Custom homes discussions and local services.

Brick veneer or real brick walls - worth the extra hassle?

388 replies
 

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

"Maybe it's the charm factor or perceived durability...not sure."

Yeah, you're onto something there. Solid brick definitely has that classic, timeless look buyers seem to love. When we were deciding, our builder mentioned veneer can sometimes limit your resale in high-end markets - but it really depends on your neighborhood. I'd say check out recent sales nearby; if solid brick homes consistently sell higher, then maybe the extra hassle is worth it. Either way, sounds like you're considering all the right things!


Reply

We had veneer on our first house, and honestly, it held up pretty well. But when we moved into our current place - a solid brick home built in the 60s - I noticed a difference right away. It just feels sturdier somehow, quieter inside too. Not sure if it's psychological or what, but neighbors who've renovated veneer homes seem to deal with more moisture issues. Could be coincidence, but I'd lean toward solid brick if budget allows...just my two cents.


Reply

Interesting points about moisture issues - I've seen that happen too, especially if the veneer wasn't installed properly or the drainage wasn't thought through. Solid brick definitely has its perks, but I'm curious: have you noticed any difference in insulation or heating costs since moving into your solid brick home? Older brick houses sometimes have their own quirks when it comes to energy efficiency...would be interesting to hear your experience on that front.


Reply

"Older brick houses sometimes have their own quirks when it comes to energy efficiency..."

You're spot on about older brick homes having quirks. I've lived in both veneer and solid brick houses, and honestly, the solid brick place felt noticeably chillier in winter. Even with decent insulation upgrades, heating bills were still higher than expected. That said, summers were surprisingly comfortable - brick seems to hold cooler temps longer. So it's a bit of a trade-off...depends if you're more concerned about winter heating or summer cooling costs, I guess.


Reply

I totally get what you're saying about the chill factor in solid brick houses. My grandparents had this old solid brick farmhouse, and I remember visiting as a kid - winters there were something else. They'd crank up the wood stove, and we'd still be huddled under blankets because the walls just seemed to soak up all the heat. But summers? Man, that place was a lifesaver. We'd come in from working outside on hot afternoons, and it felt like stepping into a cool cellar.

Funny thing is, years later when I built my own place, I went with brick veneer thinking I'd dodge some of those winter chills. It definitely helped with insulation and heating bills, but honestly, it never quite matched that natural coolness in summer that solid brick had. Guess there's no perfect solution - just depends on which season bugs you more...


Reply

"Guess there's no perfect solution - just depends on which season bugs you more..."

That's a fair point, but honestly, I'd argue there's a third option worth considering that might give you the best of both worlds. When we renovated our home a few years back, we faced the same dilemma - solid brick charm versus veneer practicality. After a lot of research and some trial and error, we ended up going with brick veneer combined with a thicker-than-standard insulation layer and thermal mass internally (like concrete floors or internal brick feature walls). Here's how we approached it step-by-step:

First, we chose a high-quality brick veneer for the exterior. This gave us the aesthetic appeal we wanted without the full cost and complexity of solid brick construction. Next, we invested in extra insulation - more than the standard building code required. We went with spray foam insulation because it seals gaps better and reduces drafts significantly. This alone made a noticeable difference in winter comfort.

But the real game-changer was adding thermal mass inside the house. We installed polished concrete floors in the main living areas and even incorporated an internal brick wall as a feature in our living room. These elements absorb heat during the day and slowly release it at night, stabilizing indoor temperatures year-round. In winter, the floors and internal walls hold onto warmth from sunlight or heating systems, and in summer, they soak up excess heat, keeping the interior pleasantly cool.

Now, I'm not saying it's exactly like that old farmhouse coolness you described - there's definitely something uniquely refreshing about solid brick - but it's pretty close. Plus, our heating bills dropped significantly, and summers are way more comfortable than before. It might not be the traditional solution, but sometimes blending old-school principles with modern techniques can give you surprisingly good results.

Just thought I'd toss that out there as food for thought...


Reply

We did something similar - brick veneer outside, extra insulation, and internal brick walls. Honestly, best decision we made. Keeps temps steady year-round, and our energy bills dropped noticeably. Solid brick charm is nice, but practicality won out for us...no regrets here.


Reply

"Solid brick charm is nice, but practicality won out for us...no regrets here."

Couldn't agree more on practicality winning out. We went with brick veneer too, primarily because we wanted flexibility with insulation and wiring upgrades down the road. Real brick walls can be a nightmare if you ever need to run new electrical lines or plumbing - speaking from experience, helping a friend retrofit his older solid-brick home was a weekend I won't soon forget.

One thing I'd add is that brick veneer also makes exterior maintenance easier. If you ever have moisture issues or damage, repairs are generally simpler and less costly than with solid brick structures. Of course, solid brick does have its charm and durability, but for modern living and efficiency, veneer just makes more sense. Glad to hear your energy bills improved noticeably; ours did too, especially in winter months.


Reply

I see your point about practicality, and generally I'd agree. Brick veneer definitely offers flexibility, especially if you're planning future upgrades or renovations. I've worked on plenty of homes where solid brick walls turned simple wiring jobs into expensive headaches - so your friend's experience sounds painfully familiar.

