Custom homes discussions and local services.

Brick veneer or real brick walls - worth the extra hassle?

388 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

Good points raised here, especially about moisture. A couple things to keep in mind:

- Brick veneer has improved a lot, but you're right - moisture management can still be tricky. Proper installation with a good drainage plane and ventilation gap behind the veneer is key. I've seen some newer builds handle this really well, but it definitely depends on the contractor knowing their stuff.

- Real brick does breathe better, true, but it's not foolproof either. I've come across older brick homes with moisture issues because of poor mortar maintenance or inadequate flashing. So even real brick needs attention over time.

- Nostalgia is definitely a factor, but there's also the environmental angle. Real brick tends to have a higher upfront environmental impact (energy-intensive manufacturing), but it lasts forever if maintained properly. Veneer might be lighter on resources initially, but if it needs replacing sooner, that advantage fades.

Personally, I'd lean toward real brick if budget and structural considerations allow - but veneer can work great too, provided you don't cut corners on installation details.


Reply

Good insights here, especially on moisture. Honestly, I've seen veneer done beautifully in some high-end homes lately - when the builder really knows their stuff, it's impressive how well it holds up. That said, real brick just has that timeless feel you can't quite replicate. Had a friend whose older brick home needed some mortar work after decades, but once fixed, it was solid again. If you're planning long-term and can swing the extra cost, real brick might be worth it...but veneer can definitely be a solid choice too if installed properly.


Reply

Had a similar experience with veneer - looked fantastic at first, but after about 10 years, some sections started loosening up. Could've been installation issues, though. Curious if anyone's seen veneer hold up well beyond 15-20 years without needing repairs?


Reply

My folks' place has veneer that's pushing 25 years now...still looks decent, but they've had to patch up a few loose spots here and there. Probably depends a lot on climate and how well it was installed in the first place.


Reply

"Probably depends a lot on climate and how well it was installed in the first place."

That's true to an extent, but honestly, even with perfect installation, veneer has its limits. I've seen plenty of cases where moisture eventually finds its way behind the veneer, especially in wetter climates or areas with freeze-thaw cycles. Once water gets trapped, it can cause issues like mold or structural damage that aren't immediately visible.

Real brick walls, while definitely more hassle upfront (and pricier), tend to handle moisture and temperature fluctuations better over the long haul. They breathe better and are less prone to hidden deterioration. Sure, veneer can look great for decades if you're lucky, but if you're thinking long-term - like 30+ years - real brick might save you headaches down the road.

Just something to consider...


Reply

Good points overall, but a couple things to keep in mind:

- Even real brick walls aren't foolproof. I've seen plenty of older brick homes with mortar issues or moisture damage if maintenance slips.
- Proper drainage and flashing behind veneer can make a huge difference. If done right, veneer can hold up surprisingly well.
- Still, you're right about freeze-thaw cycles - those can be brutal on veneer over time.

Bottom line, both have pros and cons...depends how much maintenance you're willing to commit to long-term.


Reply

"Proper drainage and flashing behind veneer can make a huge difference. If done right, veneer can hold up surprisingly well."

Couldn't agree more with this point. When we renovated our place, the contractor emphasized drainage and flashing behind the brick veneer, and it's held up beautifully for nearly a decade now - even through some harsh winters. Real brick walls definitely have their charm, but honestly, with proper installation and occasional checks, veneer hasn't been much hassle at all. Just my two cents from personal experience...


Reply

Yeah, good points all around. I've seen veneer installations fail miserably when drainage was overlooked - mold, moisture buildup, total mess. But with proper detailing and regular maintenance, veneer can be just as reliable as solid brick, at a fraction of the weight and hassle.


Reply

"But with proper detailing and regular maintenance, veneer can be just as reliable as solid brick, at a fraction of the weight and hassle."

Makes sense, but I'm wondering - does veneer hold up as well long-term in harsher climates? Like, would freezing winters or heavy rain eventually cause more issues compared to solid brick? Just curious if anyone's had experience with that...


Reply

I've worked with both veneer and solid brick in developments up north, and honestly, while veneer can perform well if meticulously maintained, harsher climates do test it more. Freezing cycles and heavy rain can lead to moisture getting trapped behind the veneer, causing eventual cracking or loosening over time. Solid brick walls, though heavier and pricier upfront, often handle these conditions better without as much fuss. Just something to consider if you're building in areas with harsh winters...


Reply

Totally agree with your points, especially about moisture issues. I've seen veneer walls that looked great initially but started showing problems after just a few harsh winters. Solid brick definitely holds up better long-term, though it can be a pain budget-wise at first. One thing I'd add is insulation - solid brick walls can sometimes feel colder inside if not properly insulated. So, it's worth factoring in extra insulation measures if you go that route...just something else to keep in mind.


