Sure, chicken wire isn’t exactly winning any design awards, but if it keeps the raccoons from tearing up my beds for the fifth time in a season, I’ll take ugly over ruined crops any day.

Layering is key. I used to think one “fix” would solve it all, but nope - critters are too clever for that. A mix of fencing, some strategic planting (marigolds actually helped with rabbits for me), and yeah, even a few old-school scare tactics like shiny tape or fake owls. Not perfect, but it’s about making your garden just annoying enough that they go bother someone else.

It gets frustrating, no doubt, but you’re spot on - gardeners are stubborn by nature. If nothing else, every failed trick is just one more story to laugh about later... or at least grumble over coffee.


Reply

Title: Keeping the critters out: weird but effective tricks?

Those ultrasonic things are a joke, honestly. I tried one last year after my neighbor swore by it - figured maybe I was missing something. Nope. Squirrels just used it as a launchpad to get to my tomato cages. The only thing that seemed remotely phased was my dog, who refused to go near that end of the yard for weeks.

Physical barriers are ugly, sure, but at least they work. I built a little “fortress” around my raised beds with hardware cloth and some leftover 2x4s. Not going to win any curb appeal contests, but I haven’t lost a single pepper plant since. Raccoons are persistent, though... I caught one trying to dig under the fence at 2am. Ended up burying the wire a foot down - felt a little ridiculous, but it did the trick.

I’m still skeptical about the fake owl thing. Tried one once, and the crows just stared at it like it owed them money. But shiny tape actually did help with the birds pecking at my strawberries, so I’ll give credit where it’s due.

Marigolds for rabbits is new to me - I might have to try that. Usually I just end up chasing them off with a broom in my pajamas, which I’m sure is a sight for the neighbors.

It’s always a patchwork of solutions, isn’t it? Every time I think I’ve outsmarted them, some new critter shows up with a different playbook. At least it keeps things interesting... or at least gives me something to complain about when the coffee’s brewing.


Reply

Physical barriers are ugly, sure, but at least they work. I built a little “fortress” around my raised beds with hardware cloth and some leftover 2x4s. Not going to win any curb appeal contests, but I haven’t lost a single pepper plant since.

I totally get the struggle between function and aesthetics - sometimes it feels like you have to pick one or the other. If you’re looking to soften the look of those hardware cloth fortresses, have you tried weaving in some flexible willow branches or even bamboo? It’s not a perfect disguise, but it can blend things in a bit and add a more natural vibe. I’ve seen folks use climbing plants like sweet peas or nasturtiums along the outside of their barriers too. They grow fast and can cover up a lot of “ugly” without interfering with the structure.

Curious if anyone’s had luck with scent-based deterrents? I’ve heard mixed things about using things like coffee grounds or citrus peels around beds, but haven’t tried it myself. Wondering if that’s just another garden myth or if it actually helps keep the critters guessing...


Reply

Curious if anyone’s had luck with scent-based deterrents? I’ve heard mixed things about using things like coffee grounds or citrus peels around beds, but haven’t tried it myself.

I tried citrus peels last year after reading about it online - honestly, didn’t notice much difference. Squirrels still dug around like they owned the place. Coffee grounds seemed to help a bit with slugs, but not the bigger critters. Maybe it depends on what you’re dealing with? I’ve had better luck with motion-activated sprinklers, but those can be a pain to set up if you’ve got a weird-shaped garden.


Reply

Keeping The Critters Out: Weird But Effective Tricks?

Funny you mention motion-activated sprinklers - I tried those too, and yeah, they’re effective but kind of a hassle if you’ve got a garden that’s not just a simple rectangle. I’m honestly skeptical about the scent stuff for anything bigger than slugs or maybe cats. Have you ever tried companion planting for pest control? I’ve had some luck with marigolds keeping certain bugs away, but not sure if that’d do much for squirrels or raccoons. Wonder if there’s a “greener” solution that actually works for the bigger troublemakers...


Reply

Keeping The Critters Out: Weird But Effective Tricks?

I’ve tried the marigolds too, and while they’re pretty, I’m not sure they did much for anything bigger than aphids. My neighbor swears by planting garlic around the perimeter, but honestly, I think the squirrels just treat it like an obstacle course. One year, I tried hanging old CDs from fishing line - supposedly the reflections scare off birds and maybe other critters - but all it really did was make my yard look like a disco gone wrong.

The raccoons are the real puzzle for me. They’re smart enough to open latches and seem unfazed by most deterrents. Has anyone ever tried using sound as a deterrent? I read somewhere about motion-activated radios tuned to talk stations, but I can’t decide if that’s genius or just wishful thinking. Wondering if there’s something less intrusive that actually works for those little bandits...