That said, I wouldn't completely dismiss solid brick. From a builder's perspective, there's something reassuring about the structural integrity and longevity it provides. I've seen century-old brick homes still standing strong with minimal structural issues, provided they're properly maintained. Veneer, while easier to repair, can sometimes hide underlying moisture problems if not installed correctly.

Still, for most modern homeowners, veneer probably is the smarter choice. Easier maintenance, better insulation options, and fewer headaches down the road...hard to argue against that. Glad it's working out well for you.


Reply

Totally get where you're coming from with solid brick having that old-school charm and durability. Honestly, I love the look of those century-old brick homes - something about them just feels timeless and cozy. But as someone who's always juggling a tight budget, veneer was a lifesaver for us. Easier wiring, insulation upgrades without breaking the bank...and fewer surprise expenses down the line. Still, gotta admit, sometimes I envy those classic brick walls - just not enough to empty my wallet for them, haha.


Reply

- Totally agree with you on the veneer front - went that route myself a few years back.
- Real brick has amazing charm, no doubt, but man... the cost and hassle of repairs can really sneak up on you.
- Had friends who bought a gorgeous old brick place; looked fantastic, but insulation was a nightmare. Heating bills through the roof every winter.
- Veneer gave us flexibility for upgrades without sacrificing too much of that classic look.
- Still, gotta say, whenever I walk past those historic brick homes downtown, there's definitely some envy creeping in, haha.


Reply

Real brick definitely has its quirks, but I wouldn't write it off completely. I've worked on a few older homes where we managed to significantly improve insulation without losing the original brick charm. It takes some creativity (and yeah, extra budget), but the results can be pretty rewarding. Veneer is practical, sure, but there's something about the texture and depth of real brick that's hard to replicate... even with the best veneers out there.


Reply

Worked on a renovation last year - 1920s brick home, beautiful but drafty as heck. We ended up using internal insulation panels to keep the exterior brick untouched. It was definitely trickier (and pricier) than veneer, but the thermal performance improved dramatically without sacrificing aesthetics. Veneers have come a long way, sure, but real brick just ages differently... there's a depth and subtle variation that's tough to match. Guess it depends how much you're willing to compromise on authenticity vs. convenience.


Reply

Did a custom build recently where the client opted for real brick walls, insisting on authenticity. Beautiful result, but yeah, insulation was a headache - we ended up framing an inner stud wall with spray foam insulation behind drywall. Worked great, but definitely more labor-intensive (and costly) than veneer would have been. Veneers nowadays can look pretty convincing, but real brick just has that character you can't fully replicate. Depends if you're after the look alone or the whole package...


Reply

"Depends if you're after the look alone or the whole package..."

Exactly - are you planning to sell soon or hold onto the property long-term? Real brick definitely has character, but from a developer's standpoint, veneer often makes more sense financially and logistically. I've had buyers who couldn't even tell the difference until they touched it. Is that extra authenticity worth the added costs and headaches in your market? Something to consider before diving in...


Reply

Real brick has charm, sure, but honestly most folks I've built for end up happier with veneer. Less headaches down the road, easier maintenance...and your wallet will thank you later. Unless you're restoring some historic mansion, veneer usually wins out practically speaking.


Reply

"Less headaches down the road, easier maintenance...and your wallet will thank you later."

Agreed - practicality often tips the scales toward veneer. I've noticed clients appreciate the flexibility veneer offers, especially when it comes to interior design choices. With veneer, it's simpler to integrate insulation, wiring, or even adjust layouts down the line. Real brick can definitely limit your options and complicate future renovations...although, admittedly, nothing quite matches the authentic texture and depth real brick can add to a space. Still, from a purely practical standpoint, veneer usually makes more sense.


Reply

"Real brick can definitely limit your options and complicate future renovations..."

True, but let's not forget real brick's thermal mass benefits - great for passive solar designs. Veneer might be easier, but real brick can pay off in energy savings if planned right. Just something to consider...


Reply

Good points about thermal mass, but I've found real brick can sometimes trap moisture if not done carefully - had a friend who dealt with mold issues down the road. Have you considered how climate or humidity might affect your choice?


Reply

Yeah, moisture issues with brick can definitely be tricky. Had a similar experience myself a few years back - worked on a renovation project for an older home in a pretty humid area. The homeowner insisted on real brick walls for authenticity, and honestly, it looked fantastic at first. But after about two years, they started noticing some damp patches and that musty smell you just can't ignore.

Turns out the contractor hadn't properly accounted for drainage and ventilation behind the brickwork. Moisture was getting trapped between the brick and insulation layers, and mold started creeping in. Fixing it wasn't cheap or easy either - had to remove sections of brick, redo waterproofing membranes, and add proper weep holes to let moisture escape.

That said, I wouldn't completely write off real brick walls. When done right - with careful detailing, proper drainage planes, and good ventilation - they can perform really well even in humid climates. I've seen plenty of older buildings with original brickwork holding up beautifully because they were built thoughtfully from the start.

Brick veneer is definitely easier to manage moisture-wise since there's usually a clear gap behind it for airflow. But if you're set on real brick for aesthetic or thermal reasons, just make sure whoever's doing the work knows their stuff about moisture management. It's one of those things where cutting corners or overlooking details can really come back to bite you later...


Reply
Scroll to Top