Reply

Good points overall, but a couple things to consider:

- Solid brick definitely has longevity, but I've seen cases where improper insulation actually led to condensation issues inside. So insulation isn't just about warmth - it's also about moisture control.
- Budget-wise, veneer can be tempting, but have you looked into higher-quality veneers with better moisture barriers? They cost more upfront but might bridge that gap between durability and budget.

Curious if anyone's had experience with these upgraded veneer systems holding up better long-term...


Reply

Good points about moisture barriers - wish I'd thought more about that when I first started my build. A few years back, I went with a mid-range brick veneer system because the real brick was just too pricey and seemed like overkill for my needs. At first, everything looked great, but after a couple winters, I noticed some dampness creeping in around the windows and corners. Nothing catastrophic, but enough to make me question my choice.

Ended up having to redo some flashing and add extra sealing - probably could've avoided that hassle if I'd invested in one of those upgraded veneer systems you're mentioning from the start. I've heard good things about them since then, especially the ones with integrated moisture barriers and better insulation backing.

Still curious myself how much better these premium veneers hold up in practice though. Are they really worth the extra upfront cost, or is it just marketing hype? From what I've seen, installation quality matters just as much as materials. Even top-notch products can fail if they're not installed carefully (learned that lesson the hard way...).

Also agree on your point about insulation - moisture control is huge. A friend of mine built with solid brick walls but skimped on insulation details; he ended up battling mold issues for months until he finally bit the bullet and fixed his insulation setup properly.

Anyway, if I ever do another build (fingers crossed!), I'll definitely dig deeper into these upgraded veneers before making a decision. Seems like they might hit that sweet spot between budget and durability - but I'd still love to hear more firsthand experiences before committing.


Reply

Definitely agree about installation quality - seen premium veneers fail badly just because of rushed installs. Personally, though, I've found the upgraded systems with integrated moisture barriers do noticeably better over time, especially in harsher climates. Worth considering if longevity's a priority.


Reply

Have you noticed a big difference in moisture performance with those upgraded systems? I've had mixed experiences myself. Did a build about five years ago with a premium veneer and integrated moisture barrier, thinking it'd hold up better in our wet winters. Honestly, it did pretty well initially, but after a couple of seasons, I started noticing some minor issues - nothing catastrophic, but enough to make me question if the extra cost was really justified.

On the flip side, I've done plenty of real brick walls that have stood rock-solid for decades without any fuss. Sure, they're more labor-intensive and pricier upfront, but there's something reassuring about knowing they're built to last. Maybe it's just me, but I tend to trust traditional methods more when longevity's the goal.

Curious though - has anyone else had similar experiences with these newer systems not quite living up to expectations over time?


Reply

I've noticed something similar with veneer setups. Had one installed about 6 years back, looked great at first but started seeing moisture creeping in around year three. Real brick walls I've had never gave me issues - maybe old-school is just more reliable long-term?


Reply

"Had one installed about 6 years back, looked great at first but started seeing moisture creeping in around year three."

That's interesting... Do you think it might've been a sealing or installation issue rather than the veneer itself? I'm currently planning my first custom build and debating between veneer and traditional brick. Kinda worried now about moisture problems down the line. Did your installer mention anything specific about maintenance or sealing to prevent water intrusion? Curious if that's a common thing people overlook...


Reply

Had a similar experience a few years back - turned out the moisture issue wasn't really the veneer itself but rather the flashing and sealing around windows and joints. Once we got that sorted, no more problems. Did your installer use any sort of moisture barrier behind the veneer? Sometimes that step gets rushed or overlooked... Proper detailing makes all the difference.


Reply

Good points here - seen this issue pop up a lot. Usually it's exactly as you said, flashing and sealing details. Couple quick things I'd add from experience:

- Moisture barrier behind veneer is non-negotiable. If your installer skipped or rushed it, you're asking for trouble down the road.
- Proper weep holes at the base are also critical. Seen some jobs where they were forgotten entirely - no joke, brick wall turned into a sponge.
- Real brick walls aren't immune either, though. If detailing's sloppy, you'll still end up chasing leaks.

End of the day, good detailing beats fancy materials every time...


Reply

"End of the day, good detailing beats fancy materials every time..."

Couldn't agree more with this. A few years back, I went with real brick thinking it'd be bulletproof - ended up with leaks anyway because the flashing was sloppy. Lesson learned.

Couple things I'd add from a budget-conscious perspective:

- Brick veneer can actually be pretty solid if done right. Key is finding someone who knows their stuff and won't cut corners on moisture barriers and weep holes (seriously, can't stress this enough).
- Real brick walls look great, but the cost jump isn't always worth it. You're paying extra mostly for aesthetics and a bit more durability, but if your installer skimps on detailing, you're still stuck with problems.
- Maintenance matters too. Veneer repairs tend to be quicker and cheaper. Real brick fixes... well, let's just say my wallet still remembers.

Bottom line, whichever you choose, don't cheap out on the installer. Good craftsmanship pays off big time down the road.


Reply
Scroll to Top