Reply

I’ve actually tried the motion-activated radio trick for raccoons - set it to a talk station like you mentioned. It worked for about a week, then they just got used to it and ignored the noise. Honestly, they’re too clever for most of these “weird” tricks. The only thing that’s slowed them down for me is using a locking bin with a bungee cord, and even then, I check it every morning just in case. Raccoons are relentless.


Reply

I hear you on raccoons being little escape artists. The radio trick is clever, but yeah, they catch on quick. Here’s what I’ve had luck with: first, double up on deterrents - combine that locking bin with a layer of heavy paving stones on top. Second, sprinkle a line of cayenne pepper or ammonia-soaked rags around the base. Sounds odd, but it’s kept them guessing on my projects. They’re persistent, but mixing up your approach every few weeks seems to throw them off their game.


Reply

mixing up your approach every few weeks seems to throw them off their game.

I’ve definitely found that switching things up is key. Raccoons in my area figured out bungee cords and even managed to roll a bin down the driveway once - still not sure how. What’s worked best for me is a combo: screw-top compost bins (no easy handles), plus a motion-activated sprinkler. The water freaks them out way more than smells, at least for a while... but yeah, they’re clever. Never underestimate a motivated raccoon.


Reply

Never underestimate a motivated raccoon.

That’s the truth. I swear, sometimes I think they’re just waiting for us to get complacent. The motion-activated sprinkler is a solid move - water seems to be one of the few things that actually gets their attention, at least until they wise up. I’ve tried those ultrasonic noise gadgets, but honestly, I think the raccoons just learned to ignore them after a week or two. Maybe they’re only good for squirrels or something less stubborn.

I’m with you on the screw-top bins. Handles are basically an invitation for trouble. I once watched a raccoon try to unscrew a lid for a good ten minutes before giving up, and it was almost impressive how close it got. Makes me wonder if we’re just in an arms race with these little bandits.

Mixing up tactics every few weeks is smart, but I sometimes wonder if we’re training them to be even more resourceful. Like, are we just making them smarter by forcing them to solve new puzzles all the time? Not that there’s much choice - if you stick with one method, they’ll crack it eventually.

Anyway, your combo approach sounds like the way to go. I’d say don’t be afraid to get weird with it either. I’ve heard of people using old CDs as reflectors, or even sprinkling cayenne pepper around the bins (though that seems a bit harsh). At the end of the day, it’s about staying one step ahead... or at least trying to.

Props for not giving up after the bungee cord incident. That’s some next-level raccoon ingenuity right there.


Reply

I sometimes wonder if we’re training them to be even more resourceful.

That’s crossed my mind too. I swear, half the time it feels like I’m running a raccoon bootcamp in my backyard. I tried the cayenne trick once - felt a bit overkill, honestly. What’s worked for me is a combo of a heavy stone on the lid and moving the bins around every week. They hate unpredictability. If they can’t memorize the setup, they seem to lose interest faster.


Reply

That unpredictability trick is clever. I’ve noticed the same thing - if I stick to a routine, they figure it out fast. I tried bungee cords once, but they just chewed through them. Heavy stone seems more reliable, honestly. You’re not alone in this raccoon arms race...


Reply

Heavy stone seems more reliable, honestly. You’re not alone in this raccoon arms race...

I hear you on the bungee cords - tried that myself and it was basically a raccoon chew toy by morning. Heavy stones work, but they’re a pain to move every time you need to get into the bin or whatever. I ended up switching to those metal trash cans with locking lids. Not perfect, but at least they can’t just muscle their way in or gnaw through.

One thing I’ve noticed: if you change up where you put your bins or rotate which ones have food scraps, it throws them off for a bit. They’re smart, but they seem to get frustrated if the “puzzle” keeps changing. Still, nothing’s foolproof. I swear these critters are evolving just to mess with us.

If you’ve got any fencing around, electric wire (low voltage) along the top edge works too - just enough to startle, not hurt. Not everyone’s cup of tea, but it’s been effective for me on some sites.


Reply

Heavy stones work, but they’re a pain to move every time you need to get into the bin or whatever.

I get the appeal of heavy stones, but honestly, I’m skeptical about their long-term practicality. Metal cans with locking lids are a step up, but I’ve seen raccoons figure those out too if they’re determined enough. As for electric wire - effective, sure, but it feels like overkill for a backyard bin. I’ve had some luck with motion-activated lights; not perfect, but sometimes the simplest deterrents buy you a little peace.


Reply
Scroll to Top